HowtoCombinetheBestofWeb2.
0andaSemanticWeb:ExamplesfromRevyu.
comTomHeathandEnricoMottaKnowledgeMediaInstitute,TheOpenUniversity,UKt.
heath@open.
ac.
uk,e.
motta@open.
ac.
ukItisnotuncommontoviewWeb2.
0andtheSemanticWebasmutuallyexclusive,competingpathstotheWebofthefuture,eachadvocatedbyadistinctcommunity.
Wearguethatthetwoapproachesareinfactcomplementary,andthatbothfacechallengestheothercansolve,suchashowtointegrateWeb2.
0dataonaWebscale,andhowtoenableuserstocreatesemanticallyrichannotations.
HerewewilluseexamplesfromRevyu.
comtodemonstratehowfeaturesofWeb2.
0andtheSemanticWebcanbecombinedinasingleservicethatovercomesthesechallenges.
Revyu1isaWebsitewherepeoplecanreviewandrateanythingtheychoose.
ThesiteisbuiltonSemanticWebtechnologies,butalsousescommonfeaturesofWeb2.
0,suchaskeywordtagging.
Web2.
0providesanumbrellalabelformyriadapplicationsthatelicitandreuseuser-generatedcontent,supportsocialandcollaborativeinteractionontheWeb,andprovideengaginguserinteractionsbasedonAJAX.
TheSemanticWebvisionisoneofdatapublishedinmachine-readableformats,givenformalsemanticsthroughtheuseofsharedontologies,andinterlinkedonaWebscale.
BymakingWebdatamoreopentoprocessingbymachines,theSemanticWebfundamentallyaimstobringtangiblebenefitstousers.
Despitebothapproaches'revolutionarypotential,barriersexisttothisbeingfullyrealised.
Web2.
0applicationshaveelicitedvastamountsofuser-generatedcontent,suchaswikientries,taggedphotos,andlinksjoiningpeopleinsocialnetworks.
However,atpresent,mostsuchapplicationsrepresentwalleddatagardensfromwhichinformationcannotbeeasilysetfreeandcombinedwithothersources.
Thiscanleadtotheun-Web-likesituationwheremyfriendinOrkutisastrangeronMySpace.
Overcomingthisrequiresservicestopublishdatainformatseasilyprocessedbythirdparties.
TheSemanticWeboffersaplatformonwhichtodojustthis.
PublishingdatainRDFlowersthebarrierstoitsreusebyothers.
Twoapplicationsmaychoosetodescribetheirdatausingthesameschema,ortheymaynot.
Thisisimmaterial,providedmappingscanbedefinedbetweenthetwodatamodels.
However,usingelementsfromexistingontologiesdoessignificantlystreamlinethedataintegrationprocess.
KeytothepowerofRDFistheabilitywithinonedocumenttomixstatementsthatuseelementsfromanynumberofontologies,withoutthedocumentitselfneedingtovalidateagainstafixedschema.
Forexample,inadditiontoXHTML,RevyuexposesreviewsinRDFusingelementsfromtheReviewvocabulary2andtheFOAFontology3(fordescribingpeople).
AdoptingthesepopularontologiesmakeRevyu1http://revyu.
com2http://purl.
org/stuff/rev#3http://xmlns.
com/foaf/0.
1/datainstantlyinteroperablewiththatfromothersources.
CreatingaRevyu-specificontologythatwasthenmappedtootherswouldhavebeenanequallyvalid,albeitmorecomplexprocess.
Acknowledgingthatanysemanticsarebetterthannone,RevyualsoexposesreviewsusingthehReviewmicroformat4embeddedinXHTMLpages.
ServicesthatofferdataAPIs,suchasAmazonorFlickr,goalongwaytodismantlingthewallsofthedatagarden.
However,barrierstothereuseofthisdatastillexist.
Datastructuresmaybetrulynovel,requiringnewmappingsbetweeneveryadditionaldatasourcethatisintegrated.
Evenmorecritically,wherevanillaXMLisused,integratingdatafromdifferentsourcesmayinvolverewritingexistingschemasifnewinformationistobeincorporatedandrepublishedinthesamedocument.
RDFdoesnotsufferthesamelimitation,allowingstatementstobearbitrarilycombinedinonedocument,madeindifferentlocationsbutreferencingthesameidentifier,ormadeindifferentlocationsusingdifferentidentifiersbutstatingthatbothidentifiersrefertothesamething.
ThislastscenarioisnicelyillustratedbyRevyu'sRDFdescriptionsofreviewers.
NewURIsaremintedforeachreviewer,whomayalreadyhaveseveralothers.
WhereareviewermaintainstheirownRDFdescriptioninanotherlocation,thisisprocessedtoretrievetheiradditionalURIs.
StatementsarethenaddedtotheirRevyuRDF,statingthatallURIsidentifythesameperson.
Humanusersalsobenefit,asadditionalinformationaboutthereviewer(e.
g.
photosorhomepagelinks)canberetrievedfromexternalRDFfilesandusedtoenhancetheirprofilepage(asillustratedbelow),withoutitbeingduplicatedinRevyu.
WebServicesthatpublishvanillaXMLpresentapplicationdeveloperswiththeadditionalchallengeofparsingXMLtreestoretrievethedesireddata.
Whilstmostprogramminglanguagesmakethistasktrivial,dataprocessingremainstiedtotheunderlyingsyntacticratherthansemanticstructureofthedata.
CreatingWeb2.
0mashupsconsequentlyrequiresthewritingofcustomhandlerstointeractwitheachAPI.
Nocommonlanguageisavailableforqueryingandintegratingsuchdatasources.
Thisissuemustbeovercomeifmashupsaretobecreatedonatrulyflexible,Webscale.
TheSPARQLquerylanguagefortheSemanticWebenablesstandardisedaccesstodistributeddatasources.
4http://microformats.
org/wiki/hreviewSQL-likequeriescanbeexecutedasHTTPGETrequestsagainstremote"endpoints",returningdatathatcanbeprocessedusingstandardcode,irrespectiveoftheendpointsunderlyingimplementation.
DevelopersmustsimplyknowthestructureoftheRDFgraphbehindtheendpointinordertowritetheappropriatequery.
Revyuexposesreview,people,andtaggingdataviaitsSPARQLendpoint.
Atpresent,additionalinformationaboutbooksreviewedonRevyuisretrievedviatheAmazonWebServicesAPIanddisplayedtousersofthesite,asshowninthefigurebelow.
However,creationoftheRDFBookMashup5meansAmazon-specificcodewillshortlybereplacedbyasingleSPARQLquery.
UnderpinningsuchdataintegrationandWeb-scalemashupexercisesistheneedforwidespreadmintingofURIsidentifyingnon-Webresources,toenablelinkingofdatafromdisparatelocations.
Asforreviewers,URIsareassignedtoeveryitemreviewedonRevyu,thereviewitself,andalltagsused.
Consequently,manythingsintheofflineworldnowhaveURIsagainstwhichfurtherRDFstatementscanbemade,onRevyuorelsewhere.
ThingssuchasrestaurantsorpubsareunlikelytominttheirownURIsinthenearfuture.
ConsequentlyRevyuprovidesvaluableinfrastructureonwhichtobuildnextgenerationmashups.
RevyuURIscanallbedereferenced,respondingwithHTTP303redirects,accordingtotheW3CTAG'sfindingonthehttpRange-14issue6.
HavingdiscussedhowSemanticWebapproachesmayaddresschallengesfacingWeb2.
0,wewillnowexaminetheinverserelationship.
WearguethattheSemanticWebvisionfaceschallengesofequalsignificanceifitistoreachwidespreadadoption.
Inourviewthesearefocusedontwoissues:availabilityofdataandinteractiondesign.
Initiativessuchasdbpedia7arebootstrappingtheSemanticWebbyRDF-isingexistingdatasets.
However,instarkcontrasttotheconventionalWebandWeb2.
0,fewmechanismscurrentlyexistallowingnon-specialistuserstocontributetotheSemanticWeb.
EarlygrowthoftheWebiswidelyattributedtoindividualscreatingpersonalsitesbycopying/pastingHTMLcodeorusingvisualeditors.
SuchapproachesmaynotbeappropriatetoaSemanticWeb.
However,therearemanyWeb2.
0applicationsenablingregularuserstocontributecontentwithoutspecialistskills.
Withfewexceptions,similartoolsenablinggrassrootspublishingontheSemanticWebarenotcurrentlyavailable.
Revyuisoneexception.
ByadheringtothewellestablishedinteractionpatternofcompletingformsinaWebbrowser,RevyuallowsuserstocreatecontentthatisimmediatelyusableontheSemanticWeb.
ThisoccurswithoutanyuserknowledgeofRDF,ontologies,oreventheprinciplesoftheSemanticWeb.
Inourview,specific,focusedapplicationsthatguide5http://sites.
wiwiss.
fu-berlin.
de/suhl/bizer/bookmashup/6http://www.
w3.
org/2001/tag/issues.
html#httpRange-147http://dbpedia.
org/userinputthroughtheuseofformsrepresentthemostpromisingwaytoelicitsemanticannotationsfromregularWebusers.
Inaddition,Revyuliftstheburdenofclassifyingrevieweditemsaccordingtocomplex,existing,orrelativelyfixedtaxonomies,throughtheuseofkeywordtagging.
Thiscreatesgreaterflexibilityinwhatcanbereviewed,andweargue,lowersthebarriertocontributionofreviews.
Alessdesirableconsequenceofthisfeatureisthatmachine-readablestatementsregardingthenatureofrevieweditemscannotbemadewithanyconfidence.
Furtherinvestigationisrequiredastohowthismaybeachieved.
Assumingthatsufficientdatacanbeproduced,theSemanticWebfacesafurtherchallenge:creatinginterfacesallowingnon-specialistuserstoexploitit.
Humanshavethousandsofyearsofexperiencecreatingandusingtextualdocuments,anddecadesofexperiencewithhypertextsystems.
TheSemanticWebisnotconstrainedtothenotionofadocumentinthesamewayastheconventionalWebofHTMLpages.
Thequestionremainsofhowwedesigncompelling,coherent,andusableinteractionsbasedondatafrommultiplesources,insuchawaythatitssource,trustworthiness,andvaluecanbedetermined.
Map-basedWeb2.
0mashupsprovidesomecluesinthisdirection,bypresentingalternativevisualisationsforcomplexdatasets.
HowsuchapproachesmayscaleonaWebofinfinitelyinterlinkeddataisnotclearatpresent.
ThisremainsanopenandpressingresearchquestionfortheWebcommunity.
Conclusions:ThispaperhassoughttohighlightdistinctchallengesfacingtheWeb2.
0andSemanticWebcommunities,identifypotentialsolutionseachcommunitymayoffertheother,andillustratewithexamplesfromRevyuhowthesemayberealised.
Inconclusionwemakethefollowingrecommendationstoeachcommunity.
Firstly,thattheWeb2.
0community:givesseriousconsiderationtopublishingdatainformsthataremoreeasilyreusable,suchasRDF;investigatestheuseofSPARQLforremotedataaccessratherthancustomAPIs;andmintsURIsforofflineitemsthataredistinctfromtheURIsofdocumentsdescribingthem.
Secondly,wearguethattheSemanticWebcommunitymustgiveurgentattentiontocreatinginterfacesallowingregularWebuserstocontributetotheSemanticWeb.
ThisshouldnottaketheformofmoreusableeditorsforontologiesorRDFinstancedata(whilstthesewouldundoubtedlybeuseful),butseektoexploitfamiliarinteractionpatterns.
Revyu'sform-basedapproachisnodoubtjustoneofmanyoptions.
Intandem,significanteffortmustbegiventodevelopingcompellinginterfacesabletodisplaystructured,linkeddatafromacrosstheWeb.
Mashupshavesetthestandardforsuchinterfacesandinteractions.
ThenextgenerationmustdemonstratetheuniquebenefitsofaWebofinterlinkeddata.
Lastly,whilstacknowledgingthatwehavemadedistinctionsofthisnaturehere,wesuggestthatviewingWeb2.
0andSemanticWebapproachesasmutuallyexclusiveisdetrimentaltoallthoseinvolved,andtothedevelopmentoftheWebasawhole.
totyun,新公司,主要运作香港vps、日本vps业务,接入cn2网络,不限制流量!VPS基于KVM虚拟,采用系统盘和数据盘分离,从4G内存开始支持Windows系统...大家注意下,网络分“Premium China”、“Global”,由于站长尚未测试,所以也还不清楚情况,有喜欢吃螃蟹的尝试过不妨告诉下站长。官方网站:https://totyun.com一次性5折优惠码:X4QTYVNB3P...
酷锐云是一家2019年开业的国人主机商家,商家为企业运营,主要销售主VPS服务器,提供挂机宝和云服务器,机房有美国CERA、中国香港安畅和电信,CERA为CN2 GIA线路,提供单机10G+天机盾防御,提供美国原生IP,支持媒体流解锁,商家的套餐价格非常美丽,CERA机房月付20元起,香港安畅机房10M带宽月付25元,有需要的朋友可以入手试试。酷锐云自开业以来一直有着良好的产品稳定性及服务态度,支...
搬瓦工最近新增了荷兰机房中国联通(AS9929、AS4837)线路的VPS产品,选项为NL - China Unicom Amsterdam(ENUL_9),与日本软银和洛杉矶(DC06)CN2 GIA配置一致可以互换,属于高端系列,2.5Gbps-10Gbps大带宽,最低季付46.7美元起。搬瓦工VPS隶属于老牌IT7公司旗下,主要提供基于KVM架构VPS主机,数据中心包括美国洛杉矶、凤凰城、纽...
m.yushuwu.com为你推荐
著作权登记为什么要申请著作权登记京沪高铁上市首秀京沪高铁将有哪些看点?摩根币摩根币是什么意思?对对塔今儿老师给推荐了一个叫对对塔的学习网站,看起来挺不错的,有用过的人吗?管不管用?哪些功能比较好啊?广东GDP破10万亿在已披露的2017年GDP经济数据中,以下哪个省份GDP总量排名第一?18comic.fun有什么好玩的网站比肩工场大运比肩主事,运行长生地是什么意思?www.55125.cn如何登录www.jbjy.cnip在线查询通过对方的IP地址怎么样找到他的详细地址?抓站工具一起来捉妖神行抓妖辅助工具都有哪些?
域名投资 代理域名备案 域名备案中心 如何注册中文域名 uk2 搜狗抢票助手 魔兽世界台湾服务器 我爱水煮鱼 web服务器架设 刀片服务器是什么 域名转接 169邮箱 cdn加速原理 网络空间租赁 七夕快乐英语 独享主机 可外链的相册 空间申请 江苏徐州移动 rewritecond 更多