onerousrrqqq.com
rrqqq.com 时间:2021-04-08 阅读:()
Mr.
StevenAftergoodINSPECTORGENERALDEPARTMENTOFDEFENSE4800MARKCENTERDRIVEALEXANDRIA,VIRGINIA22350-1500MAR042015FederationofAmericanScientists1725DeSalesStreetNW,Suite600Washington,DC20036DearMr.
Aftergood:Ref:FOIA-2015-00487ThisisinresponsetoyourMarch30,2015,FreedomofInformationAct(FOIA)requestforacopyofDODIG-2015-097,EvaluationofDoDUseofUnmannedAircraftSystems(UAS)forSupporttoCivilAuthorities.
WereceivedyourrequestonMarch30,2015,andassigneditcasenumberFOIA-2015-00487.
TheOfficeoftheDeputyInspectorGeneralforIntelligenceandSpecialProgramAssessmentsconductedasearchandlocatedtheencloseddocuments.
Ideterminedthatsomeredactedportionsoftherecordsareexemptfromreleasepursuantto5U.
S.
C.
§552(b)(6),whichpe1iainstoinformation,thereleaseofwhichwouldconstituteaclearlyunwarrantedinvasionofpersonalprivacy.
Mr.
Pa\llR.
Polk,InitialDenialAuthorityfortheNationalGeospatial-Intelligence.
Agency,determinedthatsomeredactedp01iionsareexemptfi·omreleasepursuantto5U.
S.
C.
§552(b)(3),whichpertainstonondisclosureprovisionscontainedinotherFederalstatutes.
Inthiscase,theFederalstatutewhichpreventsdisclosureis50U.
S.
C.
§3142,whichexemptsfromdisclosureoperationalfilesoftheNationalGeospatial-IntelligenceAgency.
ColonelChristianRofrano,ChiefCounselattheNationalGuardBureau,determinedthatsomeredactedp01iionsofthedocumentareexemptfromreleasepursuantto5U.
S.
C.
§552(b)(7)(E),whichpetiainstorecordsorinformationthatwouldrevealtechniquesandproceduresforlawenforcementinvestigationsorprosecutionsorthatwoulddiscloseguidelinesforlawenforcementinvestigationsorprosecutionsifdisclosureoftheinformationcouldreasonablybeexpectedtoriskcircumventionofthelaw.
Inviewoftheabove,youmayconsiderthistobeanadversedeterminationthatmaybeappealedtotheDepartmentofDefense,OfficeoflnspectorGeneral,ATTN:FOIAAppellateAuthority,Suite1OB24,4800MarkCenterDrive,Alexandria,VA22350-1500.
Yourappeal,ifany,mustbepostmarkedwithin30daysofthedateofthisletterandshouldreferencethefilenumberabove.
Irecommendthatyourappealanditsenvelopebothbearthenotation"FreedomofInformationActAppeal.
"Sincerely,MarkDorganActingDivisionChiefFOIA,PrivacyandCivilLibertiesOfficeINTEGRITY*EFFICIENCY*ACCOUNTABILITY*EXCEllENCEMi~~ionOurmissionistoprovideIndependent,relevant,amitimelyovcrsi[JhtoftheDepc;rtmentofDe[ensetlw(support$theWarf!
ghter;promotesaccountclbtlit,y,integrity,amJeffidency;.
advisestheSecretmyofDefenseandCon,qress;andInformstilepublic.
Vi~ionOurvisionistobeamodeloversightorgcmtzatlonintlwFederalGovemmentbyJeaclingchange,speCikingtruth,andprO/notingeXcCllence-adiwrseorganizationworkit~,qtogetherasorwprofessionalteam,ri!
co,(Jnlzedasleadl!
t~~lwourfield.
F!
ll'moreinflll'llHJ\IonaboutwhlstlcQiowerprotec.
Uon,pleasese.
etheinsidebad(cpvet:FOROFFICI/'J.
LUSEONLY0JlObjective(!
l)purobjcctiv~wast6de~e.
~mh\~Whether.
·I.
Jh~liotici.
Ptoce.
dyr~~fo.
r~singl)ol)UAs.
~.
!
l~lt"w~essi9!
J.
~lljliOJ~tlon.
an.
~~i$~~mlratloJi·att~vitie$compl)'·witl)·ap~I!
CPerati.
n~\l(l~st!
)Idus!
lta.
r,y;h!
!
et1!
eyundemamttbeAm!
ific:l\r!
I>Ublic'sll'l!
itlliiate~oMetnlrab9\itc!
0llibettles.
an\lprivacyn~htS,theydotlqt.
o~.
er.
it.
e.
ww~anyqtlferentlyfrl'liJ)tnarinedplatf(lr~)Yitllslmllarcapabilities.
(U)Recommendations(FBHB)WerecommendthatUSD(P)establisha.
stm\dardizedformalapprovalprocessforUASsupporttodomesticcivilauthorities.
(F9\J9jWerecommendthatUSD(P)addr·esstheconcernsofMilitarySeJvice/NationalGuardBureauUASexpertsthatpolicyambiguityispotentiallydegradingUAStrainingandoperaUonalreadiness,(FBIJBjWealsorecommendthattheUSD(P)fo1'mallychartertheDomesticImageryWorkingGroup.
(U)ManagementCommentsandOurResponse(U)TheAssistantSecretaryofDefenseforPolicy,HomelandDefense&GlobalSecurityconcurredwithourrecommendations,andnofurthercommentsarerequired.
PleaseseetheRecommendationsTableonthenextpage.
FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFOROFFICIALUSEONlrYRecommendationsTable''t\11ReC!
lmmenaatmns''NoAdditional','anagemt!
ntlRIA.
VIRGINIA22350-150(}MEMORANDUMFORSECRBTARYOFDEI'ENSBUNDERSECRETARYOFDEFENSEFORPOLICYMarch20,2015SUBJECT:(UJllvaluationofDoD'sUscofUnmannedAircraftSystemsforSupporttoCivilAuthorities(ReportNo.
DODIG·2015·097)(U)ThoOoputyIG.
IntelligenceandSpecialProgramAssessments(ISPA)Isprovidingthisreportforyourinformationanduse.
(U)Weconsideredmanagementcommentsonadraftofthisreportwhenpreparingthofinalreport.
CommentsfromtheOfficeofAssistantSecretaryofOefenseforPolicy,HomelandDofenso&GlobalSocurityworeresponsiveforallrecommendations.
(U)Weappreciatethecourtesiese~tendedtothestaff.
Pleasedirectques~omton.
eat(703)699--DSN664Jiiao.
t(703)699-J>SN499-PQROFPIGIAbYSBQNbPOROFPICil'.
l,USBONL-YContents(U)Introduction(U)ObJecdve.
1(U)Background1(U)ScopeandMethodology2(U)Finding3(l'900}DoDIsFullyCompliantwithLaws,Regulations,andNationalPoliciesforUASSupporttoCivilAuthorlttes.
N,N,3(UJStatutotYEnvlt·otunentforUmploymontoflloDUASInDomesticOperations.
3(U)OfficeoftheSecretatYofDefenseUnmannedAircraftSystemPolicyandGuidance.
(U)MilitaryServiceandNationalGuardBureauImplementationandExecutionofDoDUASPolicy.
2(U)DoDUASSupporttoCivilAuthoritlosEvonts.
3(l'900}DoDDoesNotHaveaStandardizedApprovalProcessforUASSupporttoDomesticCivilAuthorities.
4(l'900}SetviceandNationalGuardUASExperts~i(U)ScopeandMethodology(U)TheevaluationwasconductedinaccordancewithQualityStandardsforInspectionandEvaluationissuedbytheCounciloftheInspectorsGeneralonIntegrityandEfficiency.
Thosestandardsrequirethatweplanandperformtheevaluationtoobtainsufficient,appropriateevidencetoprovideareasonablebasisforourfindingsandconclusionshasedonourevaluationobjectives.
(U)OurevaluationincludedareviewofFederalStatutes,DoDpolicyanddirectives,ChairmanoftheJointChiefsofStaffInstructions,Servicepolicyanddirectives,andNationalGuardBureau(NGB)policyanddirectives,WealsoconductedInterviewswithpersonnelfromacrosstheDepartmentresponsibleforpoliciesandproceduresfortheconductofUASoperations{SeetheAppendix).
2TheUSAFusesthetermRemotelyPilotedAircraftInsteadofUAS.
~"ProtectingSecurityandPrivacy~AnAno.
fyticalFrameworkforAirborneDomesticlmagery/1ColonelDaWnM.
K.
loldl,USAF;USAFLawftevtew1Vol70FOROFFICIALUSEONI:rYbJ{c~purtNn.
DOHHtEFapproval.
Sincetherequestwasforincidentawarenessandassessmentduringtheentirefireseason,theunitchosenottopursueblanketapprovalbecauseofwhattheyfeltwasanonerousapprovalprocess.
(POliO)AnotherexamplewasprovidedbytheArmyandAirNationalGuard.
Inthiscase,aDSCAexercisewasproposedtoNGB(b)(7}(E)3ProperUseMemorandum:amemorandumsignedannuallybyanorganltatlon'scertifyinggovernmentoffleialthatdefu,estheorganbatlonsdomestlcImageryrequirementsandIntendedosc.
ItalsocontainsaproperusestatementacknowledgingawarenessofthelegalandpolicyrestrictionsregardingdomesticImagery,AF114-104,23Apr2012FOROFFICIAbI:JSBm!
bHtiporlNo,IHJDH.
i-20I1i.
fJIJ7]GFOROFFICIAbUSBONbY(~'Q!
JQ~WewerealsotoldaboutaDSCAtrainingexercisewiththeDepartmentofEnergyusingaU.
S.
AirForceremotelypilotedaircraftthatwasconductedwithoutformalSECDEFapproval.
ThisexercisewasforincidentawarenessandassessmentsupportofasimulatedhazardousmaterialreleaseonDepartmentofEnergyproperty.
ThetrainingmetalloftheInternalServiceguidelinesandwasforwardedforapproval.
However,sincetheexercisewasconductedwithinDoDrestrictedairspace,theJointStaffdeterminedthatapprovalwasnotrequired.
OurintervieweesexplainedthatthisleftthemconfusedaboutjustwhentheOSDpolicyrequiringSECDEFapprovalofUASsupportforDSCAapplied.
(FQ!
JQ~Finally,aU.
S.
MarineCorpUASunittoldusthatonceeachmonththeirwinghostsacommunityleadershipprogramwherelocalpoliticiansareinvitedtoviewandlearnaboutthecapabilitiesofthevariousaircraftonbase.
Duringonesuchevent,alocalmayorrequestedUASsupporttolookforpotholesInthearea.
Whiletheunitconcededthatthistypeofoperationcouldproviderealistictrainingfortheirpilotsandsensoroperators,localcommandersdeterminedthatundertheinterimguidance,requestingSECDEPapprovaltoconductaUASmissionofthistypedidnotmakeoperationalsense.
(U)ImpactofDoDUASPolicyonProcessing,Exploitation,andDisseminationforDSCA(JlQYQ)AlongwithinterviewingvariousunitsoperatingUASs,wealsointerviewedorganizationsresponsibleforperformingthePEDofUAScollecteddata.
WemetwithNationalGeaspatiallntelligenceAgency(NGA)personnelresponsibleforensuringthatNGAandotherDefenseIntelligenceComponentscomplywjththedomesticcollectionoftacticalimageryconsistentwithDoD5240.
1-R.
WhileNGAdoesnotoperateUASstheydoprovidePEDsupporttoDoDDSCAandotherFederalagencyUASoperationswithintheUnitedStates.
NGA(b)(})'0USC§Jl42NGA(b)Olsouse§3142FOROFPICIAbUSBmlbYFSRSFFIGIAbHSES~H:rYFindlng,'GA(b)(3)'iOUSC§~1.
i:UAI)GNWAfHllHGYON,bCiUOMOUh~\Jr.
Ut)'17,2015MEMOHANIJLiMfORSH:R.
f.
lARW.
SOFT1Jf!
Mlll'fAJlYDEIARTh.
t\!
NtSCHAIRMANOFTHEJOINTCltiEfSOFSTAfftiNl>PtSECR~-I'ARYOFDEf""ENSEFORACQUlMliON.
TIWHfi.
'OLOOV,ANULOOL'i.
TICSUNDEl\SJ:CRETARYOFDEFENS[FORPOUCYUNOfJt!
Sf,(;H.
I:;TARYOFUf.
H::NSEFORPERSONNELANIJ1ti":AOIN)~SSUNDUtsrRtTARVOFOEICNSEFORINTELLIG!
iNCI:COMMANDI'R,U.
S.
NORTI!
UlNCOMMANDCOMMANOliR,IJ.
S.
PAnnccO~iMANDClllm·,NA110NAIGIIART>llUIr~1-:CRF!
'AR\'OJ.
'IJr:ft~St':fORU:OIStATJVl:'AFFAIRSDP.
PARTMtNl'Ofllri'HNSECIIIWINI'OitMA'riONOHict'RASSISTMITTOnm·sr;crurrAR\'OFUfTl!
NSt.
FORPUHLKAfFAIRSSF.
NIOllINTEI.
I.
IG~NCflOVJ:RSIGHTOl'FI('~I\SIJBJEN:PolityMemorandwnIS-002,''('mldmccrorlh~DomtllicUscofUnmmntd1\ln:n\1\S)!
h.
owy17,2018POI'Nl'OFCONTACT;&1ormo"'lnrumwtlon,~ntco;tflASil(HD&OS)al(571)2S61Ji11Uspo11o)'tnemonhdumprovfdosBuldat\coforlhodomt;Stlcuscofuruno.
nncdAlrm.
l\a)'$mJ'(lfAS)wtruwo,thotcporlfn.
:nt"r~r~ru~o@oi.
))OASarourwIn~~withU.
S.
bw111dDoDpolky,Mdtoomlurctltq!
PJI>Pfl""1110ofDoDUAS"""Indom.
.
llofJIWIIlh'lru,trainlntntttbet.
Mdwnlng.
DoDdomedlctvlatiQnOJ~rlimu~uppottUomtluidlkfciiM::(HDl.
O~femcSupportofCivilAuthorities(DSCA)1andmiliW)'ltalnlngandrxt:n:lstl.
llnlw;a5p0eific.
allyl'f'O\idedfcrlnihbpolk:y,law,orotbcrgufd!
\JI!
;(',th~&pprovdofdw8"rdttt)'ofPcfm~WIs~equimlforalldommlcliASofl'I'IIM>(lnCiudlngDoDUASopcUiantt!
onP.
S.
~t,lrcdhc5~00.
271aude:ppl~ingthe('vtolghtguldanrecootalr.
tdinl>oD$240,1-R"IOiutclligcncilandnon·lntel!
igtncc.
.
.
:lalcddomutlcUAS_u~,allUASatqubhitll'l,.
'~llJ.
tl'N'Nprlatueln:uml!
lt.
no:n,UhSm)'~llUdlolieuol'munnNnircMtl(~>rd()mC!
>"tlcmtult:IM.
AnmJrritttthturn~m.
o:yineluddwttcn:&ll$tt&lnedtndurat1Q.
l~n~J1>~MO~qu!
rl!
'd;UMW'.
neda!
rmftpmvid~uptrlt'tcapabilll.
!
rs;orpt1)"il'!
'lll11ftftWW:ttltt:linlitatioMJWi'>hll!
itthousc,lfm411ordtolaty·orthcd:·Win~11lroran.
uouIJASIn!
heUnlud5tl~tJIJUI)'oo1y~wedfrrrno,DSCA,ondN:OHla!
t"'rPPon,pmfitm~,lnefudlngopemtlnnklSUPfWlrlttemntl,~taiL',J~al,llttdtribalgtWeMini!
DtorganltAaon,lf'l't>""'m0\~t(ftlt11Set;"t.
!
l.
at}ofl)tfe~:hmayt'OOSiderDoDUASan_rlo)11lC'nlinthtlrplanningfordim!
ltl.
':fft'J;fl'"tt!
Wnctivlllc-~.
t:PoDUASnt~ctiJoJurponofStRII)dhadetNaponsc'hou!
Jiubmlrnl'omudrcquntlb\\lilinslothOc&:creta')'ori)(fcnl.
tSw:hTAttJCMsshldcoJ\tltlntheannly.
shtf)ridnctcdtb11t!
f~mnlnetllbBtuthcrmann.
r.
d11!
r~'"we~n~flJl)'n>Pf(lll~.
1l1CClutlnnnnoftheJointChief~ofSII)ff,Int.
flf)UASln.
$ll(li'OitcfaStaiC-fNUUt!
.
Plon!
!
ihoutdfllCtorIntOOr.
~ure.
'mtimen-qulrOO(('ItFAAe·MbgemenlAgtncy·toordlnatcdrc@ouotlplanning,&n)'StateChitprop~th~'*"ofPoDUASinlUil'lanttt,vuldco.
-.
nwllwithrb~wm:\pc_ndlnaeca&rJrhlcComblltSIJtCnmt11itrldcrtoCl151110thatStflii:andDDlrettiu~lOlS-.
18,''OcftiJ~eS\~lf'\lr1otCMIAutlmrhir.
~.
''TheprimM)'pi!
IJXlSOofdomc:rtiellAStraining1\fldexercisesisforP:oDfon.
'Cbto~:oodul.
\1ren.
lj~tlctrainingIntheircorel'~(.
'fafmilllttr)'!
11!
~9h:ihIU't4J,DoDUASusedh1tfainlngnudex~:rd~wlllnot.
c.
qul~or('(lfl~tinf,-,mu:tion(e-t;ceptfor~nci!
kntalcotlettlon)about"{'"ifiiltU,S,~n~orOOtl·DOf)'ontroUcdpr9pcrtyfirfaciiiUcsI~X.
t'llednutsldoDoD·Jnlrolh:dln~mlllltionswitlli'Utamscot.
AllUASl\l:qJllsitinn,roue~liOf1tr&nlk!
n,anddliStm~hmtJflnrorm:~ltonwillb(finlltC(Irdmcewhhstnodln;.
;Dollhl:B\ll~timuMdpolicy,includingl,)(lu(.
'nmponentlnielll~neeol'tufg:btguld.
wre,andwillttqulreo!
JtJM.
UscurDoDOASWtl$JndQili\.
'J>IIclmln!
li$-.
tdtJ:X~(('iS-e!
lnVJUltn:l11iutnotlfl{:ftlfnnto1J10SercLUyof'Ocf'en~~lftl10plntftmnill!
llilriJ"IlOoDUAS1an4bto~used1ntNIInlnl!
JUdtl:rtefcnwrcqolrcdbythisdionwillbesttbmittedtotho5tW~YntIC8113~dQ.
y&prl-by-ccon~ultwiththeFAAf~r~~"tutil~neecmtynlnp11;:#f!
ndtotJbtttlnS~elllf)'"rUc:kun~IIJlPfO\'ol.
Stotcslnwhlt:hDoDUASa1:ittsuofleWcdlhatha\'c~V~tUircmtnlfertheirusointheset.
"te:bf:s(ortrnJnlngn:qutrtng11ppr0vn.
lbytheSIttoryofOeren~)\l.
i_ll$tlbtnlttheUovcrnor'fRq~tlnwOtlngattcu30dayr;inadu.
ncetotheSa:r&l'}'ofDchmethroughnppn1pria.
1~MilitAryOcromncnfiS~·In",(\J~IIbt!
tllntlOmmaod.
orNOllchal!
ndsvW.
thtJointSta.
fT(J~;J),andf!
1a)'shbJUilsuchu:qut~rllthmt11Jth~NAS,MwellasIn11gg~55ivcly(levt:loplogddedund&W'+idtcchnotog:.
·toori!
IUJ'(IMf~fol"(:fiJtlonofUASinon~c:gragat'edalri:poc~TheChAirorthe~D~\'~lie)'lJo;udonF_edmtAvb.
tia110'8FAlwllllc.
ldtheDepmmcnt'seffotUII>advi,'UtoforUtec_tlmln4t10!
1ofunnf(t1UtyI'C'guiR!
OI)'l'C$trictlon$thatpreventrauiloo\\I:mowthedevelapmentortcCtmo1uglc9,_!
trutdAn.
11:!
!
~opcraUusvrocWu!
Utandpoll~l'"thatensure~tUQOU~8~ll.
'lilhtotonpcratcs~tfc1ywllhlnthentJtonalain~whileMillObftlanclttgandrrotcdingptrJOI'!
I'Itprlvi!
Cly,fhhcrQtmlgnModl\sl3pomlhll!
!
le!
jUntl.
!
rSe~.
·r.
taryofDt.
{fmll/orP~llayTher;ndu:i~RiatyufOcfe-psefurPolit)'1U~D(P))bIIU11wri~cdco~:abllsbthoapprorrimefiOlltyfordomes1ieU$CcrUASforforceprot~~lonlndprotcclll'inofolhcrDoD8$$&,whetherIn_DoDlnstroction2000,16,"DoDU'ASdome.
ttleoprrallon\ThisguhhMtreplaceandM'lnd$th~Ot,'JIIIIY~r.
:le1111}'11rDeftnsc:Men10rJlldttm,"fntc1mOl.
lldftnceforlheDomt'$11CIJ~otnfllnrnrmm"dAircraftSy~tem~.
''""''"'""21,2006:~fi6R8Pf'le!
AbHSB8HbHepnrlNo.
JH)OH.
i-tOt:i·Wr/jl(,FOROFFICIALUSEONINAppendixesAppendixes(U)DoDOfficesVisited(U)UnderSecretaryofDefenseforPolicyrepresentativesfromHomelandDefense&America'sSecurityAffairs.
(U)UnderSecretaryofDefenseforIntelligencerepresentativesfromWarflghterSupport.
(U)AssistanttotheSecretaryofDefenseforIntelligenceOversightrepresentatives.
(U)USNORTHCOMDirectorsfromtheOperations,Plans,Intelligence,andJudgeAdvocateGeneralDirectorates.
(U)NationalGeospatialAgency(NGA)representatives.
(U)NationalSecurityAgency(NSA)representatives.
(U)HeadquartersNationalGuardBureauPolicy,Operations,andIntelligenceDirectors.
(U)Headquartersu.
s.
Army,U.
S.
Navy,U.
S.
MarineCorps,andU.
S.
AirForcePolicy,Operations,andIntelligenceDirectors.
(U)U.
S.
Army,U.
S.
Navy,U.
S.
MarineCorps,andU.
S.
AirForceCommandsresponsibleforServiceUASemploymentpolicies,tactics,techniques,andprocedures.
(U)U.
S.
Army,U.
S.
Navy,U.
S.
MarineCorps,andU.
S.
AirForceCommandsresponsibleforServicePEDpolicies,tactics,techniques,andprocedures.
FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFOROFFJC!
Abl:JSEONI:NAppondixos(U)Unit'sVisitedandLocation1stAirForceTyndallAFB,FloridaSecondMarineAircraftWing(2dMAW)MCASCherryPoint,NorthCarolina480thISRWing(ISRW)langleyAFB,Virginia27thIntelligenceSquadron(2715)langleyAFB,VirginiaCaliforniaNationalGuardJFHQSacramento,CaliforniaAirNationalGuard181stIntelligenceWingTerreHaute,IndianaAirNationalGuard174AttackWingSyracuse,NewYorkArmy15thMilitaryIntelligenceBattalionFortHood,Texas1StCAV-GreyEaglesFortHood,Texas9''ReconnaissanceWingBealeAFB,California491'FighterWingHollomanAFB,NewMexicoJTF-NorthFtBliss,Texas2-13'hAviationRegimentFtHuachuca,ArizonaCommanderNavalAirForcesNASCoronado,CaliforniaU.
S.
NORTHCOMColoradoSprings,ColoradoNAVAIRPatuxentRiverNAS,MarvlandVMU-2MCASCherryPoint,NorthCarolina(U)UseofComputer-ProcessedData(U)Wedidnotusecomputer-processeddatatoperformthisevaluation.
(U)PriorCoverage(U)NopriorcoveragehasbeenconductedonDoD'sdomesticuseofUASforcivilauthoritiesduringthelast5years.
FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFOROFFICIALUSEONLY/\cronyrnsandf\tlhreviations(U)AcronymsandAbbreviationsCOCOMCombatantCommandDCGSDistributedCommonGroundSystemDIWGDomesticImageryWorkingGroupDoDDepartmentofDefenseDSCADefenseSupporttoCivilAuthoritiesISRIntelligence,surveillance,andReconnaissanceNGANationalGeospatlalAgencyNGBNationalGuardBureauOSDOfficeoftheSecretaryofDefensePEDProcessing,Exploitation,andDisseminationPUMProperUseMemorandumRPARemotelyPilotedAircraftSECDEFSecretaryofDefenseUASUnmannedAircraftSystemUSNORTHCOMUnitedStalesNorthernCommandFOROFFIC!
t.
LUSEONI:NFOROFFICIALUSEONLYWbistleblowerProtectionU.
S.
DEPARTMENTOFDEFENSE11111Whlsl/eb/owel'ProtectionlinlwncementActof2012reqrtiresthelnspecwrGencmltodesignateaWhistleblowerProtection.
Omb.
11(/smantoeducateogmn:J'cmplt~Yeesaboutpi'Ohibitlonsonre/(1/iatlon,amiri,ghtsandremediesagainstreta/lutionj'orprotccll!
clc/isdo.
~rw~:s.
1/wdesignatedm1ibudsmanist/111Do/)1/ot/ineDirec/01:Formoreitlj(mnol/011onyourri,qhtsandJ'l!
mediesagainstrewllat(lm,visitwwll'.
clod/g.
nJII/t't'Of)l'iltns/wl!
istlciJ/ower.
Formoteinformationaboutl>oDIGreport~oractivities,plea~econtactus:CongressloiialLiaisoncongressionill@dodlg.
mil;703.
604.
8324MediaConta~tpublic.
affahs@dodis.
mil;703.
604o8324MonthlyUp1late!
lodlgconnect-request@listserve.
wmReJ!
OrtsMaHlngListdodig_report@listserve.
comTwittertwitter.
com/DoD_IGDoDHotlinedodlg.
mil/hotlineFOROFPICIALUSEONLY
StevenAftergoodINSPECTORGENERALDEPARTMENTOFDEFENSE4800MARKCENTERDRIVEALEXANDRIA,VIRGINIA22350-1500MAR042015FederationofAmericanScientists1725DeSalesStreetNW,Suite600Washington,DC20036DearMr.
Aftergood:Ref:FOIA-2015-00487ThisisinresponsetoyourMarch30,2015,FreedomofInformationAct(FOIA)requestforacopyofDODIG-2015-097,EvaluationofDoDUseofUnmannedAircraftSystems(UAS)forSupporttoCivilAuthorities.
WereceivedyourrequestonMarch30,2015,andassigneditcasenumberFOIA-2015-00487.
TheOfficeoftheDeputyInspectorGeneralforIntelligenceandSpecialProgramAssessmentsconductedasearchandlocatedtheencloseddocuments.
Ideterminedthatsomeredactedportionsoftherecordsareexemptfromreleasepursuantto5U.
S.
C.
§552(b)(6),whichpe1iainstoinformation,thereleaseofwhichwouldconstituteaclearlyunwarrantedinvasionofpersonalprivacy.
Mr.
Pa\llR.
Polk,InitialDenialAuthorityfortheNationalGeospatial-Intelligence.
Agency,determinedthatsomeredactedp01iionsareexemptfi·omreleasepursuantto5U.
S.
C.
§552(b)(3),whichpertainstonondisclosureprovisionscontainedinotherFederalstatutes.
Inthiscase,theFederalstatutewhichpreventsdisclosureis50U.
S.
C.
§3142,whichexemptsfromdisclosureoperationalfilesoftheNationalGeospatial-IntelligenceAgency.
ColonelChristianRofrano,ChiefCounselattheNationalGuardBureau,determinedthatsomeredactedp01iionsofthedocumentareexemptfromreleasepursuantto5U.
S.
C.
§552(b)(7)(E),whichpetiainstorecordsorinformationthatwouldrevealtechniquesandproceduresforlawenforcementinvestigationsorprosecutionsorthatwoulddiscloseguidelinesforlawenforcementinvestigationsorprosecutionsifdisclosureoftheinformationcouldreasonablybeexpectedtoriskcircumventionofthelaw.
Inviewoftheabove,youmayconsiderthistobeanadversedeterminationthatmaybeappealedtotheDepartmentofDefense,OfficeoflnspectorGeneral,ATTN:FOIAAppellateAuthority,Suite1OB24,4800MarkCenterDrive,Alexandria,VA22350-1500.
Yourappeal,ifany,mustbepostmarkedwithin30daysofthedateofthisletterandshouldreferencethefilenumberabove.
Irecommendthatyourappealanditsenvelopebothbearthenotation"FreedomofInformationActAppeal.
"Sincerely,MarkDorganActingDivisionChiefFOIA,PrivacyandCivilLibertiesOfficeINTEGRITY*EFFICIENCY*ACCOUNTABILITY*EXCEllENCEMi~~ionOurmissionistoprovideIndependent,relevant,amitimelyovcrsi[JhtoftheDepc;rtmentofDe[ensetlw(support$theWarf!
ghter;promotesaccountclbtlit,y,integrity,amJeffidency;.
advisestheSecretmyofDefenseandCon,qress;andInformstilepublic.
Vi~ionOurvisionistobeamodeloversightorgcmtzatlonintlwFederalGovemmentbyJeaclingchange,speCikingtruth,andprO/notingeXcCllence-adiwrseorganizationworkit~,qtogetherasorwprofessionalteam,ri!
co,(Jnlzedasleadl!
t~~lwourfield.
F!
ll'moreinflll'llHJ\IonaboutwhlstlcQiowerprotec.
Uon,pleasese.
etheinsidebad(cpvet:FOROFFICI/'J.
LUSEONLY0JlObjective(!
l)purobjcctiv~wast6de~e.
~mh\~Whether.
·I.
Jh~liotici.
Ptoce.
dyr~~fo.
r~singl)ol)UAs.
~.
!
l~lt"w~essi9!
J.
~lljliOJ~tlon.
an.
~~i$~~mlratloJi·att~vitie$compl)'·witl)·ap~I!
CPerati.
n~\l(l~st!
)Idus!
lta.
r,y;h!
!
et1!
eyundemamttbeAm!
ific:l\r!
I>Ublic'sll'l!
itlliiate~oMetnlrab9\itc!
0llibettles.
an\lprivacyn~htS,theydotlqt.
o~.
er.
it.
e.
ww~anyqtlferentlyfrl'liJ)tnarinedplatf(lr~)Yitllslmllarcapabilities.
(U)Recommendations(FBHB)WerecommendthatUSD(P)establisha.
stm\dardizedformalapprovalprocessforUASsupporttodomesticcivilauthorities.
(F9\J9jWerecommendthatUSD(P)addr·esstheconcernsofMilitarySeJvice/NationalGuardBureauUASexpertsthatpolicyambiguityispotentiallydegradingUAStrainingandoperaUonalreadiness,(FBIJBjWealsorecommendthattheUSD(P)fo1'mallychartertheDomesticImageryWorkingGroup.
(U)ManagementCommentsandOurResponse(U)TheAssistantSecretaryofDefenseforPolicy,HomelandDefense&GlobalSecurityconcurredwithourrecommendations,andnofurthercommentsarerequired.
PleaseseetheRecommendationsTableonthenextpage.
FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFOROFFICIALUSEONlrYRecommendationsTable''t\11ReC!
lmmenaatmns''NoAdditional','anagemt!
ntlRIA.
VIRGINIA22350-150(}MEMORANDUMFORSECRBTARYOFDEI'ENSBUNDERSECRETARYOFDEFENSEFORPOLICYMarch20,2015SUBJECT:(UJllvaluationofDoD'sUscofUnmannedAircraftSystemsforSupporttoCivilAuthorities(ReportNo.
DODIG·2015·097)(U)ThoOoputyIG.
IntelligenceandSpecialProgramAssessments(ISPA)Isprovidingthisreportforyourinformationanduse.
(U)Weconsideredmanagementcommentsonadraftofthisreportwhenpreparingthofinalreport.
CommentsfromtheOfficeofAssistantSecretaryofOefenseforPolicy,HomelandDofenso&GlobalSocurityworeresponsiveforallrecommendations.
(U)Weappreciatethecourtesiese~tendedtothestaff.
Pleasedirectques~omton.
eat(703)699--DSN664Jiiao.
t(703)699-J>SN499-PQROFPIGIAbYSBQNbPOROFPICil'.
l,USBONL-YContents(U)Introduction(U)ObJecdve.
1(U)Background1(U)ScopeandMethodology2(U)Finding3(l'900}DoDIsFullyCompliantwithLaws,Regulations,andNationalPoliciesforUASSupporttoCivilAuthorlttes.
N,N,3(UJStatutotYEnvlt·otunentforUmploymontoflloDUASInDomesticOperations.
3(U)OfficeoftheSecretatYofDefenseUnmannedAircraftSystemPolicyandGuidance.
(U)MilitaryServiceandNationalGuardBureauImplementationandExecutionofDoDUASPolicy.
2(U)DoDUASSupporttoCivilAuthoritlosEvonts.
3(l'900}DoDDoesNotHaveaStandardizedApprovalProcessforUASSupporttoDomesticCivilAuthorities.
4(l'900}SetviceandNationalGuardUASExperts~i(U)ScopeandMethodology(U)TheevaluationwasconductedinaccordancewithQualityStandardsforInspectionandEvaluationissuedbytheCounciloftheInspectorsGeneralonIntegrityandEfficiency.
Thosestandardsrequirethatweplanandperformtheevaluationtoobtainsufficient,appropriateevidencetoprovideareasonablebasisforourfindingsandconclusionshasedonourevaluationobjectives.
(U)OurevaluationincludedareviewofFederalStatutes,DoDpolicyanddirectives,ChairmanoftheJointChiefsofStaffInstructions,Servicepolicyanddirectives,andNationalGuardBureau(NGB)policyanddirectives,WealsoconductedInterviewswithpersonnelfromacrosstheDepartmentresponsibleforpoliciesandproceduresfortheconductofUASoperations{SeetheAppendix).
2TheUSAFusesthetermRemotelyPilotedAircraftInsteadofUAS.
~"ProtectingSecurityandPrivacy~AnAno.
fyticalFrameworkforAirborneDomesticlmagery/1ColonelDaWnM.
K.
loldl,USAF;USAFLawftevtew1Vol70FOROFFICIALUSEONI:rYbJ{c~purtNn.
DOHHtEFapproval.
Sincetherequestwasforincidentawarenessandassessmentduringtheentirefireseason,theunitchosenottopursueblanketapprovalbecauseofwhattheyfeltwasanonerousapprovalprocess.
(POliO)AnotherexamplewasprovidedbytheArmyandAirNationalGuard.
Inthiscase,aDSCAexercisewasproposedtoNGB(b)(7}(E)3ProperUseMemorandum:amemorandumsignedannuallybyanorganltatlon'scertifyinggovernmentoffleialthatdefu,estheorganbatlonsdomestlcImageryrequirementsandIntendedosc.
ItalsocontainsaproperusestatementacknowledgingawarenessofthelegalandpolicyrestrictionsregardingdomesticImagery,AF114-104,23Apr2012FOROFFICIAbI:JSBm!
bHtiporlNo,IHJDH.
i-20I1i.
fJIJ7]GFOROFFICIAbUSBONbY(~'Q!
JQ~WewerealsotoldaboutaDSCAtrainingexercisewiththeDepartmentofEnergyusingaU.
S.
AirForceremotelypilotedaircraftthatwasconductedwithoutformalSECDEFapproval.
ThisexercisewasforincidentawarenessandassessmentsupportofasimulatedhazardousmaterialreleaseonDepartmentofEnergyproperty.
ThetrainingmetalloftheInternalServiceguidelinesandwasforwardedforapproval.
However,sincetheexercisewasconductedwithinDoDrestrictedairspace,theJointStaffdeterminedthatapprovalwasnotrequired.
OurintervieweesexplainedthatthisleftthemconfusedaboutjustwhentheOSDpolicyrequiringSECDEFapprovalofUASsupportforDSCAapplied.
(FQ!
JQ~Finally,aU.
S.
MarineCorpUASunittoldusthatonceeachmonththeirwinghostsacommunityleadershipprogramwherelocalpoliticiansareinvitedtoviewandlearnaboutthecapabilitiesofthevariousaircraftonbase.
Duringonesuchevent,alocalmayorrequestedUASsupporttolookforpotholesInthearea.
Whiletheunitconcededthatthistypeofoperationcouldproviderealistictrainingfortheirpilotsandsensoroperators,localcommandersdeterminedthatundertheinterimguidance,requestingSECDEPapprovaltoconductaUASmissionofthistypedidnotmakeoperationalsense.
(U)ImpactofDoDUASPolicyonProcessing,Exploitation,andDisseminationforDSCA(JlQYQ)AlongwithinterviewingvariousunitsoperatingUASs,wealsointerviewedorganizationsresponsibleforperformingthePEDofUAScollecteddata.
WemetwithNationalGeaspatiallntelligenceAgency(NGA)personnelresponsibleforensuringthatNGAandotherDefenseIntelligenceComponentscomplywjththedomesticcollectionoftacticalimageryconsistentwithDoD5240.
1-R.
WhileNGAdoesnotoperateUASstheydoprovidePEDsupporttoDoDDSCAandotherFederalagencyUASoperationswithintheUnitedStates.
NGA(b)(})'0USC§Jl42NGA(b)Olsouse§3142FOROFPICIAbUSBmlbYFSRSFFIGIAbHSES~H:rYFindlng,'GA(b)(3)'iOUSC§~1.
i:UAI)GNWAfHllHGYON,bCiUOMOUh~\Jr.
Ut)'17,2015MEMOHANIJLiMfORSH:R.
f.
lARW.
SOFT1Jf!
Mlll'fAJlYDEIARTh.
t\!
NtSCHAIRMANOFTHEJOINTCltiEfSOFSTAfftiNl>PtSECR~-I'ARYOFDEf""ENSEFORACQUlMliON.
TIWHfi.
'OLOOV,ANULOOL'i.
TICSUNDEl\SJ:CRETARYOFDEFENS[FORPOUCYUNOfJt!
Sf,(;H.
I:;TARYOFUf.
H::NSEFORPERSONNELANIJ1ti":AOIN)~SSUNDUtsrRtTARVOFOEICNSEFORINTELLIG!
iNCI:COMMANDI'R,U.
S.
NORTI!
UlNCOMMANDCOMMANOliR,IJ.
S.
PAnnccO~iMANDClllm·,NA110NAIGIIART>llUIr~1-:CRF!
'AR\'OJ.
'IJr:ft~St':fORU:OIStATJVl:'AFFAIRSDP.
PARTMtNl'Ofllri'HNSECIIIWINI'OitMA'riONOHict'RASSISTMITTOnm·sr;crurrAR\'OFUfTl!
NSt.
FORPUHLKAfFAIRSSF.
NIOllINTEI.
I.
IG~NCflOVJ:RSIGHTOl'FI('~I\SIJBJEN:PolityMemorandwnIS-002,''('mldmccrorlh~DomtllicUscofUnmmntd1\ln:n\1\S)!
h.
owy17,2018POI'Nl'OFCONTACT;&1ormo"'lnrumwtlon,~ntco;tflASil(HD&OS)al(571)2S61Ji11Uspo11o)'tnemonhdumprovfdosBuldat\coforlhodomt;Stlcuscofuruno.
nncdAlrm.
l\a)'$mJ'(lfAS)wtruwo,thotcporlfn.
:nt"r~r~ru~o@oi.
))OASarourwIn~~withU.
S.
bw111dDoDpolky,Mdtoomlurctltq!
PJI>Pfl""1110ofDoDUAS"""Indom.
.
llofJIWIIlh'lru,trainlntntttbet.
Mdwnlng.
DoDdomedlctvlatiQnOJ~rlimu~uppottUomtluidlkfciiM::(HDl.
O~femcSupportofCivilAuthorities(DSCA)1andmiliW)'ltalnlngandrxt:n:lstl.
llnlw;a5p0eific.
allyl'f'O\idedfcrlnihbpolk:y,law,orotbcrgufd!
\JI!
;(',th~&pprovdofdw8"rdttt)'ofPcfm~WIs~equimlforalldommlcliASofl'I'IIM>(lnCiudlngDoDUASopcUiantt!
onP.
S.
~t,lrcdhc5~00.
271aude:ppl~ingthe('vtolghtguldanrecootalr.
tdinl>oD$240,1-R"IOiutclligcncilandnon·lntel!
igtncc.
.
.
:lalcddomutlcUAS_u~,allUASatqubhitll'l,.
'~llJ.
tl'N'Nprlatueln:uml!
lt.
no:n,UhSm)'~llUdlolieuol'munnNnircMtl(~>rd()mC!
>"tlcmtult:IM.
AnmJrritttthturn~m.
o:yineluddwttcn:&ll$tt&lnedtndurat1Q.
l~n~J1>~MO~qu!
rl!
'd;UMW'.
neda!
rmftpmvid~uptrlt'tcapabilll.
!
rs;orpt1)"il'!
'lll11ftftWW:ttltt:linlitatioMJWi'>hll!
itthousc,lfm411ordtolaty·orthcd:·Win~11lroran.
uouIJASIn!
heUnlud5tl~tJIJUI)'oo1y~wedfrrrno,DSCA,ondN:OHla!
t"'rPPon,pmfitm~,lnefudlngopemtlnnklSUPfWlrlttemntl,~taiL',J~al,llttdtribalgtWeMini!
DtorganltAaon,lf'l't>""'m0\~t(ftlt11Set;"t.
!
l.
at}ofl)tfe~:hmayt'OOSiderDoDUASan_rlo)11lC'nlinthtlrplanningfordim!
ltl.
':fft'J;fl'"tt!
Wnctivlllc-~.
t:PoDUASnt~ctiJoJurponofStRII)dhadetNaponsc'hou!
Jiubmlrnl'omudrcquntlb\\lilinslothOc&:creta')'ori)(fcnl.
tSw:hTAttJCMsshldcoJ\tltlntheannly.
shtf)ridnctcdtb11t!
f~mnlnetllbBtuthcrmann.
r.
d11!
r~'"we~n~flJl)'n>Pf(lll~.
1l1CClutlnnnnoftheJointChief~ofSII)ff,Int.
flf)UASln.
$ll(li'OitcfaStaiC-fNUUt!
.
Plon!
!
ihoutdfllCtorIntOOr.
~ure.
'mtimen-qulrOO(('ItFAAe·MbgemenlAgtncy·toordlnatcdrc@ouotlplanning,&n)'StateChitprop~th~'*"ofPoDUASinlUil'lanttt,vuldco.
-.
nwllwithrb~wm:\pc_ndlnaeca&rJrhlcComblltSIJtCnmt11itrldcrtoCl151110thatStflii:andDDlrettiu~lOlS-.
18,''OcftiJ~eS\~lf'\lr1otCMIAutlmrhir.
~.
''TheprimM)'pi!
IJXlSOofdomc:rtiellAStraining1\fldexercisesisforP:oDfon.
'Cbto~:oodul.
\1ren.
lj~tlctrainingIntheircorel'~(.
'fafmilllttr)'!
11!
~9h:ihIU't4J,DoDUASusedh1tfainlngnudex~:rd~wlllnot.
c.
qul~or('(lfl~tinf,-,mu:tion(e-t;ceptfor~nci!
kntalcotlettlon)about"{'"ifiiltU,S,~n~orOOtl·DOf)'ontroUcdpr9pcrtyfirfaciiiUcsI~X.
t'llednutsldoDoD·Jnlrolh:dln~mlllltionswitlli'Utamscot.
AllUASl\l:qJllsitinn,roue~liOf1tr&nlk!
n,anddliStm~hmtJflnrorm:~ltonwillb(finlltC(Irdmcewhhstnodln;.
;Dollhl:B\ll~timuMdpolicy,includingl,)(lu(.
'nmponentlnielll~neeol'tufg:btguld.
wre,andwillttqulreo!
JtJM.
UscurDoDOASWtl$JndQili\.
'J>IIclmln!
li$-.
tdtJ:X~(('iS-e!
lnVJUltn:l11iutnotlfl{:ftlfnnto1J10SercLUyof'Ocf'en~~lftl10plntftmnill!
llilriJ"IlOoDUAS1an4bto~used1ntNIInlnl!
JUdtl:rtefcnwrcqolrcdbythisdionwillbesttbmittedtotho5tW~YntIC8113~dQ.
y&prl-by-ccon~ultwiththeFAAf~r~~"tutil~neecmtynlnp11;:#f!
ndtotJbtttlnS~elllf)'"rUc:kun~IIJlPfO\'ol.
Stotcslnwhlt:hDoDUASa1:ittsuofleWcdlhatha\'c~V~tUircmtnlfertheirusointheset.
"te:bf:s(ortrnJnlngn:qutrtng11ppr0vn.
lbytheSIttoryofOeren~)\l.
i_ll$tlbtnlttheUovcrnor'fRq~tlnwOtlngattcu30dayr;inadu.
ncetotheSa:r&l'}'ofDchmethroughnppn1pria.
1~MilitAryOcromncnfiS~·In",(\J~IIbt!
tllntlOmmaod.
orNOllchal!
ndsvW.
thtJointSta.
fT(J~;J),andf!
1a)'shbJUilsuchu:qut~rllthmt11Jth~NAS,MwellasIn11gg~55ivcly(levt:loplogddedund&W'+idtcchnotog:.
·toori!
IUJ'(IMf~fol"(:fiJtlonofUASinon~c:gragat'edalri:poc~TheChAirorthe~D~\'~lie)'lJo;udonF_edmtAvb.
tia110'8FAlwllllc.
ldtheDepmmcnt'seffotUII>advi,'UtoforUtec_tlmln4t10!
1ofunnf(t1UtyI'C'guiR!
OI)'l'C$trictlon$thatpreventrauiloo\\I:mowthedevelapmentortcCtmo1uglc9,_!
trutdAn.
11:!
!
~opcraUusvrocWu!
Utandpoll~l'"thatensure~tUQOU~8~ll.
'lilhtotonpcratcs~tfc1ywllhlnthentJtonalain~whileMillObftlanclttgandrrotcdingptrJOI'!
I'Itprlvi!
Cly,fhhcrQtmlgnModl\sl3pomlhll!
!
le!
jUntl.
!
rSe~.
·r.
taryofDt.
{fmll/orP~llayTher;ndu:i~RiatyufOcfe-psefurPolit)'1U~D(P))bIIU11wri~cdco~:abllsbthoapprorrimefiOlltyfordomes1ieU$CcrUASforforceprot~~lonlndprotcclll'inofolhcrDoD8$$&,whetherIn_DoDlnstroction2000,16,"DoDU'ASdome.
ttleoprrallon\ThisguhhMtreplaceandM'lnd$th~Ot,'JIIIIY~r.
:le1111}'11rDeftnsc:Men10rJlldttm,"fntc1mOl.
lldftnceforlheDomt'$11CIJ~otnfllnrnrmm"dAircraftSy~tem~.
''""''"'""21,2006:~fi6R8Pf'le!
AbHSB8HbHepnrlNo.
JH)OH.
i-tOt:i·Wr/jl(,FOROFFICIALUSEONINAppendixesAppendixes(U)DoDOfficesVisited(U)UnderSecretaryofDefenseforPolicyrepresentativesfromHomelandDefense&America'sSecurityAffairs.
(U)UnderSecretaryofDefenseforIntelligencerepresentativesfromWarflghterSupport.
(U)AssistanttotheSecretaryofDefenseforIntelligenceOversightrepresentatives.
(U)USNORTHCOMDirectorsfromtheOperations,Plans,Intelligence,andJudgeAdvocateGeneralDirectorates.
(U)NationalGeospatialAgency(NGA)representatives.
(U)NationalSecurityAgency(NSA)representatives.
(U)HeadquartersNationalGuardBureauPolicy,Operations,andIntelligenceDirectors.
(U)Headquartersu.
s.
Army,U.
S.
Navy,U.
S.
MarineCorps,andU.
S.
AirForcePolicy,Operations,andIntelligenceDirectors.
(U)U.
S.
Army,U.
S.
Navy,U.
S.
MarineCorps,andU.
S.
AirForceCommandsresponsibleforServiceUASemploymentpolicies,tactics,techniques,andprocedures.
(U)U.
S.
Army,U.
S.
Navy,U.
S.
MarineCorps,andU.
S.
AirForceCommandsresponsibleforServicePEDpolicies,tactics,techniques,andprocedures.
FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFOROFFJC!
Abl:JSEONI:NAppondixos(U)Unit'sVisitedandLocation1stAirForceTyndallAFB,FloridaSecondMarineAircraftWing(2dMAW)MCASCherryPoint,NorthCarolina480thISRWing(ISRW)langleyAFB,Virginia27thIntelligenceSquadron(2715)langleyAFB,VirginiaCaliforniaNationalGuardJFHQSacramento,CaliforniaAirNationalGuard181stIntelligenceWingTerreHaute,IndianaAirNationalGuard174AttackWingSyracuse,NewYorkArmy15thMilitaryIntelligenceBattalionFortHood,Texas1StCAV-GreyEaglesFortHood,Texas9''ReconnaissanceWingBealeAFB,California491'FighterWingHollomanAFB,NewMexicoJTF-NorthFtBliss,Texas2-13'hAviationRegimentFtHuachuca,ArizonaCommanderNavalAirForcesNASCoronado,CaliforniaU.
S.
NORTHCOMColoradoSprings,ColoradoNAVAIRPatuxentRiverNAS,MarvlandVMU-2MCASCherryPoint,NorthCarolina(U)UseofComputer-ProcessedData(U)Wedidnotusecomputer-processeddatatoperformthisevaluation.
(U)PriorCoverage(U)NopriorcoveragehasbeenconductedonDoD'sdomesticuseofUASforcivilauthoritiesduringthelast5years.
FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFOROFFICIALUSEONLY/\cronyrnsandf\tlhreviations(U)AcronymsandAbbreviationsCOCOMCombatantCommandDCGSDistributedCommonGroundSystemDIWGDomesticImageryWorkingGroupDoDDepartmentofDefenseDSCADefenseSupporttoCivilAuthoritiesISRIntelligence,surveillance,andReconnaissanceNGANationalGeospatlalAgencyNGBNationalGuardBureauOSDOfficeoftheSecretaryofDefensePEDProcessing,Exploitation,andDisseminationPUMProperUseMemorandumRPARemotelyPilotedAircraftSECDEFSecretaryofDefenseUASUnmannedAircraftSystemUSNORTHCOMUnitedStalesNorthernCommandFOROFFIC!
t.
LUSEONI:NFOROFFICIALUSEONLYWbistleblowerProtectionU.
S.
DEPARTMENTOFDEFENSE11111Whlsl/eb/owel'ProtectionlinlwncementActof2012reqrtiresthelnspecwrGencmltodesignateaWhistleblowerProtection.
Omb.
11(/smantoeducateogmn:J'cmplt~Yeesaboutpi'Ohibitlonsonre/(1/iatlon,amiri,ghtsandremediesagainstreta/lutionj'orprotccll!
clc/isdo.
~rw~:s.
1/wdesignatedm1ibudsmanist/111Do/)1/ot/ineDirec/01:Formoreitlj(mnol/011onyourri,qhtsandJ'l!
mediesagainstrewllat(lm,visitwwll'.
clod/g.
nJII/t't'Of)l'iltns/wl!
istlciJ/ower.
Formoteinformationaboutl>oDIGreport~oractivities,plea~econtactus:CongressloiialLiaisoncongressionill@dodlg.
mil;703.
604.
8324MediaConta~tpublic.
affahs@dodis.
mil;703.
604o8324MonthlyUp1late!
lodlgconnect-request@listserve.
wmReJ!
OrtsMaHlngListdodig_report@listserve.
comTwittertwitter.
com/DoD_IGDoDHotlinedodlg.
mil/hotlineFOROFPICIALUSEONLY
- onerousrrqqq.com相关文档
- 通讯rrqqq.com
- iterativerrqqq.com
- inchesrrqqq.com
- Concentrationsrrqqq.com
- HUMIDITYrrqqq.com
- Sourcesrrqqq.com
HostKvm 黑色星期五香港服务器终身六折 其余机房八折
HostKvm商家我们也不用多介绍，这个服务商来自国内某商家，旗下也有多个品牌的，每次看到推送信息都是几个服务商品牌一起推送的。当然商家还是比较稳定的，商家品牌比较多，这也是国内商家一贯的做法，这样广撒网。这次看到黑五优惠活动发布了，针对其主打的香港云服务器提供终身6折的优惠，其余机房服务器依然是8折，另还有充值50美元赠送5美元的优惠活动，有需要的可以看看。HostKvm是一个创建于2013年的...
织梦DEDECMS即将授权收费和维权模式 站长应对的几个方法
这两天在站长群里看到不少有使用DEDECMS织梦程序的朋友比较着急，因为前两天有看到来自DEDECMS，我们熟悉的织梦程序官方发布的公告，将会在10月25日开始全面商业用途的使用DEDECMS内容管理程序的会采用授权收费模式，如果我们有在个人或者企业商业用途的，需要联系且得到授权才可以使用，否则后面会通过维权的方式。对于这个事情，我们可能有些站长经历过，比如字体、图片的版权。以及有一些国内的CMS...
器安装环境和运维管理工具推荐
今天看到一个网友从原来虚拟主机准备转移至服务器管理自己的业务。这里问到虚拟主机和服务器到底有什么不同，需要用到哪些工具软件。那准备在下班之间稍微摸鱼一下整理我们服务器安装环境和运维管理中常见需要用到的软件工具推荐。第一、系统镜像软件一般来说，我们云服务器或者独立服务器都是有自带镜像的。我们只需要选择镜像安装就可以，比如有 Windows和Linux。但是有些时候我们可能需要自定义镜像的高级玩法，这...
rrqqq.com为你推荐
-
地图应用什么地图导航最好用最准确www.kkk.comwww.kkk103.com网站产品质量有保证吗xyq.163.cbg.com梦幻CBG的网站是什么。www.765.com有没好的学习网站dadi.tv智能网络电视smartTV是什么牌子本冈一郎本冈一郎是什么东西？？谁知道？？汴京清谈汴京残梦怎么样铂金血痕花开易见落难寻，阶前愁杀葬花人；独把花锄偷洒泪，洒上空枝见血痕。是什么意思盗车飞侠请教:游戏盗车飞侠4怎么开飞机,怎么买枪,怎么开坦克啊?b.faloo.com那有能看完整小说的在线阅读手机网站(我看得都是有删节的,内容勉强连贯)