differenceshuaigay
shuaigay 时间:2021-03-25 阅读:(
)
GAYMEN'SLITERATUREINTHETWENTIETHCENTURYAlsobyMarkLillyCHARLOTTEBRONTE'S'VILLETTE'(editor)""LESBIANANDGAYWRITING:AnAnthologyofCriticalEssays(editor)""SHAKESPEARE'S'MEASUREFORMEASURE'""THENATIONALCOUNCILFORCIVILLIBERTIES:TheFirstFiftyYears""AlsopublishedbyMacmillanGayMen'sLiteratureintheTwentiethCenturyMARKLILLY!
50thYEARMMACMILLANMarkLilly1993Softcoverreprintofthehardcover1stedition1993Allrightsreserved.
Noreproduction,copyortransmissionofthispublicationmaybemadewithoutwrittenpermission.
Noparagraphofthispublicationmaybereproduced,copiedortransmittedsavewithwrittenpermissionorinaccordancewiththeprovisionsoftheCopyright,DesignsandPatentsAct1988,orunderthetermsofanylicencepermittinglimitedcopyingissuedbytheCopyrightLicensingAgency,90TottenhamCourtRoad,LondonW1P9HE.
Anypersonwhodoesanyunauthorisedactinrelationtothispublicationmaybeliabletocriminalprosecutionandcivilclaimsfordamages.
Firstpublished1993byTHEMACMILLANPRESSLTDHoundmills,Basingstoke,HampshireRG212XSandLondonCompaniesandrepresentativesthroughouttheworldAcataloguerecordforthisbookisavailablefromtheBritishLibrary.
TypesetbyNickAllen/LongworthEditorialServicesLongworth,Oxon.
ISBN978-0-333-49436-3ISBN978-1-349-22966-6(eBook)DOI10.
1007/978-1-349-22966-6Thisbookisdedicatedtoallthosemilitantactivistsinthelesbianandgaycommunitywhosecourageandtenacityinthefaceofoverwhelmingoddsisaninspirationtousall.
IfBritaineverbecomesacivilisedandjustsociety,itwillpartlybeasaresultoftheirselflessefforts.
ContentsAcknowledgementsviiiIntroductionix1TheHomophobicAcademy12TheLegacyofByronandWilde153ThePoemsofConstantineCavafy334E.
M.
Forster:Maurice535TheLovePoetryoftheFirstWorldWar646JeanGenet:TheAutobiographicalWorks837ThePlaysofTennesseeWilliams1058YukioMishima:ConfessionsofaMask1279JamesBaldwin:AnotherCountryandGiovanni'sRoom14410ThePlaysofJoeOrton16811ChristopherIsherwood:ASingleMan18012AndrewHolleran:DancerfromtheDanceandNightsinAruba19013DavidLeavitt:TheLostLanguageofCranes206Notes220Index230viiAcknowledgementsTheauthorandpublisherswishtothankthefollowingforpermissiontousecopyrightmaterial:RosicaColinLtd.
,onbehalfoftheauthor'sEstatefortheextractsfrom'Reserve'and'Soliloquy1'inCollectedPoemsbyRichardAldington.
Copyright1948,1976RichardAldington.
FaberandFaberLtd.
,fortheextractfrom'TheModernAchilles'inTheBuriedStreambyGeoffreyFaber,1941.
DavidHighamAssociatesLtd.
,onbehalfoftheauthor'sEstatefortheextractfrom'MyCompany'inCollectedPoemsbyHerbertRead(FaberandFaber).
MacmillanPublishersLtd.
,fortheextractsfrom'Lament'inWhinbyWilfridGibsonand'SentryGo'inNeighboursbyWilfridGibson.
RandomCenturyGroup,fortheextractfrom'Fulfilment'inArdoursandEndurancesbyRobertNicholls(Chatto&Windus),and'TheSecret'byRobertNichollsinAureliaandOtherPoems(Chatto&Windus).
Everyefforthasbeenmadetotraceallthecopyrightholders,butifanyhavebeeninadvertentlyoverlookedthepublisherwillbepleasedtomakethenecessaryarrangementatthefirstoppor-tunity.
Iwasgreatlyassistedinmyworkbypreviousstudies,notablyGregWoods'sArticulateFlesh,MartinTaylor'santhologyofFirstWorldWarpoetry,Lads,withitsfineintroduction;andHenryScottStokes'sTheLifeandDeathofYukioMishima.
Ithanktheseauthorswarmlyfortheirassistance.
ParticularthanksarealsoduetoRobertRebein,oftheUniversityofBuffalo,whomadedetailedsuggestionsforchangesandadditions.
viiiIntroductionInanecstasyofincoherentrage,hisfatherproceededtospitrepeatedlyonthepagesuntilhischinwascoveredwithsaliva;thenheliftedthebooktohismouth,anddismembereditwithhisteeth.
WhenhisinnocentsonbravelypersistedindemandingwhatitwasthatOscarWildehaddone,hereceivedtheanswerwrittenonascrapofpaper:Illumcrimenhorribile.
.
.
quodnonnominandumest.
[Thathorriblecrime.
.
.
whichisnottobenamed.
](BeverleyNicholsbeingcaughtreadingDorianGray).
.
.
allapieceofliteratureshoulddo,Ithink,istellyouwhatitwasliketouchingFrankRomero'slipsforthefirsttimeonahotafternooninAugustinthebathroomofLes'sCafeonthewaytoFireIsland.
(AndrewHolleran,DancerfromtheDance)Poet,youarenoliar.
Theworldthatyouimagineistherealone.
Themelodiesoftheharpaloneknowtruth,andinthislifetheycanbeouronlytrueguides.
(Cavafy,'ThePoetandtheMuse').
.
.
thegreatdifferencebetweenpeopleinthisworldisnotbetweentherichandthepoororthegoodandtheevil,thebiggestofdifferencesinthisworldisbetweentheonesthathadorhavepleasureinloveandthosethathaven'tandhadn'tanypleasureinlove,butjustwatcheditwithenvy,sickenvy.
(TennesseeWilliams,SweetBirdofYouth)Hislife,passions,trials,loves,were,atworst,filth,and,atbest,diseaseintheeyesoftheworld,andcrimesintheeyesofhiscountrymen.
Therewerenostandardsforhimexceptthosehecouldmakeforhimself.
Therewerenostandardsforhimbecausehecouldnotacceptthedefinitions,thehideouslymechanicaljargonoftheage.
Hesawnoonearoundhimworthhisenvy,didixXIntroductionnotbelieveinthevast,greysleepwhichwascalledsecurity,didnotbelieveinthecures,panaceas,andsloganswhichafflictedtheworldheknew;andthismeantthathehadtocreatehisstandardsandmakeuphisdefinitionsashewentalong.
Itwasuptohimtofindoutwhohewas,anditwashisnecessitytodothis.
.
.
alone.
ijamesBaldwin,AnotherCountry)Idon'tknowifyou'relivingstillOrfalleninthefightButinmyheartyourheartissafeTillthelastnight(FirstWorldWarpoem,'HisMate',byStuddertKennedy)Alloftheseextractsappearinthisbook.
Seentogether,theygiveanideaoftheextraordinarydiversityofapproachamongstthewritersIproposetodiscuss.
Tendernessliessidebysidewithrage,existentialrejectionofconventionsrubsshoulderswithsexualhedonism.
Onlywithsteadyreflectioncanweteaseoutsomesharedpreoccupations.
Eachchapterinthisbookisdedicatedtotheworkofanauthorwhowasorispredominantlyorexclusivelygay,withtheexceptionofthechapteronthepoetryoftheFirstWorldWar(thereasonsformakingtheexceptionaresetoutinthechapteritself)andthesectiononByron(whowasbisexual).
Thebookisanintroduction,andhasbeenwrittenwiththefirst-yearcollegeanduniversitystudent,andthegeneralreader,especiallyinmind.
Itwouldofcoursebegratifyingtofindmyacademiccolleaguesamongstitsreaders,butitisnotdesignedforthem.
Ihavetriedtodowithoutmostofthetechnicaljargonofacademiccriticism,andtowriteasclearlyandconciselyaspossible.
Clarityofexpositionhasbeenmyguidingprinciple.
Forthemostpart,eachchapterdealswithasingleauthor.
Ihavewritteneachoftheseparatechaptersinsuchawaythateachoneformspartofacontinuingargumentaboutgaywritingacrossthewholeperiod,butalsosothateachchaptermakessenseasaseparateessay.
Thisisbecausetherewillbereaderswhohaveaninterestinoneortwoauthors,butdonotwishtoworktheirwaythroughthewholebook.
Thisbookisnotageneralsurvey,andthereforeintheselectionofauthorsfordiscussion,Ihavemadenoattempttobecompre-Introductionxihensive.
Thereis,forexample,nothingonmajorfigureslikeProust,Gide,MannorAuden,oroncontemporarywriterswhohaveattractedconsiderableacclaimsuchasThornGunn,EdmundWhiteandAgustinGomez-Arcos.
Instead,myaimhasbeentochoosealimitednumberoftextsfromalimitednumberofwritersinordertoinvestigatecertainsharedthemesandpatterns.
Confiningthescopeinthiswayhasallowedmetogivedetailedreadingsofindividualtexts,inawaythatisimpossibleinageneralsurvey.
Ofcourse,mychoicesarepersonalandthereadermustjudgetheirsuitability.
Nevertheless,Ishouldliketoprovideashortrationaleforthem.
Akeyprinciplewascoherence;thatis,positivelytochooseagroupofgayauthorswhoseworkcouldbediscussedintheform,asitwere,ofadevelopingstory.
FromByrononwards,thewritersstudiedhereallexpressarejectionofthesocietyinwhichtheyfindthemselves.
Theyfallintotwogroups.
Therearethose,followingShakespeare'sCoriolanus,whosaydefiantly,ontheirexpulsionfromsociety,'Thereisaworldelsewhere'and,whenbanished,retort,'Ibanishyou!
'GenetBaldwinandMishima,intheirdeeploathingofcontemporarysociety,adoptthisattitude,renouncetheworldvehemently,butcombinetheirvigorousiconoclasmwithimpliedorexplicitsuggestionsforadifferentworld.
Thesecondgroupofwriters,peoplelikeForster,Isher-woodandLeavitt,arereformersratherthanrebels.
Theyspeakcalmly,tryingtomoveorcajolethereaderintotolerantattitudesandarenunciationofprejudice.
Theywanttochangeafewdetailshereandthereratherthansweepthewholeboardclean.
Withinbothgroupscertainthemesemergerepeatedly.
Thereistheexistentialistdeterminationnottoacceptsocialrulesandcustomsfortheirownsake;eachpersonmusthavethecouragetorealisehisfreedomthroughexercisingit,oftenindefianceofsocialnorms.
Thenthereisthethemeofself-contempt:gaycharacters(inBaldwin,HolleranandWilliams,forexample)whoacceptsociety'sevaluationoftheirownworthwithoutquestion,andwhoseregrettablefateisthereforetobeseenasinsomesenseself-inflicted.
Mostofthesewritersalsoarticulateadesiretoescapefromtheoppressiveheterosexualworldintoanalternativeone.
Thismightbethecrazydrug-drenchedexcitementofHolleran'sdiscosinNewYorkandFireIsland;orthepastoralidyllinForster'sMaurice;ortheworldofartisticcreationinthepoetryofCavafy;orthezanyworldof'camp'humourinthexiiIntroductionplaysofOrton.
Mostoftheseworksexaminethenotionftheoutsider.
Societieshaveaneedtoidentifyeasytargets-gays,Jews,blacks-forabuseand,ifnecessary,murder,inordertoexorcisetheiranxietiesabouttheirlives,overwhichtheyclearlyfeeltheyhavenocontrol.
Asthesethemesemergeagainandagainindifferentforms,diverselyexpressedbutneverthelesssuggestingacertaincohesionanduniformity,theirsignificanceandmeaningforthereaderofthisbookwill,Ihope,besatisfactorilyamplifiedandenriched.
Thisbookisintendedasacontributiontowardsthefieldofgaystudies.
Incomparisonwiththeestablishedsuccess,especiallyintheUnitedStates,ofstudiesbasedonwomenandrace,gaystudiesareintheirinfancy.
Thespecialistpublishinghouses,academicsub-committees,universityandcollegecourses,grants-infactthewholeapparatusbymeansofwhichtheworldknowsthatanareaofstudyhasarrivedat'respectability'-arenotasfirmlyinplaceforgaystudiesasforstudiescentringonwomenandpeopleofcolour.
However,despitetheconsiderableop-position,itlooksclearthattheywillnotonlycontinuetodevelop,buttoexpandatadramaticrate.
Butthereisalivelyandcontinuingdebateabouttheirrationale.
Ishouldliketosetout-especiallyforthebenefitofreadersnewtothedebate-someofthequestionsthatareraisedbytheveryexistenceofgaystudies.
Weneedtostartwiththequestionofpurpose.
Whyhavegayorblackorwomen'sstudiesatallSurelytheyencouragetheseparatisttendenciesofWesternculturegenerally.
Anintellectualghettohasthesameadverseeffectsasaphysicalone:peopledividedfromeachother,akindofinformalapartheid.
Themeritofliterarystudiesunderthetraditionaldispensation,soitisargued,isthat,irrespectiveofconsiderationsofgender,race,sexualorientationoranyotherdefiningcategory,workscanbediscussedandinterpretedusingtoolsofcriticismwhich,becausetheyrepresentaunifyingconsensus,alsobestowprestigeandevenreliabilityontheresultingjudgements.
Thiscomplaintvoicesalegitimateconcern.
ManyofthoseinvolvedinwhatIproposetocall'minoritystudies'(tobeunderstoodasincludingwomen)addressitbysayingthattheyliketothinkofthesestudiesastemporaryandprovisional,inthewaythatIsuggestbelowallcriticalapproachesare.
Theargumentrunsthat,atthepresentmoment,mainstreamcultureignoresanddebasesminorityexperience(thisismorefullydevelopedinIntroductionxiiichapter1),andthereforeinorderbothtocounteractthenegativestereotypesandtheprejudicedorculturallyill-informedcom-mentariesofthetraditionalists,thereneedstobeaperiodinwhichamoreorlesssustained,committedandconcentratedattacktakesplace.
Oncethevalueofminorityexperienceisunderstoodandvalued,academicseparatismcanwitheronthevine.
However,itisonlyfairtoaddthattherearemorehard-lineseparatistswhocannotimagineheterosexualseveraccom-modatingthemselvestothelegitimateaspirationsofgaypeople(andsoformen/women;black/white)andwemustthereforeresignourselvestoanindefinitefutureinwhichinterestgroupsexistasopenlyintheacademyastheydointheworldofsocietyandpolitics.
Therearethreeothermajorcomplaintsmadebyopponentsofgay/black/women'sstudies.
First,intellectualendeavourrequiresneutrality,butthevastmajorityofthoseengagedinsuchstudiesarepartisansormembersofthegroupinvolved,andun-embarrassedlydeclaretheircommitmenttoadvancethestatusandinterestsofthegroup.
Howcanacademicstudiesbeimpartialifthereisafixedagendainadvance,andcertainunfavourableconclusionsarelikelytobesuppressedSecondly,minoritystudiesareseenaspoliticalinthesensethattheyseektodestabiliseanddiscreditmainstreamassumptionsaboutcultureandvalue.
AnexcellentexampleofthisistakingplaceasIwrite(Spring1991)inWashingtonDC,whereanexhibitionofpaintingsonthethemeoftheAmericanWesthasbeensuppliedwithacatalogueandcommentaryinterpretingfamouscanvassesnotintheestablishedway(asgivingvalidityandevenglorytowhiteAmericans'territorialincursionsagainsttheIndians)butinawaythatcastigatesthosedeedsasbarbarous.
Thirdly,thetraditionalcriteriaofliteraryexcellenceareseentobeunderthreatfromminoritystudies.
Novelsandpoemswhich,undertheolddispensation,wouldnothavebeenconsidered(toputitbaldly)goodenoughtobestudied,arenowbeingallowedontosyllabusesbecauseoffashion.
Furthermore,theyareactivelydisplacingsomeofthegreatclassicswhichhavealreadyprovedtheirworth.
Ephemeralworksshouldnotbeaccordedthesamestatusascanonictextswhosesurvivalovertimeisclearevidenceoftheirexcellence.
Itisnotsuggestedthatliteraryworksofminorityinterestshouldbeomittedfromsyllabuses;butthattheirplacethereshouldbewonnotbecausetheyare'relevant'orxivIntroductionfashionable,butbecausetheyarefineworksofartaccordingtothetraditionalcriteria.
Wenowtumtotheargumentsofthedefence.
First,ifminoritystudiesarepartisan,thensoaretraditionalstudies.
Thedifferenceliesinthefactthatthepartisanshipofthefirstgroupisopenlyavowedandclearlyunderstood,whereasthatofthesecondgroupconstitutesasortofhiddenagenda.
Individualtraditionalistsmaynotevenbefullyawarethemselvesofthenatureoftheirownpartisanship,butsuchlackofawarenessdoesnotreduceitseffect.
Furthermore,itisnowanacceptedcommonplacethat'neutrality'ornon-partisanshipisimpossible;wecananddoseethingsonlyfromasubjectivestandpoint.
Ofcourse,someinterpretationsareregularlydescribedasbeingmore'objective'thanothers,butthisisoftenanimpressioncreatedbyacertainapparentlydetachedlinguisticstyleanddoesnotnecessarilyreflectasubstantivedifference.
Secondly,ifpractitionersofminoritystudiesaretobedescribedasintentondiscreditingmainstreamculturalvalues,theanswerisahappyacknowledgementthatthisisindeedthecase.
Itisnotclearwhysuchanapproachisanydifferentfromthevehementprotectionofmainstreamculturalvalues.
Therearedefendersandattackersinanybattle,buttheyareallequallyfighters.
Thethirdchargehasprovedtobethemostcontentious:thatestablishedandtestedcriteriaofexcellencearereplacedbywhimsicalfashionablenotionsofpoliticalrelevance,withtheresultthat'inferior'worksarestudied.
Theanswertothis,putsimply,isthatthereisnojustificationforassumingthattraditionalcriteriaare'better'thannovelones,orthatconsiderationsotforexample,fashionorpoliticalconcernshouldbeconsideredinferiortoanyothers.
Inaddition,thereisanunacknowledgeddishonestyinthetraditionalists'casewhichconsistsintheimpliedpretencethatthemainstreamliterarycriteriaonwhichtheyrelyhavealengthyhistoricalpedigree.
Infact,theircriticalassumptionsarequitemodem,andiftheyweretolookonlyalittlebackwardstheywouldfindmuchtoquarrelwith.
Forexample,eighteenth-centurywriterslikePope,Addison,SteeleandSwifttookitforgrantedthatliteraturewas,partlyatleast,politicalpropaganda.
Inthenineteenthcentury,animportanttestoftheworthinessofanovelwaswhetheritwasfitforladiesandcouldbeleftinthedrawing-room;JaneEyre,togiveoneexample,wasnot.
Weshouldalsolooktothefuturewhenconsideringthisissue.
ItismorethanIntroductionXVlikelythatatsomepossiblyneardateinthefutureMobyDickwillbeseenasawickedbookbyvirtueofits'speciesism'(itdealswiththecruelpersecutionofadumbanimal)justasitisnowconsideredbyfeministcriticismasastatementofmasculineassertivenessbyvirtue,interalia,ofthealmostcompleteabsenceoffemalecharacters.
Literatureisread,andcanonlyberead,inthecontextofsocietiesinwhichhundredsofvariablesalterandadjustthewaywewanttosearchforvalue.
Weshouldbearinmindthat,whenweconsiderthepast,everysetofcriticalassumptionsandpracticessinceAristotlenowseemstoustobeeithersimplistic,offensive,absurdorattheveryleastradicallyincomplete.
Soitwillbewith'newcriticism',structuralism,deconstruction;andsoitwillcertainlybewithgaystudiesasaconcept.
Thetraditionalists'impliedclaimtohavediscoveredsometranscendentcriteria,goodforalltime,isthereforeprofoundlyunhistorical.
Finally,awordabouttheterm'gaymen'sliterature'.
Thereisnoconsensusatthemomentastoitsscope,anditcanthereforeincludesomeorallofthefollowingcategories:worksthatdealwithhomosexualitywrittenbyheterosexuals;worksbyclosetedgaymen,writingwithoutdirectreferencetohomosexuality,whosemeaningisneverthelessinformedbythewriter'ssexuality(Forster'sTheLongestjourney,TennesseeWilliams'sTheGlassMenagerie);theworkofgaywritersseeminglyunaware(con-sciously)oftheirsexuality,butarticulatingitnevertheless(theHopkinsofTheBugler'sFirstCommunionandHarryPloughman);andfinallytheworkof'out'gaywriters,addressingissuesofhomosexualdesireandculturedirectly(AndrewHolleran,EdmundWhite).
RackNerd 商家我们应该是比较熟悉的商家,速度一般,但是人家便宜且可选机房也是比较多的,较多集中在美国机房。包括前面的新年元旦促销的时候有提供年付10美元左右的方案,实际上RackNerd商家的营销策略也是如此,每逢节日都有活动,配置简单变化,价格基本差不多,所以我们网友看到没有必要囤货,有需要就选择。RackNerd 商家这次2022农历新年也是有几款年付套餐。低至RackNerd VPS...
Friendhosting商家在前面的篇幅中也又陆续介绍到,是一家保加利亚主机商,主要提供销售VPS和独立服务器出租业务,数据中心分布在:荷兰、保加利亚、立陶宛、捷克、乌克兰和美国洛杉矶等。这不近期黑色星期五活动,商家也有推出了黑五优惠,VPS全场一次性45折,虚拟主机4折,全球多机房可选,老用户续费可获9折加送1个月使用时长,VDS折后最低仅€14.53/年,有需要的可以看看。Friendhos...
简介华圣云 HuaSaint是阿里云国际版一级分销商(诚招募二级代理),专业为全球企业客户与个人开发者提供阿里云国际版开户注册、认证、充值等服务,通过HuaSaint开通阿里云国际版只需要一个邮箱,不需要PayPal信用卡,不需要买海外电话卡,绝对的零门槛,零风险官方网站:www.huasaint.com企业名:huaSaint Tech Limited阿里云国际版都有什么优势?阿里云国际版的产品...
shuaigay为你推荐
微信回应封杀钉钉为什么微信被封以后然后解封了过了一会又被封了西部妈妈网九芽妈妈网加盟费多少xyq.163.cbg.com梦幻CBG的网站是什么。百度关键词工具常见百度关键词挖掘方法分别是什么请列举?www.119mm.comwww.kb119.com 这个网站你们能打开不?www.765.com哪里有免费的电影网站javmoo.com找下载JAV软件格式的网站javmoo.com0904-javbo.net_avop210hhb主人公叫什么,好喜欢,有知道的吗www.33xj.compro/engineer 在哪里下载,为什么找不到下载网站?www.se333se.com米奇网www.qvod333.com 看电影的效果好不?
vpsio 韩国电信 好看的桌面背景图片 彩虹ip 商务主机 免费个人空间 200g硬盘 php空间购买 重庆双线服务器托管 银盘服务 360云服务 域名dns 工信部icp备案查询 中国联通宽带测试 腾讯网盘 googlevoice 神棍节 赵荣博客 ftp服务器架设 网站服务器硬件配置 更多