extendedxyq.cbg.163.com
xyq.cbg.163.com 时间:2021-03-20 阅读:()
StudyonthedeformationcharacteristicsanddynamicmechanismofseismicfracturesinWenchuanearthquakeshatteredslopesJinKeYUAN,RunQiuHUANGandXiangjunPEIStateKeyLaboratoryofGeohazardPreventionandGeoenvironmentProtection,ChengduUniversityofTechnology,Chengdu610059,SichuanE-mail:yuanjingke@163.
comAbstractNumerousshatteredslopestriggeredbywenchuanearthquake,theshatteringareawerelargeandtheseismicfractureswerewidedistribution,mostlythreatenedthepost-hazardreconstruction.
Accordingtothecharacteristicsofseismicfracturesinshatteredslopes,theresearchresultsshow:(1)Theseismicfractureswasdividedintosixtypes:surfacetype,transfixingtype,striketype,tendencytype,closuretype,extensiontypefromthroughsurveythemorphologicalcharacteristicsanddeformationindications;(2)OnthewholetheSeismicfractureswasN30~60Etrending,whichaccordswiththewholestrikeofactivefaultinwenchuanearthquake;(3)mainlydistributedinseismogenicfaultsareaorridge、andsteepwithslowborderarea;(4)wellextension,highopendegree,upperwideandlowernarrowofprofilemorphology,fillingslessorno,mainlymixedstonefragments,withaerialphenomena.
Basedonthetheoryoffracturemechanics,themechanismofseismicfractureswasbelongtotensilecrack,thedeformationandfailureprocessofstructuralplanesunderdynamicactionwasdividedintorupture,expansionandarrestabilitythreestages.
Keywords:wenchuanearthquake,shatteredrockmass,seismicfracture,geohazards1.
IntroductionTensofthousandsofcollapse,landslidesandsecondarygeologicaldisasterstriggeredbyWenchuanEarthquake.
Earthquakeinducedalargenumberofslopegeologicaldisasters,alsocausedapotentialdisaster—Slopeshattereddeformablebodywhichnamelyshatteredrockmass.
Theshatteredrockmassasageologicalphenomenon,itwasmainlyaffectedbytheearthquakeforceunderthecertaingeologicalconditions(Liangetal.
2003;Fengetal.
2009;Liangetal.
2009).
Thedynamiceffectofseismicwaveinrockmassdestroyedtherockmassstructure,itswholestructurevaried(Shao2005;Zuoetal.
2008).
Themosttypicalfeatureofslopeshatter-destroyedisthattheseismicfracturesdevelopedThedeformation,instabilityofshatteredrockmasshascontrolledbyseismicfractures,itisapotentialdisaster.
Theshatteredrockmasshasnomacrodestructionfeaturessuchaslargedeformation,largedisplacementasotherdestructionforms,itwasaninherentrockmassdamage,alsoitwasthemaincauseofsecondarydisastersaftertheearthquaketakenplacefrequently.
Studytheseseismicfractureshasimportantsignificancetorecognizethedeforma-tionandfailure,formationmechanismsofshatteredrockmasscorrectly.
2.
SeismicfractureclassificationsandfailurecharacteristicsTherockmassstructurewerecrackedopenbyearthquakeforce,sotheseismicfractureformed.
Theclassificationofseismicfractureshouldcorrespondstoitsformationmechanisms,nowtheclassificationresearchtofracturesmainlybasedonthevisual,intuitiveshapeofsurvey(Xie1988).
Theclassificationanalysistofracturesmainlybasedonitsdistribution,developmentcharacteristics,deformati-onfeatures,andmakeitpossibletopredictitsdeformationanddestruction.
Basedonthisconsideration,theseismicfractureswasdividedintosixtypes:surfacetype,transfixingtype,striketype,tendencytype,closuretyp,extensiontypefromthemorphologicalcharacteristicsanddeformationfeatures.
2.
1SurfacetypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsSurfacetypeseismicfracturewasrefertotherockmasssurfaceshatteredlongerlengthfromitscharacteristics,butitswidthandvisibledepthisgenerallysmall.
Smallscaleofsuchfracturesweredevelopedinallkindsofslopestructure,andthereisnoobviousdirectionaldistribution,itdistributedintherockmasssurface,andhadpoordeepinterconnectivity(Fig1).
(Ⅰ)(Ⅱ)Fig.
1SurfaceseismicfractureInaccordancewiththeextensioncharacteristicsofsurfacetypeseismicfracturecanbedividedintobrokenlinetype,Lineartype.
Fromitscombinationfeaturescanbedividedintoen-echelontype,crossovertype.
[1]brokenlinetype:Thespreadingdirectioninplaneofseismicfractureswasturning、bentpointofthepolylineorarc-shaped,andthencontinuetoextend(Fig.
1Ⅰ).
[2]Lineartype:Theoverallspreadingdirectioninplaneofseismicfractureswasextendedstraight,littlechangeindirection,nosignificantturningorbendingintheprocessofextending(Fig.
1Ⅱ).
[3]En-echelontype:itformedbyaseriesofseismicfractureswhosedirectionsubstantiallythesame,en-echelondistributionpresentedontheplane,seismicfractureswerebrokenlineorlineartype(Fig2).
Fig.
2Distributionschematicdiagramofen-echelontypeseismicfracture[4]crossovertype:itformedbythetwoorthreegroupsofseismicfractureswhoseextensiondirectionweredifferent,crosseachother,thedistributionshapeontheplanewas"X"or"Y"shaped(Fig3).
(Ⅰ)"X"shapedseismicfracture(Ⅱ)"Y"shapedseismicfractureFig.
3CrossovertypeseismicfractureSurfaceseismicfracturewereexistintherockmasssurface,theycan'tcontrolthedeformation、instabilityofrockmass.
However,thistypeofseismicfracturesdistributedgenerally,higherdensitydevelopedinlocalposition,therebyitdestroyedtheoverallstructureofrockmass.
Anditeasytobecomeagoodwaytorainwaterinfiltrationwhenexperiencerainfallconditions.
2.
2TransfixingtypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsComparativelyspeakingtoseismicfracturesurface,thetransfixingseismicfracturenotonlylongextendinglength,butalsolargeopeningdegree,visibledepthwasupto10m.
Thefracturehadgoodinterconnectivity,linearextensioninplane,jointinterfacejagged,throughoutinsidetherockmassbytheformofpinch-out.
Forsurvey,themajorityofseismicfracturesbelongtothistype(Fig.
4).
Fig.
4SeismicfracturethroughoutinsiderockmassThedevelopmentscaleofransfixingseismicfractureswerelargeandhadgoodinterconnectivity,itcausedsignificantdamagetorockmassstructureandaffectthedeformationandinstabilityofrockmass.
Throughtheinvestigationoffracturesonslope,suchfracturesdevelopedinbetterpositionasslopetop,steepslowborder,freefacetoformedthetrailingedgeorsideedgeboundaryofcuttingrockmass,itbecomethemaincontrollingfactorsofshatteredrockmassstability.
Seismicfracturescuttingrockmasstoformedthedangerousrockbodyonslope(Fig.
5).
Fig.
5DangerousrockformedbyseismicfracturecuttingSeismicfractureswasfillinglessorno.
Theycouldfurtherextendedwhenencounteredtherainfallorvibrateinterference.
Whenthefracturescontinuedtorunthroughthelockedsegmentinshatteredrockmass,thelockedsegmentcouldsuddenlysnippedoncethetensilestressofrockmasswasgreaterthanthetensilestrengtundertheactionofgravity,earthquakeforceevenwind.
Thendangerousrockseparatedfromthematernalrocktodropandformedrollingrock.
Throughthecollapsesinvestigation,theperforateseismicfracturesbecamethemaincontrollingfactorofcollapsedisastersafterearthquake.
Suchseismicfracturesweredevelopedinalargescal、stronginterconnectivity,theyoftencausedgreatcollapsehazard.
2.
3StriketypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsAccordingtotheextensiondirectionofseismicfractures,thestriketypeseismicfracturewasrefertoitslengthalongthestrikedirectionwaslargerthanalongthedipdirection,fracturedevelopedmainlyalongitsstrike.
Theextensiondirectionofstriketypeseismicfracturewasidenticalorsimilartothedirectionoftectonicforce(suchasthestrikeoffault).
Theseseismicfracturesextendedalongitsstrike,theyhadstrongdirectional(Fig6).
Sincethistypeofseismicfracturesdevelopedwasmainlyduetotheeffectoftectonicforce,sotheirdevelopmentalscaleweregenerallylarger.
Fig.
6SeismicfracturedevelopednearthefaultStriketypeseismicfracturesexposedonslopebylesserextentofsubjectedtotheinfluenceofterrainandsurfacefeatures,theirextensionlengthalongthestrikedirectionwaslarge.
Seismicfracturesweremainlydistributedinthevicinityoffault.
Itwasduetothestrongearthquakeforceexistedatthefault,higherdegreeofrockmassshattered,fracturescouldeasilydevelopedalongthestrikedirectionoffault.
Andseismicfractureswhichexistedatotherlocations,owningtotheirextendprocesswaslimitedbytheinfluenceofterrainandsurfacefeatures,sothecharacteristicsalongthestrikeextensionwasnotobvious.
ThestrikeofthistypeseismicfracturewasN30~60Ebyfieldinvestigation,seismicfractureswhichdevelopedalongtheirstrikedirectionwerelocatedinthevicinityoffault.
Thelengthalongstrikeofstriketypeseismicfracturewaslonger,itcouldconstitutedtheinstabilityrangeboundaryofshatteredrockmassandcontrolledawiderangeofrockmassunstable.
Therockmassstructurearoundthistypeofseismicfractureswaspoor,higherdegreeofshatter-damaged.
Oncetheshatteredrockmassproduceddeformationandinstability,majordestructiveformed.
2.
4TendencytypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsThetendencytypeseismicfracturewasrefertoitsextensiondirectionmainlyalongitsdipdirection.
Forthedevelopmentalmorphology,thelengthalongdipdirectionwasgreaterthanalongitsstrikedirection,itsdevelopmentwasextendedintothedeepofrockmass.
Thistypeofseismicfracturesdevelopedinvariouslocationsonslope,especiallydevelopedatridge、steepwithslowborderarea.
Mostseismicfracturesbelongedtothistendencytypethroughinvestigatedonslope.
Althoughitslengthexposedongroundwasshort,owningtoitwasextendedintothedeepalongitsdipdirection,itsvisibledepthwasupto10minthedeepofrockmass.
Therearecertaindistributioncharacteristicsinsuchseismicfractures,theLaddertype、"Y"-shapetypeandTrace-backtypehadpresentedinthemorphologyofprofilecombination(Fig.
7).
Laddertypeseismicfractureswascharacterizedbyaseriesoffractureswhichinclined、extendedtothesamedirection,parallelornearlyparalleltoeachother.
Duetothevisibledepthlimitedinsuchseismicfractures,sothistypefracturesmayalsointersectedinthedeeperpositionofrockmass.
Thecharacteristicsof"Y"-shapetypeseismicfractureswasthataseriesofdifferenttendenciesseismicfracturescrossedintheextendprocesstothedeep,"Y"-shapepresentedintheprofile.
Trace-backtypeseismicfracturewasrefertothefracturesoccurredoneormorebranches,thesecondaryseismicfractureswhichcontinuousorintermittentappearedinitsextendprocessintothedeep.
Fig.
7CombinationschematicdiagramoftendencytypeseismicfracturesTendencytypeseismicfracturescuttingrockmass,constitutedtheinstabilityboundariesofshatteredrockmass,formeddangerousrockhangedontheslope.
Owningtothelengthofseismicfractureextendingtodeep,goodcontinuitywithaerialphenomenon,itoftenbecomeagoodchannelforrainwater、groundwaterinfiltration,couldeasilycausetheinstabilityofshatteredrockmasstocollapse.
Thistypeofseismicfractureswaswidedistributiononslope,sotheformationofdamageisrelativelylarge.
2.
5ClosuretypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsFortheextendingtrendenceinthedistributionplaneofseismicfractures,thejointinterfaceonthistypeoffracturesuneveninextensionprocess,atbothendsofthefractureclosedornearlyclosed,buttheintermediateportionisopen,smallopeningwidth(Fig.
8).
Fig.
8ClosuretypeseismicfractureClosuretypeseismicfracturesweremainlydistributedinthebetterpartsofrockmassstructure.
Thebettertheoverallstructureofrockmass,thelessdamageextentbyseismicforcestotherockmassstructure.
Seismicfracturesoccurredbyrockmasstensioncrackintheextendingprocesswasrestricted,itdiscontinuousdistributedbytheformofbeaded-shapeinslopesurface.
Thisfracturewassmalldegreeopening,thejointinterfaceonbothsidesinrockmassgraduallyfillingatlaterundertheactionofgravity、fracturedeposits.
Sincethistypeofseismicfracturesintermittentdistributed,poorcontinuity,smalldegreeopening,thejointinterfacegraduallyhealinglater,devastatinglimited,butitdiscontinuousdistributedintheslopesurface,withacertaindegreeofductility,itdestroiedtheoverallstructureofslope.
Seismicfracturefillinglessorno,overheadrockmass,itcouldconstituteagoodchannelforrainwater、groundwaterinfiltration.
Onceitconnectwithotherfractureswhichwaslargeopening、goodcontinuity、stronginterconnectivity,thesefracturescouldcausecrackingscaling,acceleratingtherockmassdeformationinstability,sodestructive.
2.
6ExtendedtypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsExtendedtypeseismicfracturereferstoitsextensioninthesection,oneendwasgraduallyopen,andextendedtotheslopesurfacewithopeninggraduallylarge,oneendgraduallypinchoutintothedeep,andhadthewedge-shapedgapofwideupper-narrowlower.
Thiskindsoffractureswaslargeopeningdegree,fillinglessorno,thejointinterfacewasroughandjagged(Fig.
9).
Fig.
9ExtendedtypeseismicfractureThroughslopeseismicfracturesinvestigation,thefracturewhichwaswideupper-narrowlowershapedinsection,largedegreeopening,overheadrockmass.
Itmostlybelongtotheextensionseismicfracture.
Thisseismicfractureformatedbythehighdegreeofshatterdamagedcausedbyseismicforcestotherockmassstructure,severelydamaged,thedevelopmentoffracturesextendedalongthedirectionofseismicforce.
Usingthetheoryoffracturemechanics,fracturesbegintoexpandwhenitstipstressintensityfactorisgreaterthanrockmassintensityfactorbyseismicforce,thiscanberoughlydividedintothreestages:initialshatteredstage,fractureformed,developmentstage,fracturepropagation、extendingtosurfacestage(Linetal.
1986).
Extendedtypeseismicfractureswerewidelydevelopedontheslopesaccordingtothesurvey,especiallydevelopedatcrest、ridgeorsteepwithslowborderarea,acertainsizedistributed.
Thisseismicfracturesnotonlydestroiedtherockmassstructure,butalsolargedegreeopening,overheadrockmass.
Aftertheearthquake,frequentaftershocks、rainfallandwindforceswereconstantlychangedthestateofshatteredrockmassbalance,thesemadetheseismicfracturescontinuestoexpand、extend.
Thesefracturesleadtherockmassinstabilityandcollapse.
3.
SeismicfracturedevelopmentcharacteristicsInvestigatedthebasiccharacteristicsofseismicfractures,theirspread、developmentcharacteristics、deformationsignshadsomecorrespondingcharacteristics.
3.
1SpatialdistributioncharacteristicsSeismicfractureswasN30~60Etrending(Fig.
10),itisbasicallythesamewiththetriggeringseismicfaultsinWenchuanearthquake,theextensiondirectionoffractureshasobviouslyeffectedbythetriggeringseismicfault.
Somelargerdegreeofshatteredopeningfracturesspreadbylinearshaped,goodextension,generallynotsubjectedtotheinfluenceoftheterrainandsurfacefeaturesinitsextendingdirection.
Someseismicfractureswerecorrespondingwiththefaultwhichinfluencedtheirdevelopment.
Americanscholars(Leonard1929;Holzeretal.
1987)putforwardedtheviewoftectonicorigininseismicfracturesbyanalysistheearthquakeforce,theythinkedthetectonicisthedominantfactorinformationanddevelopmentofseismicfractures.
Fig.
10StatisticalgraphoftypicalseismicfracturesThedistributionofseismicfracturesweremainlyduetotheeffectoftriggeringseismicfaults,theyweremainlydistributedinthevicinityofcausativefaultorridgespositionandsteepslowborderinslope,thesepositionswerealsothesiteofstrongseismicforce.
3.
2ExtendedlengthcharacteristicsTheextensionlengthofseismicfracturereferstoitscontinuouslengthexposedontheslopesurface.
Thefracturesextendedlengthgenerallylonger,morethan6m.
Someshatteredseriousfractureswasupto10minlength,portionextendedtothetopofslope.
Collapsepit、tensionalslotwereexposedintheprocessofextending(Fig.
11).
Largenumberofsecondaryseismicfracturesweredistributedaroundthemainseismicfractures.
Thesecondaryseismicfracturesdiscontinuousdistributedandpoorcontinuity.
Fig.
11Tensilegroovedeveloped3.
3OpeningdegreecharacteristicsTheopeningdegreeofseismicfracturemainlyreferstothewidthofcrackinrockandsoilmassbyshockedtensionintheearthquakeforce.
Throughthesurvey,theopeningdegreeofseismicfracturewastheformofwideupper-narrowlowershaped,pinchoutintothedeep(Fig.
12).
CaiandZhang(2001)indicatedthattheseenseismicfracturewaswedgeshapedfracturesonthewideupper-narrowlowerform.
Forsomebetteroverallstructureofrockmass,theopeningdegreewassmall,generallyonlyafewcentimeterstoadozencentimeters;Somerockmasswithpoorstructureandstructuralplanesignificantlydeveloped,theirfracturesopenedagreaterdegree.
Andtheseismicfractureslocatedaroundthetriggeringseismicfaultshadthewedge-shapedgapofwideupper-narrowlower,theopeningdegreeintopwasclosedto1m,itisillustratedtherockmassaroundthefaultswasseriousshattered.
Fig.
12SchematicsectionofseismicfractureTheshatteredwidthofSurveiedfractureswere20cmormore,inclinationanglegreaterthan60,extendedtodeepbyjagged-shaped,butitextendingtothedeep,theshatteredwidthbecamesmallergradually.
3.
4FillingcharacteristicsTheseseismicfractureswerelargeopeningdegreegenerally,fillinglessorno,overheadrockmass.
Thejointinterfacewasrelativelynewandbedrockexposed,straightorjagged,extendinglonger.
Wideupper-narrowlowershapedintheformoffractures,shatteredstonefragmentswerefilledinit.
Bothsidesofrockandsoilcollapsedwascausedbysomeseismicfractureswhichhadlargedegreeopening(Fig.
13).
Fig.
13Collapseinducedbythesloperockmasswereshattered4.
SeismicfracturemechanicsmechanismanalysisSeismicfracturewasmainlycausedbytheearthquakeforce.
Refractionandreflectionofseismicwavesoccurredinthestructuralplanewhentheseismicwavesaffectedit(Fig.
14),sotherockmassinstructuralplaneshatteredcrackduetothetensioncrackwhichcausedbytheaccumulatedstress(Zhangetal.
1993).
Theslopedamagecausedbyseismicforcewascloselyrelatedtotheeffectofseismicwaves,seismicwaveisdividedintoP-wave(longitudinalwave)andS-wave(shearwave),bothjointactionatthestructuralplaneofrockmass.
P-waveandS-wavewithfrequencyup-downandhorizontalvibration,thisgeneratedn-pull、anti-pullrepeatedstresstorockmassinthestructuralplane,androckmassinthestructuralplanecrackedopenalongthestructureplaneunderthedynamicactionofpowerfulearthquakeforce(Zhangetal.
2005;Fengetal.
2009;Newmark1965).
Theshearstrengthofstructureplanequicklylowerowningtoitsufferedrepeatedshearstress,rockmasswascuttedalongthestructureplanebytheactionofstrongshearstress,rockmassopenedanddeformed.
Myer(1990)studiedthepropagationcharacteristicsofseismicwavesthroughtherockmassjointsurfaceandtheforcebetweentherockmassinterfacecontrolledbytheCoulombcriterion.
Liang(2003)holdedthatthestructureplaneformedshatteredfacebytheearthquakeforce,therockmassabovethesurfacewouldoutoftheparentrockandcontinuetomovement,andtherockmassbelowthesurfacewouldgenerateanewfreesurfaceduetotheinfluenceofuppershatteredface.
Fig.
14SchematicdiagramofstresswavepropagationeffectedbythestructuralplaneSeismicfractureformedbytheprocessofrupture、perforation、extendinrockmass,internalfracturewasfurtherdevelopedintolargefractureintheslopeatlast.
Therupturedofrockmasswasmainlyduetoseismicwaves,Fig15showsasimplifiedseismicwavesschedulefigure,Fig16isafigureofsimplifiedequivalentstressintensityfactorcurves.
Usethefracturemechanicstheorytoanalysistheprocessofrupture、propagationandcrackarrestinrockmass(Li2010).
Fig.
15CurvediagramofFig.
16Curvediagramofseismicwavecoursestressintensityfactor4.
1FracturecriterionCombinedwithfracturemechanics,therupturecriterionofrockmassisthemaximumstressintensityfactorcriterion,lawofK,therockmasswillproducetensilefailureifthestressintensityisgreaterthanthefracturetoughness.
Attimet=0,seismicwavesisnotyetineffect,thestructureplaneonlyinthestaticstressfield,KIt2,theeffectcourseofseismicwaveswillenduntilt=t3.
Theeffectofseismicwaveswillstopaftert>t3,extendedfractureisinthestaticstressfield.
Ifthestressintensityfactorisstillgreaterthanthefracturetoughnessofrockmass,thefracturewillcontinuetoextendinthestaticstressfield,itstoptheextensionuntilt=t4.
4.
3CrackarrestevidenceAstheseismicintensitydecreases,theenergyreduce,thefracturestoprupturewhenthestressintensityfactorislessthanthefracturetoughness.
Forthestructuralplaneeffectedbystrongearthquakeforce,itmayhavehigherstressintensityfactoraftertheearthquakestop.
Thefractureinthestaticstressfieldmaycontinuetoextend、untilthecrackarrestconditionsismet.
5.
ConclusionsInsummary,throughdetailedinvestigationandanalysistothedeformationcharacteristics、deformationandfailuremechanisms、deformationkinematiccharacteristicsofslopeseismicfracture,theresultsshowthat:Basedonthemorphologicalcharacteristicsanddeformationdeformationfeaturesofslopeseismicfracture,theseismicfractureswasdividedintosixtypes:surfacetype、transfixingtype、striketype、tendencytype、closuretype、extensiontype.
Surfaceseismicfractureinaccordancewithitsextensioncharacteristicscouldbedividedintobrokenlinetype、Lineartype.
Fromitscombinationfeaturescanbedividedintoen-echelontype、crossovertype.
SlopeseismicfractureswasN30~60Etrending,theyweremainlydistributedinthevicinityofcausativefaultorridgespositionandsteepslowborderinslope.
Seismicfracturewaswellextension、highopendegree、obviousconnectivityandlargescale.
Upperwide-lowernarrowofprofilemorphology,pinchoutintothedeep,fillingslessorno.
Basedontherockfracturemechanicsmechanism,combinedwiththestressintensityfactortoanalysistheshatterdamagemechanismofthestructureplane.
Themechanicstypeofslopefracturesmainlybelongtothetensioncrack,rockstructureplanewouldrupturetogeneratecrackunderthedynamicaction,crackgraduallyextendtobecomethepenetratingtensionalseismicfracture.
AcknowledgementsFinancialsupportfromkeyprojectoftheNaturalScienceFoundationofChina(NSFC,NO.
40972195)andtheIndependentresearchoftheStatekeyLaboratoryofGeologicalHazardPrevention&GeologicalEnvironmentProtection(HGY-2012-08)isgratefullyacknowledged.
ReferencesLiangQG,HanWF(2009):Characteristicsofrockmassfailureunderseismicloadsatstrongearthquakeareas,JournalofNorthwesternSeismological,Vol.
31,pp.
15-20.
ShaoP(2005):Researchonthedynamiceffectofelasticwavesindiscontinuousjointedrockmass,ChinaUniversityofMiningandTechnologyPress,Xuzhou,China.
ZuoYJ,LiXB,ZhangYP(2008):Failureandfragmentationcharacteristicsofrockunderstatic-dynamiccouplingloading.
MetallurgicalIndustryPress,China.
XieGL(1988):GroundFissure.
SeismologicalPress,China.
LinJS,Whitman(1986):Earthquakeinduceddisplacementsofslidingblocks.
JournalofGeotechnical,No.
1,pp.
45-59.
Leonard,RJ(1929):AnearthfissureinsouthernArizona.
JournalofGeology,No.
8,pp.
765-774.
Holzer,TL,Gabrysch(1987):EffectifWater-levelrecoveriesonfaultCreep,Texas,GroundWater,No.
4,pp.
392-397.
CaiHC,ZhangJY,LiuRL,et(2001):ThefeatureandresearchingsignificanceofthegroundfissuresformedbyZhangbei6.
2earthquake.
NorthChinaEarthquakeSciences,Vol.
19,pp.
47-53.
ZhangZY,WangST,WangLS(1993):Principlesofengineeringgeology,GeologicalPublishingHouse,China.
ZhangZN,GeXR(2005):Fracturemodelofjointedrockmasssubjectedtoseismicloading.
ChineseJournalofRocksMechanicsandEngineering,Vol.
24,pp.
645-1648.
FengWK,XuQ,HuangRQ(2009):Preliminarystudyonmechanicalmechanismofslopeearthquake-induceddeformation,JournalofRockMechanicsandEngineering,Vol.
28,pp.
3124-3130.
NewmarkNM(1965):Effectsofearthquakesondamsandembankments.
Geotechnique,No.
2,pp.
l39-l60.
MyerL,Cook,NGW(1990):Effectsofsinglefracturesonseismicwavepropagation.
ProceedingsofISRMSymposiumonRockJoints:A.
ABalkema,pp.
467-475.
LiangQG,HanWF,etal(2003):Dissiononrockmassfailureunderseismicload,JournalofRockMechanicsandEngineering,No.
2,pp.
2783-2788.
LiSY,HeTM,YinXC(2010):Introductiontorockfracturemechanics,HefeiUniversityofScienceandTechnologyofChinaPress,China.
comAbstractNumerousshatteredslopestriggeredbywenchuanearthquake,theshatteringareawerelargeandtheseismicfractureswerewidedistribution,mostlythreatenedthepost-hazardreconstruction.
Accordingtothecharacteristicsofseismicfracturesinshatteredslopes,theresearchresultsshow:(1)Theseismicfractureswasdividedintosixtypes:surfacetype,transfixingtype,striketype,tendencytype,closuretype,extensiontypefromthroughsurveythemorphologicalcharacteristicsanddeformationindications;(2)OnthewholetheSeismicfractureswasN30~60Etrending,whichaccordswiththewholestrikeofactivefaultinwenchuanearthquake;(3)mainlydistributedinseismogenicfaultsareaorridge、andsteepwithslowborderarea;(4)wellextension,highopendegree,upperwideandlowernarrowofprofilemorphology,fillingslessorno,mainlymixedstonefragments,withaerialphenomena.
Basedonthetheoryoffracturemechanics,themechanismofseismicfractureswasbelongtotensilecrack,thedeformationandfailureprocessofstructuralplanesunderdynamicactionwasdividedintorupture,expansionandarrestabilitythreestages.
Keywords:wenchuanearthquake,shatteredrockmass,seismicfracture,geohazards1.
IntroductionTensofthousandsofcollapse,landslidesandsecondarygeologicaldisasterstriggeredbyWenchuanEarthquake.
Earthquakeinducedalargenumberofslopegeologicaldisasters,alsocausedapotentialdisaster—Slopeshattereddeformablebodywhichnamelyshatteredrockmass.
Theshatteredrockmassasageologicalphenomenon,itwasmainlyaffectedbytheearthquakeforceunderthecertaingeologicalconditions(Liangetal.
2003;Fengetal.
2009;Liangetal.
2009).
Thedynamiceffectofseismicwaveinrockmassdestroyedtherockmassstructure,itswholestructurevaried(Shao2005;Zuoetal.
2008).
Themosttypicalfeatureofslopeshatter-destroyedisthattheseismicfracturesdevelopedThedeformation,instabilityofshatteredrockmasshascontrolledbyseismicfractures,itisapotentialdisaster.
Theshatteredrockmasshasnomacrodestructionfeaturessuchaslargedeformation,largedisplacementasotherdestructionforms,itwasaninherentrockmassdamage,alsoitwasthemaincauseofsecondarydisastersaftertheearthquaketakenplacefrequently.
Studytheseseismicfractureshasimportantsignificancetorecognizethedeforma-tionandfailure,formationmechanismsofshatteredrockmasscorrectly.
2.
SeismicfractureclassificationsandfailurecharacteristicsTherockmassstructurewerecrackedopenbyearthquakeforce,sotheseismicfractureformed.
Theclassificationofseismicfractureshouldcorrespondstoitsformationmechanisms,nowtheclassificationresearchtofracturesmainlybasedonthevisual,intuitiveshapeofsurvey(Xie1988).
Theclassificationanalysistofracturesmainlybasedonitsdistribution,developmentcharacteristics,deformati-onfeatures,andmakeitpossibletopredictitsdeformationanddestruction.
Basedonthisconsideration,theseismicfractureswasdividedintosixtypes:surfacetype,transfixingtype,striketype,tendencytype,closuretyp,extensiontypefromthemorphologicalcharacteristicsanddeformationfeatures.
2.
1SurfacetypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsSurfacetypeseismicfracturewasrefertotherockmasssurfaceshatteredlongerlengthfromitscharacteristics,butitswidthandvisibledepthisgenerallysmall.
Smallscaleofsuchfracturesweredevelopedinallkindsofslopestructure,andthereisnoobviousdirectionaldistribution,itdistributedintherockmasssurface,andhadpoordeepinterconnectivity(Fig1).
(Ⅰ)(Ⅱ)Fig.
1SurfaceseismicfractureInaccordancewiththeextensioncharacteristicsofsurfacetypeseismicfracturecanbedividedintobrokenlinetype,Lineartype.
Fromitscombinationfeaturescanbedividedintoen-echelontype,crossovertype.
[1]brokenlinetype:Thespreadingdirectioninplaneofseismicfractureswasturning、bentpointofthepolylineorarc-shaped,andthencontinuetoextend(Fig.
1Ⅰ).
[2]Lineartype:Theoverallspreadingdirectioninplaneofseismicfractureswasextendedstraight,littlechangeindirection,nosignificantturningorbendingintheprocessofextending(Fig.
1Ⅱ).
[3]En-echelontype:itformedbyaseriesofseismicfractureswhosedirectionsubstantiallythesame,en-echelondistributionpresentedontheplane,seismicfractureswerebrokenlineorlineartype(Fig2).
Fig.
2Distributionschematicdiagramofen-echelontypeseismicfracture[4]crossovertype:itformedbythetwoorthreegroupsofseismicfractureswhoseextensiondirectionweredifferent,crosseachother,thedistributionshapeontheplanewas"X"or"Y"shaped(Fig3).
(Ⅰ)"X"shapedseismicfracture(Ⅱ)"Y"shapedseismicfractureFig.
3CrossovertypeseismicfractureSurfaceseismicfracturewereexistintherockmasssurface,theycan'tcontrolthedeformation、instabilityofrockmass.
However,thistypeofseismicfracturesdistributedgenerally,higherdensitydevelopedinlocalposition,therebyitdestroyedtheoverallstructureofrockmass.
Anditeasytobecomeagoodwaytorainwaterinfiltrationwhenexperiencerainfallconditions.
2.
2TransfixingtypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsComparativelyspeakingtoseismicfracturesurface,thetransfixingseismicfracturenotonlylongextendinglength,butalsolargeopeningdegree,visibledepthwasupto10m.
Thefracturehadgoodinterconnectivity,linearextensioninplane,jointinterfacejagged,throughoutinsidetherockmassbytheformofpinch-out.
Forsurvey,themajorityofseismicfracturesbelongtothistype(Fig.
4).
Fig.
4SeismicfracturethroughoutinsiderockmassThedevelopmentscaleofransfixingseismicfractureswerelargeandhadgoodinterconnectivity,itcausedsignificantdamagetorockmassstructureandaffectthedeformationandinstabilityofrockmass.
Throughtheinvestigationoffracturesonslope,suchfracturesdevelopedinbetterpositionasslopetop,steepslowborder,freefacetoformedthetrailingedgeorsideedgeboundaryofcuttingrockmass,itbecomethemaincontrollingfactorsofshatteredrockmassstability.
Seismicfracturescuttingrockmasstoformedthedangerousrockbodyonslope(Fig.
5).
Fig.
5DangerousrockformedbyseismicfracturecuttingSeismicfractureswasfillinglessorno.
Theycouldfurtherextendedwhenencounteredtherainfallorvibrateinterference.
Whenthefracturescontinuedtorunthroughthelockedsegmentinshatteredrockmass,thelockedsegmentcouldsuddenlysnippedoncethetensilestressofrockmasswasgreaterthanthetensilestrengtundertheactionofgravity,earthquakeforceevenwind.
Thendangerousrockseparatedfromthematernalrocktodropandformedrollingrock.
Throughthecollapsesinvestigation,theperforateseismicfracturesbecamethemaincontrollingfactorofcollapsedisastersafterearthquake.
Suchseismicfracturesweredevelopedinalargescal、stronginterconnectivity,theyoftencausedgreatcollapsehazard.
2.
3StriketypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsAccordingtotheextensiondirectionofseismicfractures,thestriketypeseismicfracturewasrefertoitslengthalongthestrikedirectionwaslargerthanalongthedipdirection,fracturedevelopedmainlyalongitsstrike.
Theextensiondirectionofstriketypeseismicfracturewasidenticalorsimilartothedirectionoftectonicforce(suchasthestrikeoffault).
Theseseismicfracturesextendedalongitsstrike,theyhadstrongdirectional(Fig6).
Sincethistypeofseismicfracturesdevelopedwasmainlyduetotheeffectoftectonicforce,sotheirdevelopmentalscaleweregenerallylarger.
Fig.
6SeismicfracturedevelopednearthefaultStriketypeseismicfracturesexposedonslopebylesserextentofsubjectedtotheinfluenceofterrainandsurfacefeatures,theirextensionlengthalongthestrikedirectionwaslarge.
Seismicfracturesweremainlydistributedinthevicinityoffault.
Itwasduetothestrongearthquakeforceexistedatthefault,higherdegreeofrockmassshattered,fracturescouldeasilydevelopedalongthestrikedirectionoffault.
Andseismicfractureswhichexistedatotherlocations,owningtotheirextendprocesswaslimitedbytheinfluenceofterrainandsurfacefeatures,sothecharacteristicsalongthestrikeextensionwasnotobvious.
ThestrikeofthistypeseismicfracturewasN30~60Ebyfieldinvestigation,seismicfractureswhichdevelopedalongtheirstrikedirectionwerelocatedinthevicinityoffault.
Thelengthalongstrikeofstriketypeseismicfracturewaslonger,itcouldconstitutedtheinstabilityrangeboundaryofshatteredrockmassandcontrolledawiderangeofrockmassunstable.
Therockmassstructurearoundthistypeofseismicfractureswaspoor,higherdegreeofshatter-damaged.
Oncetheshatteredrockmassproduceddeformationandinstability,majordestructiveformed.
2.
4TendencytypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsThetendencytypeseismicfracturewasrefertoitsextensiondirectionmainlyalongitsdipdirection.
Forthedevelopmentalmorphology,thelengthalongdipdirectionwasgreaterthanalongitsstrikedirection,itsdevelopmentwasextendedintothedeepofrockmass.
Thistypeofseismicfracturesdevelopedinvariouslocationsonslope,especiallydevelopedatridge、steepwithslowborderarea.
Mostseismicfracturesbelongedtothistendencytypethroughinvestigatedonslope.
Althoughitslengthexposedongroundwasshort,owningtoitwasextendedintothedeepalongitsdipdirection,itsvisibledepthwasupto10minthedeepofrockmass.
Therearecertaindistributioncharacteristicsinsuchseismicfractures,theLaddertype、"Y"-shapetypeandTrace-backtypehadpresentedinthemorphologyofprofilecombination(Fig.
7).
Laddertypeseismicfractureswascharacterizedbyaseriesoffractureswhichinclined、extendedtothesamedirection,parallelornearlyparalleltoeachother.
Duetothevisibledepthlimitedinsuchseismicfractures,sothistypefracturesmayalsointersectedinthedeeperpositionofrockmass.
Thecharacteristicsof"Y"-shapetypeseismicfractureswasthataseriesofdifferenttendenciesseismicfracturescrossedintheextendprocesstothedeep,"Y"-shapepresentedintheprofile.
Trace-backtypeseismicfracturewasrefertothefracturesoccurredoneormorebranches,thesecondaryseismicfractureswhichcontinuousorintermittentappearedinitsextendprocessintothedeep.
Fig.
7CombinationschematicdiagramoftendencytypeseismicfracturesTendencytypeseismicfracturescuttingrockmass,constitutedtheinstabilityboundariesofshatteredrockmass,formeddangerousrockhangedontheslope.
Owningtothelengthofseismicfractureextendingtodeep,goodcontinuitywithaerialphenomenon,itoftenbecomeagoodchannelforrainwater、groundwaterinfiltration,couldeasilycausetheinstabilityofshatteredrockmasstocollapse.
Thistypeofseismicfractureswaswidedistributiononslope,sotheformationofdamageisrelativelylarge.
2.
5ClosuretypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsFortheextendingtrendenceinthedistributionplaneofseismicfractures,thejointinterfaceonthistypeoffracturesuneveninextensionprocess,atbothendsofthefractureclosedornearlyclosed,buttheintermediateportionisopen,smallopeningwidth(Fig.
8).
Fig.
8ClosuretypeseismicfractureClosuretypeseismicfracturesweremainlydistributedinthebetterpartsofrockmassstructure.
Thebettertheoverallstructureofrockmass,thelessdamageextentbyseismicforcestotherockmassstructure.
Seismicfracturesoccurredbyrockmasstensioncrackintheextendingprocesswasrestricted,itdiscontinuousdistributedbytheformofbeaded-shapeinslopesurface.
Thisfracturewassmalldegreeopening,thejointinterfaceonbothsidesinrockmassgraduallyfillingatlaterundertheactionofgravity、fracturedeposits.
Sincethistypeofseismicfracturesintermittentdistributed,poorcontinuity,smalldegreeopening,thejointinterfacegraduallyhealinglater,devastatinglimited,butitdiscontinuousdistributedintheslopesurface,withacertaindegreeofductility,itdestroiedtheoverallstructureofslope.
Seismicfracturefillinglessorno,overheadrockmass,itcouldconstituteagoodchannelforrainwater、groundwaterinfiltration.
Onceitconnectwithotherfractureswhichwaslargeopening、goodcontinuity、stronginterconnectivity,thesefracturescouldcausecrackingscaling,acceleratingtherockmassdeformationinstability,sodestructive.
2.
6ExtendedtypeseismicfracturefeaturesandfailurecharacteristicsExtendedtypeseismicfracturereferstoitsextensioninthesection,oneendwasgraduallyopen,andextendedtotheslopesurfacewithopeninggraduallylarge,oneendgraduallypinchoutintothedeep,andhadthewedge-shapedgapofwideupper-narrowlower.
Thiskindsoffractureswaslargeopeningdegree,fillinglessorno,thejointinterfacewasroughandjagged(Fig.
9).
Fig.
9ExtendedtypeseismicfractureThroughslopeseismicfracturesinvestigation,thefracturewhichwaswideupper-narrowlowershapedinsection,largedegreeopening,overheadrockmass.
Itmostlybelongtotheextensionseismicfracture.
Thisseismicfractureformatedbythehighdegreeofshatterdamagedcausedbyseismicforcestotherockmassstructure,severelydamaged,thedevelopmentoffracturesextendedalongthedirectionofseismicforce.
Usingthetheoryoffracturemechanics,fracturesbegintoexpandwhenitstipstressintensityfactorisgreaterthanrockmassintensityfactorbyseismicforce,thiscanberoughlydividedintothreestages:initialshatteredstage,fractureformed,developmentstage,fracturepropagation、extendingtosurfacestage(Linetal.
1986).
Extendedtypeseismicfractureswerewidelydevelopedontheslopesaccordingtothesurvey,especiallydevelopedatcrest、ridgeorsteepwithslowborderarea,acertainsizedistributed.
Thisseismicfracturesnotonlydestroiedtherockmassstructure,butalsolargedegreeopening,overheadrockmass.
Aftertheearthquake,frequentaftershocks、rainfallandwindforceswereconstantlychangedthestateofshatteredrockmassbalance,thesemadetheseismicfracturescontinuestoexpand、extend.
Thesefracturesleadtherockmassinstabilityandcollapse.
3.
SeismicfracturedevelopmentcharacteristicsInvestigatedthebasiccharacteristicsofseismicfractures,theirspread、developmentcharacteristics、deformationsignshadsomecorrespondingcharacteristics.
3.
1SpatialdistributioncharacteristicsSeismicfractureswasN30~60Etrending(Fig.
10),itisbasicallythesamewiththetriggeringseismicfaultsinWenchuanearthquake,theextensiondirectionoffractureshasobviouslyeffectedbythetriggeringseismicfault.
Somelargerdegreeofshatteredopeningfracturesspreadbylinearshaped,goodextension,generallynotsubjectedtotheinfluenceoftheterrainandsurfacefeaturesinitsextendingdirection.
Someseismicfractureswerecorrespondingwiththefaultwhichinfluencedtheirdevelopment.
Americanscholars(Leonard1929;Holzeretal.
1987)putforwardedtheviewoftectonicorigininseismicfracturesbyanalysistheearthquakeforce,theythinkedthetectonicisthedominantfactorinformationanddevelopmentofseismicfractures.
Fig.
10StatisticalgraphoftypicalseismicfracturesThedistributionofseismicfracturesweremainlyduetotheeffectoftriggeringseismicfaults,theyweremainlydistributedinthevicinityofcausativefaultorridgespositionandsteepslowborderinslope,thesepositionswerealsothesiteofstrongseismicforce.
3.
2ExtendedlengthcharacteristicsTheextensionlengthofseismicfracturereferstoitscontinuouslengthexposedontheslopesurface.
Thefracturesextendedlengthgenerallylonger,morethan6m.
Someshatteredseriousfractureswasupto10minlength,portionextendedtothetopofslope.
Collapsepit、tensionalslotwereexposedintheprocessofextending(Fig.
11).
Largenumberofsecondaryseismicfracturesweredistributedaroundthemainseismicfractures.
Thesecondaryseismicfracturesdiscontinuousdistributedandpoorcontinuity.
Fig.
11Tensilegroovedeveloped3.
3OpeningdegreecharacteristicsTheopeningdegreeofseismicfracturemainlyreferstothewidthofcrackinrockandsoilmassbyshockedtensionintheearthquakeforce.
Throughthesurvey,theopeningdegreeofseismicfracturewastheformofwideupper-narrowlowershaped,pinchoutintothedeep(Fig.
12).
CaiandZhang(2001)indicatedthattheseenseismicfracturewaswedgeshapedfracturesonthewideupper-narrowlowerform.
Forsomebetteroverallstructureofrockmass,theopeningdegreewassmall,generallyonlyafewcentimeterstoadozencentimeters;Somerockmasswithpoorstructureandstructuralplanesignificantlydeveloped,theirfracturesopenedagreaterdegree.
Andtheseismicfractureslocatedaroundthetriggeringseismicfaultshadthewedge-shapedgapofwideupper-narrowlower,theopeningdegreeintopwasclosedto1m,itisillustratedtherockmassaroundthefaultswasseriousshattered.
Fig.
12SchematicsectionofseismicfractureTheshatteredwidthofSurveiedfractureswere20cmormore,inclinationanglegreaterthan60,extendedtodeepbyjagged-shaped,butitextendingtothedeep,theshatteredwidthbecamesmallergradually.
3.
4FillingcharacteristicsTheseseismicfractureswerelargeopeningdegreegenerally,fillinglessorno,overheadrockmass.
Thejointinterfacewasrelativelynewandbedrockexposed,straightorjagged,extendinglonger.
Wideupper-narrowlowershapedintheformoffractures,shatteredstonefragmentswerefilledinit.
Bothsidesofrockandsoilcollapsedwascausedbysomeseismicfractureswhichhadlargedegreeopening(Fig.
13).
Fig.
13Collapseinducedbythesloperockmasswereshattered4.
SeismicfracturemechanicsmechanismanalysisSeismicfracturewasmainlycausedbytheearthquakeforce.
Refractionandreflectionofseismicwavesoccurredinthestructuralplanewhentheseismicwavesaffectedit(Fig.
14),sotherockmassinstructuralplaneshatteredcrackduetothetensioncrackwhichcausedbytheaccumulatedstress(Zhangetal.
1993).
Theslopedamagecausedbyseismicforcewascloselyrelatedtotheeffectofseismicwaves,seismicwaveisdividedintoP-wave(longitudinalwave)andS-wave(shearwave),bothjointactionatthestructuralplaneofrockmass.
P-waveandS-wavewithfrequencyup-downandhorizontalvibration,thisgeneratedn-pull、anti-pullrepeatedstresstorockmassinthestructuralplane,androckmassinthestructuralplanecrackedopenalongthestructureplaneunderthedynamicactionofpowerfulearthquakeforce(Zhangetal.
2005;Fengetal.
2009;Newmark1965).
Theshearstrengthofstructureplanequicklylowerowningtoitsufferedrepeatedshearstress,rockmasswascuttedalongthestructureplanebytheactionofstrongshearstress,rockmassopenedanddeformed.
Myer(1990)studiedthepropagationcharacteristicsofseismicwavesthroughtherockmassjointsurfaceandtheforcebetweentherockmassinterfacecontrolledbytheCoulombcriterion.
Liang(2003)holdedthatthestructureplaneformedshatteredfacebytheearthquakeforce,therockmassabovethesurfacewouldoutoftheparentrockandcontinuetomovement,andtherockmassbelowthesurfacewouldgenerateanewfreesurfaceduetotheinfluenceofuppershatteredface.
Fig.
14SchematicdiagramofstresswavepropagationeffectedbythestructuralplaneSeismicfractureformedbytheprocessofrupture、perforation、extendinrockmass,internalfracturewasfurtherdevelopedintolargefractureintheslopeatlast.
Therupturedofrockmasswasmainlyduetoseismicwaves,Fig15showsasimplifiedseismicwavesschedulefigure,Fig16isafigureofsimplifiedequivalentstressintensityfactorcurves.
Usethefracturemechanicstheorytoanalysistheprocessofrupture、propagationandcrackarrestinrockmass(Li2010).
Fig.
15CurvediagramofFig.
16Curvediagramofseismicwavecoursestressintensityfactor4.
1FracturecriterionCombinedwithfracturemechanics,therupturecriterionofrockmassisthemaximumstressintensityfactorcriterion,lawofK,therockmasswillproducetensilefailureifthestressintensityisgreaterthanthefracturetoughness.
Attimet=0,seismicwavesisnotyetineffect,thestructureplaneonlyinthestaticstressfield,KIt2,theeffectcourseofseismicwaveswillenduntilt=t3.
Theeffectofseismicwaveswillstopaftert>t3,extendedfractureisinthestaticstressfield.
Ifthestressintensityfactorisstillgreaterthanthefracturetoughnessofrockmass,thefracturewillcontinuetoextendinthestaticstressfield,itstoptheextensionuntilt=t4.
4.
3CrackarrestevidenceAstheseismicintensitydecreases,theenergyreduce,thefracturestoprupturewhenthestressintensityfactorislessthanthefracturetoughness.
Forthestructuralplaneeffectedbystrongearthquakeforce,itmayhavehigherstressintensityfactoraftertheearthquakestop.
Thefractureinthestaticstressfieldmaycontinuetoextend、untilthecrackarrestconditionsismet.
5.
ConclusionsInsummary,throughdetailedinvestigationandanalysistothedeformationcharacteristics、deformationandfailuremechanisms、deformationkinematiccharacteristicsofslopeseismicfracture,theresultsshowthat:Basedonthemorphologicalcharacteristicsanddeformationdeformationfeaturesofslopeseismicfracture,theseismicfractureswasdividedintosixtypes:surfacetype、transfixingtype、striketype、tendencytype、closuretype、extensiontype.
Surfaceseismicfractureinaccordancewithitsextensioncharacteristicscouldbedividedintobrokenlinetype、Lineartype.
Fromitscombinationfeaturescanbedividedintoen-echelontype、crossovertype.
SlopeseismicfractureswasN30~60Etrending,theyweremainlydistributedinthevicinityofcausativefaultorridgespositionandsteepslowborderinslope.
Seismicfracturewaswellextension、highopendegree、obviousconnectivityandlargescale.
Upperwide-lowernarrowofprofilemorphology,pinchoutintothedeep,fillingslessorno.
Basedontherockfracturemechanicsmechanism,combinedwiththestressintensityfactortoanalysistheshatterdamagemechanismofthestructureplane.
Themechanicstypeofslopefracturesmainlybelongtothetensioncrack,rockstructureplanewouldrupturetogeneratecrackunderthedynamicaction,crackgraduallyextendtobecomethepenetratingtensionalseismicfracture.
AcknowledgementsFinancialsupportfromkeyprojectoftheNaturalScienceFoundationofChina(NSFC,NO.
40972195)andtheIndependentresearchoftheStatekeyLaboratoryofGeologicalHazardPrevention&GeologicalEnvironmentProtection(HGY-2012-08)isgratefullyacknowledged.
ReferencesLiangQG,HanWF(2009):Characteristicsofrockmassfailureunderseismicloadsatstrongearthquakeareas,JournalofNorthwesternSeismological,Vol.
31,pp.
15-20.
ShaoP(2005):Researchonthedynamiceffectofelasticwavesindiscontinuousjointedrockmass,ChinaUniversityofMiningandTechnologyPress,Xuzhou,China.
ZuoYJ,LiXB,ZhangYP(2008):Failureandfragmentationcharacteristicsofrockunderstatic-dynamiccouplingloading.
MetallurgicalIndustryPress,China.
XieGL(1988):GroundFissure.
SeismologicalPress,China.
LinJS,Whitman(1986):Earthquakeinduceddisplacementsofslidingblocks.
JournalofGeotechnical,No.
1,pp.
45-59.
Leonard,RJ(1929):AnearthfissureinsouthernArizona.
JournalofGeology,No.
8,pp.
765-774.
Holzer,TL,Gabrysch(1987):EffectifWater-levelrecoveriesonfaultCreep,Texas,GroundWater,No.
4,pp.
392-397.
CaiHC,ZhangJY,LiuRL,et(2001):ThefeatureandresearchingsignificanceofthegroundfissuresformedbyZhangbei6.
2earthquake.
NorthChinaEarthquakeSciences,Vol.
19,pp.
47-53.
ZhangZY,WangST,WangLS(1993):Principlesofengineeringgeology,GeologicalPublishingHouse,China.
ZhangZN,GeXR(2005):Fracturemodelofjointedrockmasssubjectedtoseismicloading.
ChineseJournalofRocksMechanicsandEngineering,Vol.
24,pp.
645-1648.
FengWK,XuQ,HuangRQ(2009):Preliminarystudyonmechanicalmechanismofslopeearthquake-induceddeformation,JournalofRockMechanicsandEngineering,Vol.
28,pp.
3124-3130.
NewmarkNM(1965):Effectsofearthquakesondamsandembankments.
Geotechnique,No.
2,pp.
l39-l60.
MyerL,Cook,NGW(1990):Effectsofsinglefracturesonseismicwavepropagation.
ProceedingsofISRMSymposiumonRockJoints:A.
ABalkema,pp.
467-475.
LiangQG,HanWF,etal(2003):Dissiononrockmassfailureunderseismicload,JournalofRockMechanicsandEngineering,No.
2,pp.
2783-2788.
LiSY,HeTM,YinXC(2010):Introductiontorockfracturemechanics,HefeiUniversityofScienceandTechnologyofChinaPress,China.
- extendedxyq.cbg.163.com相关文档
- setxyq.cbg.163.com
- 23.xyq.cbg.163.com
- DWGxyq.cbg.163.com
- VM02xyq.cbg.163.com
- VWxyq.cbg.163.com
- statusxyq.cbg.163.com
这几个Vultr VPS主机商家的优点造就商家的用户驱动力
目前云服务器市场竞争是相当的大的，比如我们在年中活动中看到各大服务商都找准这个噱头的活动发布各种活动，有的甚至就是平时的活动价格，只是换一个说法而已。可见这个行业确实竞争很大，当然我们也可以看到很多主机商几个月就消失，也有看到很多个人商家捣鼓几个品牌然后忽悠一圈跑路的。当然，个人建议在选择服务商的时候尽量选择老牌商家，这样性能更为稳定一些。近期可能会准备重新整理Vultr商家的一些信息和教程。以前...
UCloud：美国云服务器,洛杉矶节点大促,低至7元起/1个月
ucloud美国云服务器怎么样?ucloud是国内知名云计算品牌服务商家，目前推出全球多地机房的海外云服务器。UCloud主打的优势是海外多机房，目前正在进行的2021全球大促活动参与促销的云服务器机房就多达18个。UCloud新一代旗舰产品快杰云服务器已上线洛杉矶节点，覆盖北美和亚太地区，火热促销中， 首月低至7元，轻松体验具备优秀性能与极高性价比的快杰云服务器。点击进入：ucloud美国洛杉矶...
HaloCloud：日本软银vps100M/200M/500M带宽,，¥45.00元/月
halocloud怎么样?halocloud是一个于2019下半年建立的商家，主要提供日本软银VPS，广州移动VDS，株洲联通VDS，广州移动独立服务器，Halo邮局服务，Azure香港1000M带宽月抛机器等。日本软银vps,100M/200M/500M带宽,可看奈飞,香港azure1000M带宽，可以解锁奈飞等流媒体，有需要看奈飞的朋友可以入手!点击进入：halocloud官方网站地址日本vp...
xyq.cbg.163.com为你推荐
-
淘宝门户分析淘宝网、三大门户网站、易趣、阿里巴巴属于哪种电子商务模式咏春大师被ko练咏春拳的杨师傅对阵散打冠军，注:是高龄级别被冠军级别打败了，那如果是咏春冠军叶问呢？更别说是李小微信回应封杀钉钉微信违规操作被封了，留学生认证留学生的学位证书怎样认证？mole.61.com摩尔庄园RK的秘密是什么？www.mywife.ccMywife-No 00357 MANAMI SAITO种子下载地址有么？求好心人给bbs2.99nets.com这个"风情东南亚"网站有78kg.cn做网址又用bbs.风情东南亚.cn那么多此一举啊!www.zhiboba.com上什么网看哪个电视台直播NBAyinrentangweichentang产品功效好不好？www.zzzcn.com哪里有免费看书的网站