diagramps半透明
ps半透明 时间:2021-02-22 阅读:()
THEASTROPHYSICALJOURNAL,516:917,1999May11999.
TheAmericanAstronomicalSociety.
Allrightsreserved.
PrintedinU.
S.
A.
(RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARSDONG-WOOKIM1ChungnamNationalUniversity,Taejon,305-764,SouthKoreaANDMARTINELVISHarvard-SmithsonianCenterforAstrophysics,60GardenStreet,Cambridge,MA02138Received1998May11;accepted1998December8ABSTRACTWehaveperformedasuccessfultargetedsearchforapopulationofred,radio-quiet,andprobablyabsorbedquasars.
Radio-quiet,opticallyredROSATPSPCX-raysourcesbrighterthan1]10~13ergscm~2s~1weresearchedforred(O[E[2.
0,O20)counterpartsintheAutomatedPlate-measuringMachinecatalogofPalomarSkySurveyobjects.
Of45objectsforwhichweobtainedadequatefollow-upopticalspectroscopy,wehavefoundsevenredquasars,vewithTheirredshiftsrangeaopt\[2.
from0.
06to0.
31,andtheirluminositiesaremoderate,lyingonthequasar/Seyfertboundary.
Theseredquasarsstrengthenthecaseforaradio-quietpopulationthatisthecounterpartoftheradio-loudredquasarsfoundbySmith&SpinradandWebsteretal.
Unidentied,faintersourcescouldincreasethefractionofredquasarsbyuptoafactorof7.
Fortheredquasarsfoundhere,theHa/Hbratios,opticalslope,andX-raycolorsallindicatethattheyareabsorbedbyratherthanhavingintrinsicallyredAVD2spectra.
ThisamountofobscurationseemstohideD1%7%ofquasarsatagivenobserveduxorD3%20%whentheiruxesarecorrectedtotheirintrinsicvalues.
Thissizeofpopulationisconsistentwithearlierlimits,withpredictedvaluesfromComastrietal.
,andiscomparablewiththeratefoundamongradio-loudquasars.
Alargepopulationofmoreheavilyabsorbedfainterquasarsequal(AV\5),insizetothebluepopulationcouldexistwithoutviolatingexistingupperlimits,whichisinaccordwiththeComastrietal.
predictions.
Subjectheadings:dust,extinctionquasars:generalX-rays:galaxies1.
INTRODUCTIONQuasarsarethecanonical""ultravioletexcessobjects(Sandage1965).
Yetredquasarshavebeenfoundinradio-selectedsamplesbySmith&Spinrad(1980)andWebsteretal.
(1995).
Websteretal.
(1995)proposedthatalargefrac-tion,perhaps80%,ofradio-loudquasarsmighthavebeenhiddenasredobjects.
Moreover,thecurrentlyfavoredexplanationsforthecosmicX-raybackgroundinvokeapopulationofheavilyobscuredactivegalacticnuclei(AGNs)5timesmorecommonthantheunobscuredpopu-lation(Comastrietal.
1995).
Ifthesmallnumberofknownredquasarsreallyisthe""tipoftheicebergofalarge,evendominant,quasarpopulation,thentheconsequenceswouldbeinteresting:theoverallAGNpopulationandsothemassiveblackholepopulationmaybe5timeslargerthanhadbeenthought;obscuredquasarswouldbealong-livedevolutionaryphase(seeSandersetal.
1988),orallquasarsmaybehiddenalong80%ofpossiblelinesofsight;andredquasarsmaycontributeimportantlytothecosmicX-raybackground.
TheWebsteretal.
conclusioniswidelydis-puted.
Boyle&diMatteo(1995),Stickeletal.
(1996),andBennetal.
(1998)allarguethatanymissingpopulationmustbesmallerandperhapsinsignicant,whileGunn&Shanks(1998)disagree.
HerewepresentanX-raybasedsurveytargetedexplicitlyatredAGNstondradio-quietredquasars.
Radio-loudredquasarsarerelativelyeasytond,sincetheradioemissionisunaectedbyabsorbinggasordustand,inlow-frequencysurveys,usuallycomesfromthelargeradiolobesthatliewelloutsideanyobscuringmaterialin1AlsoatHarvard-SmithsonianCenterforAstrophysics,60GardenStreet,Cambridge,MA02138.
thehostgalaxy.
Anexplicit,albeitsmall-scale,searchforradio-andX-rayloudbutopticallyquietquasars,whichshouldincludereddenedquasars,was,however,notsuc-cessful(Kollgaardetal.
1995).
Radio-quietredquasarsaremuchhardertond,althoughtheymightbeexpectedtobemuchmorecommon.
Inthenormalunreddenedpopulation,radio-quietquasarsoutnumberradio-loudquasars10to1(e.
g.
,theExtendedMediumSensitivitySurvey,Stockeetal.
1991;thePalomarGreencatalog[PG],Kellermanetal.
1989).
However,mostopticalquasarsurveysareactivelybiasedagainstndingredquasars.
SincethesesurveysprimarilysearchforUV-brightobjects(e.
g.
,Markarian,Lipovetsky,Markarian,&Stepanian1987;PG,Schmidt&Green1983;theLargeBrightQuasarSurvey,Hewett,Foltz,&Chaee1995;theHamburgQuasarSurvey,Engelsetal.
1998),theyareblindtoredobjects.
Asaresult,opticalboundsonhowlargeapopulationofradio-quietredquasarsmightexistareweak.
X-rayselectionprovidesawayofselectingredquasarsefficiently:hardX-rays(210keV)penetrateeventensofmagnitudesofopticalextinctionwithminimalabsorption.
EventhelowerenergybandofROSAT(0.
52.
5keV)isnotstronglyaectedbyopticalextinctionofuptoD2mag.
2Astrophysicsmightbeagainstus,sincealthoughbluequasarsareoverwhelminglyX-rayloud(Avni&Tanan-baum1986),redonesmightbeintrinsicallyX-rayfaint.
Fortunately,however,radio-loudredquasarsareknowntobeX-raysources(Bregmanetal.
1985;Elvisetal.
1994),sothisisunlikelytobeaproblem.
2ForstandardMilkyWaycompositionanddust-to-gasratio(Bohlin,Savage,&Drake1978;Seaton1979)thePSPCcountrateisreducedbyafactorof1/eatatomscm~2)forapower-lawAV\1.
7(NH\3]1021photonindexof2.
0,allat0redshift.
910KIM&ELVISVol.
516Completeux-limitedX-raysurveyshavefoundsomeredquasarsorAGNs(Stockeetal.
1982;Kruper&Canizares1989;Puchnarewiczetal.
1996,1997).
InparticulartheROSATInternationalX-Ray/OpticalSurvey(RIXOS)survey(Puchnarewicz&Mason1998)hasidentiedasmallsampleofredquasars.
AspartofamoregeneralsearchforminoritypopulationsofX-raysources,wehaveusedtheROSAT1983)(TrumperarchiveofpointedPSPC(Pfeermanetal.
1987)datatodesignanefficientsearchstrategyexplicitlytargetingredquasars.
TheROSATpointedarchiveprovidesuswithatenfoldincreaseinthenumberofX-raysourcesfrombeforeROSAT(toabout70,000)andreachesmorethan10timesfainterthantheROSATAll-SkySurvey(Vogesetal.
1996).
Bycarefullyselectingasmallnumberofinterestingobjects,wecanmakeanefficientsearchforaradio-quietpopulationofredquasars.
Inthispaperwendasubstantialpopulationofradio-quietredAGNsonthequasar/Seyfertluminositybound-ary.
2.
SAMPLESELECTIONMostROSATsourcesathighGalacticlatitudeareblue,unobscuredAGNs(e.
g.
,Boyle,Wilkes,&Elvis1997;Schmidtetal.
1997).
WeusethisfacttoefficientlyselectagainstsuchobjectsandsoisolateanyredAGNthatmaybeintheROSATarchive.
AsacompendiumoftheX-raysourcesfoundbytheROSATPSPCwehaveusedthe""WGACATcatalog(whichisnamedafteritsauthors,White,Giommi,&Angel-ini1995).
ThiscatalogwasgeneratedfromROSATPSPCpointedobservationsusingaslidingcell,detectalgorithm.
Thismethodissensitivetondingpointsourcesbutcanalsondspurioussourceswhereextendedemissionispresent.
WGACATincludesaqualityagthatnotessuchdubiousdetectionsbasedonavisualinspectionoftheelds.
WehaveonlyusedX-raysourceswithhighdetectionqualityinordertoexcludethespurioussources.
FromtheWGACATcatalogwehaveselectedsourcesbythefollow-ingcriteria:1.
X-raybrightergscm~2s~1)toallow(fX[10~13follow-upobservationswithotherX-raytelescopes;2.
welldetectedwithasignal-to-noiseratiogreaterthan10andaWGACATqualityag,DQFLAG,greaterthan5;3.
withinr\18@fromthedetectorcentertoprovidegoodpositions;4.
athighgalacticlatitude(obo[20)tominimizethefractionofGalacticstars(whicharealsored);5.
notwithin2@ofthetargetposition(atwhichpointthesourcedensityreachesthebackgroundlevel)toselectonlyrandom,serendipitous,sources;6.
northofdecl.
\[18inordertohavetwobandmea-surementsintheAutomatedPlate-measuringMachine(APM)catalog(McMahon&Irwin1992),hencegivinganarchivalopticalcolor;and7.
unidentied,withWGACATclass\9999andnoSIMBADorNASAExtragalacticDatabaseidentication.
3Therstsixcriteriaselected1624sources.
SincethesesourceswereselectedpurelyontheirX-rayproperties,theyformawell-denedsamplefromwhichtostudytheinci-denceofminorityX-raypopulations,includinganyradio-quietredquasars.
Addingtherequirementthatasourcebeunidentiedleft940X-raysourcesthatcouldbeexaminedforhavingredopticalcounterparts.
WethensearchedtheAPMcatalogofobjectsdetectedonthePalomarSkySurveyforopticalcounterpartstotheunidentiedX-raysources.
Tondcounterparts,weusedasearchradiusof26A,whichcorrespondstoabout95%con-denceforX-raysourceswithin18@ofthePSPCdetectorcenter(Boyleetal.
1995a).
Ofthese,881sourceshadAPMcatalogcounterpartsbrighterthanthelimitingmagnitudesO\21.
5andE\20.
(Theremaining""blankeldsarethe3Althoughonly""unidentiedsourceswereselected,one(1WGAJ1118.
0]4505;Table1)turnedouttobeaknownSeyfert1(Badeetal.
1995).
Fig.
1aFig.
1bFIG.
1.
(a)OpticallyidentiedEMSSsourcesintheplane.
Dierentsourcesaremarkedbydierentsymbols.
Oursource-selectioncriteriaaox-(O[E)(O[E[2,areseenasalowerrightbox.
(b)Sameas(a)butforourROSATsamples.
Thelineshowshowaslightlystrictercriterionyieldsaaox\1.
8)aoxlargerfractionofredquasars.
No.
1,1999RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARS11subjectofanotherstudy;Elvis,Kim,&Nicastro1999.
)Amongthese881,manyhadonlyO-bandmagnitudes(suggestingthattheyareblue),leaving575withO[Ecolorsavailable.
ThecombinationoftheROSATX-rayuxandtheAPMmagnitudesallowsustocreatearoughclassicationoftheX-raysourcesinoursample.
ThetwoPalomarO(blue)andE(red)magnitudesareclosetoJohnsonBandCousinsR,respectively(Greggetal.
1996).
FromtheX-rayuxandthetwoopticalmagnitudeswecanconstructatwo-colordiagramofisdenedbythepower-lawindexaox-(O[E).
aoxbetween2keVand2500(Tananbaumetal.
1979;StockeAetal.
1991).
ThisdiagramallowsustoselectredobjectsandthenreducetheGalacticstellarpopulationamongtheseredobjectsbyselectingtheX-rayloudpopulation.
HerewemakeuseoftheobservationthatinstellarsourcestheX-rayuxforagivenopticaluxismuchweakerthaninAGNsandclusters(e.
g.
,Maccacaroetal.
1988).
Figure1ashowsEinsteinExtendedMediumSensitivitySurvey(EMSS)X-raysources(Stockeetal.
1991)intheplane.
aox-(O[E)ThisplotclearlyillustratesthedistinctionbetweenGalacticstellarsourcesandextragalacticsources.
BasedontheEMSSsourcedistribution,wedividedtheROSAT-APMsourcesonthesameplane(Fig.
1b).
TheO[EAPMcolorsarenotasaccurateastheEMSSvalues,whicharebasedonCCDphotometry.
Asaresult,thespreadofobservedcolorsiswider(Fig.
1b),andtherewillbesomeblueobjectsintheredzoneandviceversa.
Tocreateourlistofredquasarcandidates,werstexcludedthe128sourceswithbecausetheyarelikelytobeGalacticaox[1.
8,stars.
Thenweexcludedanother360sourceswithbluecolors,O[E\2,becausetheyaremostlikelyjustnormal,blue,unobscuredAGNs.
Thisresultsinanalsampleof87X-raysourcesdenedbythelowerrightcornerofFigure1bintheplane.
aox-(O[E)Oursampleof87opticallyredX-rayloudsourcesisamere0.
1%oftheD70,000WGACATsources.
ThefractionofX-raysourcesthatmayberedquasars,however,ismuchlarger:D5%oftheinitialX-rayselectedsample,D15%oftheunidentiedsourceswithAPMcolors,andD20%ofX-raybrightobjectswithAPMcolorsthatwillprimarilybeAGNs.
However,otherclassesofX-raysourcethanredquasarscaninhabitthisregionoftheplane:forexample,aox-(O[E)rst-rankedellipticalgalaxiesindistantclustersofgalaxies.
Opticalspectroscopyisneededtondredquasars.
Wehavetakenspectrafor51ofthe87redquasarcandidates,asisdescribedinthenextsection.
3.
OBSERVATIONS3.
1.
OpticalSpectroscopyAtypicalX-rayerrorcirclecontainsjust12opticalobjectsintheAPMcatalog.
Sincewehaveselectedagainstbluecounterparts,webeganbyobservingthebrightestredcounterpart.
Iftwoobjectswerepresent,wealignedthespectrographslittoobtainspectraofbothatonce.
IfthistherstspectradidnotndanAGN,wethenobservedthenextfaintest,ifpresent.
Sincethedensityof(blue)AGNsatB\21isonlyD0.
005pererrorcircle(e.
g.
,Zitellietal.
1992),weexpectonlya1in4chanceofAGNcoincidenceinthe51spectra,sostoppingonceanAGNisfoundwillnotproduceasignicantnumberoffalseidentications.
WeperformedopticalspectroscopywiththeMultipleMirrorTelescope(MMT)on1997March1315,withtheFredLawrenceWhippleObservatory(FLWO)60Atele-scopeon1996November1617and1997February1213,andwiththeCerroTololoInter-AmericanObservatory(CTIO)60Atelescopeon1997February35.
Weusedlong-slitaperturesof2@@3@@]180@@andgratingswith300gpm.
Thespectralresolutionsare6and9fortheMMTand60AAtelescopes,respectively.
Wavelengthcoverageisabout35008000Wetookbias,domeat,andtwilightskyA.
frameseachnight,andthecorrespondingcorrections(biassubtraction,atelding,andilluminationcorrection)wereappliedseparatelytoeachnightofdata.
Atleasttwostan-dardstarswereobservedeachnightforspectrophotometriccalibration.
Theobservingconditionswerenotphoto-metric,exceptfortheCTIOrun,sotheabsolutecalibrationissubjecttoasignicantuncertainty.
However,relativeintensities(suchasalineintensityratioandanopticalpower-lawindex)areaccuratewithin20%,asisconrmedbymultipleobservationsofthesamesource.
Sixsourcesareofundeterminednaturebecausetheyaretoofaintandsogavespectraoftoopoorasignal-to-noiseratio.
3.
2.
ClassicationofSpectraOfthe45sourcesobservedatagoodsignal-to-noiseratio,wehaveidentiedsevenredquasars(Table1).
Theresultsforthesesevenredquasarsarepresentedinthispaper.
(Thefulldatasetwillappearelsewhere.
)Theredquasarsaremixedinwith18starsandasmallnumberofnormalbluequasars,narrowemissionlinegalaxies,andellipticalgalaxies(Table1).
Theellipticalgalaxiesarelikelytobebrightestclustergalaxies.
Wewillreportontheseseparately.
FortheremainingnineX-raysources,theredopticalcandidatewithintheerrorcircleturnedouttobeastar(mostlylatetype),butitisnotlikelythattheseredstarsarethecounterparts,becausetheirvaluesaretoolargeaoxforastar(seeabove;Maccacaroetal.
1988).
Theremainingopticalcandidatesarenotred,andhencewestoppedmakingfurtherobservations.
TheseninesourcesandthethreebluequasarsmeasurethebluecontaminationofthesampleandshouldnotbeconsideredaspartofthelistofredX-raycounterparts.
TheopticalspectraofthesevenredquasarsareshowninFigures2aand2b.
BroadlinesofHa,Hb,andMgIIareclearlyseeninthespectraaswellasbrightnarrowlines(e.
g.
,[OIII]j5007),makingtheAGNcharacteroftheobjectsunambiguous.
InTable2wetabulatesourceposition,red-shift,opticalmagnitudeandcolor,X-rayuxandX-rayTABLE1SUMMARYOFOPTICALIDENTIFICATIONSOFREDX-RAYSOURCECOUNTERPARTSMeasurementTotalRedQuasarsTooFaintNLXGEllipticalGalaxiesMStarsOtherStarsBlueQuasarsNotRed1.
8[aox[1.
6(O19)22100117102aox\1.
6(O\19)2966241037Total5176251813912KIM&ELVISVol.
516Fig.
2aFig.
2bFIG.
2.
(a)Observedspectraoftheveradio-quietredquasars(O[E[2mag,BroadlinessuchasHa,Hb,andMgIIareclearlyseenintheaopt[2.
0).
spectraaswellasbrightnarrowlines(e.
g.
,[OIII]j5007).
Thosestronglinesaremarkedinthegures.
SteepcontinuumslopesandveryweakHblinestrengthsindicateasignicantamountofdustextinctionmag),incontrastto(b),twoquasarspectrawithandrelativelystrongHblines.
(AV[2aopt\2.
0colors,andaswellasosetsbetweentheopticalandaox,X-raypositions.
InFigure1beachclassofidentiedsourcesisplottedintheplane.
Thedistributionofthesesourcesaox-(O[E)canbecomparedwiththeEMSSsourcesinFigure1a,conrmingthatmostX-raysourceswithlowareindeedaoxquasarsorgalaxyclusters.
Theselectiontechniquends7/51redquasars,i.
e.
,8%efficiency.
Aslightlystrictercri-terion,(insteadof1.
8),wouldhaveselectedredaox\1.
6quasarsmoreefficiently(Table2;Fig.
1b):onlyoneMstar(insteadof19stars)wouldhavebeenpresent,withonlyoneredquasarlost,i.
e.
,6/29,alittleover20%.
Oftheinitial87,71%(62)remainwhenistheboundary.
aox\1.
63.
3.
ObservedOpticalPropertiesoftheRedQuasarsWemeasuredtheopticalcontinuumslopesbyttingapowerlawtothecontinuumspectraafterexcludingthestrongemissionlines(Table3).
AlthoughallthesourcesTABLE2BASICPROPERTIESOFREDQUASARSNameRightAngleaDeclinationaOsetbzfXcasoftdahardeOO[Eaox(aopt\[2.
0)J2255.
5]0536225531.
005360111.
30.
06477.
741.
4590.
75016.
382.
441.
636J1234.
3]2614123421.
82613285.
00.
31202.
420.
8601.
71120.
552.
351.
180J1218.
1]2956121807.
12955214.
30.
15141.
620.
9591.
51219.
162.
081.
466J0909.
7]4302090943.
64302477.
00.
27481.
650.
8591.
41721.
382.
281.
114J1143.
6]5521114335.
55520214.
00.
14671.
520.
5351.
04019.
332.
331.
451[0.
9[aopt[[2.
0)J1051.
4]3358105128.
33358048.
00.
18292.
761.
2901.
29518.
272.
721.
515J1142.
6]4624114241.
24624213.
10.
115115.
750.
9261.
26316.
332.
441.
522aOpticalcoordinateinEquinoxJ2000.
bDierenceofX-rayandopticalpositionsinarcseconds.
cInunitsof10~13ergs~1cm~2.
dX-rayspectralindexin0.
10.
8keV.
eX-rayspectralindexin0.
82.
0keV.
No.
1,1999RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARS13TABLE3LINE,CONTINUUMPROPERTIES,ANDLUMINOSITIESOFREDQUASARSADDD4000HaNameaoptaFWHMfcLdM(O)M(E)L(X)43b(aopt\[2.
0)J2255.
5]05362.
39596229.
80.
54[21.
6[24.
11.
02J1234.
3]26142.
647184e5.
1e2.
70e[21.
1[23.
58.
19J1218.
1]29562.
3650115.
20.
56[20.
8[22.
91.
21J0909.
7]43022.
4321782.
30.
91[20.
0[22.
34.
29J1143.
6]55212.
1132235.
10.
51[20.
5[22.
91.
07([0.
9[aopt[[2.
0)J1051.
4]33580.
931797f7.
1f7.
10f[22.
1[24.
83.
07J1142.
6]46241.
41310481.
34.
90[23.
0[25.
46.
75aOpticalspectralindex,flPlaopt.
bInunitsof1043ergss~1.
cInunitsof10~15ergscm~2s~1.
dInunitsof1043ergss~1.
eMgII.
fHb.
wereselectedbasedonaredO[Ecolor,insomecasestheobservedopticalcontinuumshapeisrelativelyat.
Thisisbecauseofbothlineemissioncontributingtotheblueand/orredbandsanduncertaintiesontheOandEmagni-tudes,particularlywhentheobjectisfaint(M.
Irwin1996,privatecommunication).
Thepower-lawindex(FlDlaopt)rangesfrom[0.
9to[2.
6.
Asteepopticalcontinuum,isfoundinveofthesevenredquasars,whileaopt\[2,eventheremainingtwo,intermediateredquasarsareredderthanisfoundforUV-excessselected([1.
5\aopt\[1)quasars([0.
2^0.
8;Neugebaueretal.
1987).
Toillustratethespectraldierencesbetweenthesetwogroups,wedisplaythespectraseparatelyinFigures2a(steep)and2b(intermediate).
Inadditiontothedierenceincontinuumshape,thesetwogroupsalsodierintheirHblinestrengths(seeFigs.
2aand2b).
ThegroupwiththesteepopticalcontinuumhaveonlyweakHblinesornodetection,whereasthegroupwitharelativelyatcontinuumhavestrongerHblines.
SincetheratioofHatoHbissensitivetoopticalextinction,thissuggestsmorereddeninginthesteepslopegroupthantheintermediateslopegroup(Table3),whichisinaccordwiththeopticalcontinuumslopes.
ToquantifythiseectforthosequasarswithnodetectedHbline,weestimateditsupperlimitusingasimplemethodthatassumesaboxprolewithabaseequalto3000kms~1(themeanFWHMofdetectedHblines)andaheightequalto3timestheuctuationnoiseonthecontinuum.
Thisisaconservativemeasurement,becausethepeakofaGaussianprolewouldbemoreeasilydetectedthantheattopofaboxprole,particularlywhenthelinewidthisconsiderablylargerthanthespectralresolution.
MonteCarlosimula-tionsusingaGaussianlineproleassumingPoissonsta-tisticsshowthattheboxproleoverestimatestheupperlimitbyupto50%fortheadoptedlinewidth,whileitreproducesconsistentresultswhenthelinewidthiscompa-rablewiththespectralresolution.
ForthetwoobjectswhoseopticalspectradonotcovertheHaline,wehaveinsteadusedthe[OIII]/HbratioasameasureofrelativeHbstrength.
ForallvequasarswiththeHa/Hbratiosaopt\[2,aregreaterthan5,whilethe[OIII]/Hb[0.
8.
Thelineratiosofthetworemainingquasarsaresmaller(Table2),whichisconsistentwithlessreddeninginintermediate-slopeobjects.
Noneofthecharacteristicgalaxianstellarabsorptionfeatures4areseeninourspectra.
Moststrikingly,no4000Abreakisseeninanyoftheveredquasarsforwhichourspectracoverthatregion,includingallofthesteep-slopegroup.
TypicalvaluesofD(4000)5are11.
2,asisexpectedfromthemeasuredopticalslopes.
Thesecomparewithvaluesof2^0.
2fornormalEandS0galaxiesDressler&Shectman(1987).
Henceanystarlightcontinuumcontribu-tiontotheredquasarcontinuummustbeminor.
3.
4.
X-RayColorsoftheRedQuasarsTodeterminetheroughX-rayspectralpropertiesofthesevenredquasars,werstdouble-checkedinthePSPCimagesthatthesourceswerecleanlyseparatedfromanyconfusingsources,thenmeasuredtheirX-rayhardness(HR\H/M)andsoftness(SR\S/M)ratiosbasedonthecountratesinthestandardROSATPSPCbands:soft,S(0.
10.
4keV);medium,M(0.
40.
86keV);andhard,H(0.
872keV).
TheseratiosarethenconvertedtoeectiveX-rayspectralindices,and(Table2),tocorrectforthevariableasoftahardGalacticline-of-sightabsorptionandtheenergy-dependentpoint-spreadfunction.
(ThesearenotphysicalslopesbutshouldbeconsideredanalogoustoU[BandB[Vcolors;seeFioreetal.
1998foradetaileddiscussionoftheestima-tionandusageofeectiveX-rayspectralindices.
)Duetothelowsignal-to-noiseratioofX-raydata,individualspec-tralindicesarenotreliable.
However,thelocusoftheircolorsformsausefulindicatorofglobalX-rayproperties.
Wecomparethecolorsoftheredquasarswiththoseofnormalradio-quietquasarsinFigure3.
Thelargelledsymbolsaretheredquasarsreportedhere,whilethecloudofsmalldotsrepresentsradio-quietquasarsfromthesampleofFioreetal.
(1998).
Onaverage,theredquasarshavesmallerthanindicatingacutospectralasoftahard,shape.
[Thelinepairsaroundtheperipheryofthegure4CHG-bandj4304,MgIj5175,Ca]Fej5269,Najj5890,5896.
Dressler&Shectman5D(4000)\Fl(40504250A)/Fl(37503950A),(1987).
14KIM&ELVISVol.
516FIG.
3.
EectivesoftandhardROSATPSPCX-rayspectralindices(seetext)oftheredquasars(largelledsymbols)comparedwithnormalradio-quietquasars(smalldots;Fioreetal.
1998).
Steepopticalspectrum(a\[2)redquasarsareshownascircles,andintermediateopticalspec-trum([1.
5\a\[1)redquasarsareshownastriangles.
Thelinepairsaroundtheperipheryofthegureshowoutlinespectralshapesfortheirlocationsintheplane.
(ahard,ahard)showoutlinespectralshapesfortheirlocationsinthe(asoft,plane.
]Thisisconsistentwiththeirhavingthemoder-ahard)ateX-rayabsorptionexpectedfromtheiropticalproperties(Fioreetal.
1998).
4.
DISCUSSIONTheseobservationsshowthatapopulationofredAGNscanbeextractedefficientlyfromtheROSATpointedarchive.
Moreover,theredAGNswendareradioquiet.
NoneofthemisaradiosourceintheNRAOVLARadioSkySurveymJy;Condonetal.
1998),(f1.
4GHz\2.
5implyingGHz)]\2.
0,comparedwithRL\log[f(opt)/f(5forradio-loudquasars(Wilkes&Elvis1987).
2\RL\5TheagreementofX-raycolors,opticalcontinuumslope,andHa/Hbratioswiththesamevalueofobscuringdustandgasarguesfortheirbeingdustreddened(AVD12)objectsratherthaninstrinsicallyredcontinua.
Puchnarewicz&Mason(1988)discussasimilarpopu-lationof14candidatered,AGNsderivedfromtheaopt[2,RIXOSsample,whichextendstoseveraltimesfainterX-rayuxes.
TheRIXOSsamplewasselectedfromtheROSATpointedarchivebasedonX-rayuxalone.
(Thereisoneobjectincommonbetweenthetwosamples.
)TwooftheredRIXOSAGNsmaybeintrinsicallyred,andthreehaveclearreddening.
SothereiscurrentlyatotalofeightreddenedAGNsavailablefromROSAT.
TheredAGNs,bothfromthissampleandfromRIXOS,areborderlinequasar/Seyfertobjects.
TheobservedopticalluminositiesoftheredAGNsaremodest,lyingatthehighendofthetraditionalSeyfertluminosityrange(MB[[23mag;Veron-Cetty&Veron1984;Schmidt&Green1983):fromto[22mag.
6Thedereddened,intrinsicMO\[206Wehaveusedkms~1Mpc~1andH0\50q0\0.
luminosityofthesourcesislikelytobesignicantlyhigher,dependingontheamountofabsorption(thelowerlimitontheextinctionis23maginO).
Thisplacesthematwhichiswithinthequasarregime.
[25\MO\[22,Similarly,theobservedX-rayluminosityrangesfrom1.
3]1043to1.
2]1044ergss~1,whiletheintrinsiclumi-nositiesarelikelytobehigherbyaboutafactorof2,dependingontheintrinsicspectrumandtheamountofabsorptionpresent.
ThepreciseallocationoftheseAGNsasquasarsorSey-fertsisnotfundamentallyveryinteresting,sincethisisjustaconvenientlychosenvalueonacontinuousluminosityscale.
Forsimplicitywewillrefertothemasredquasarsfortherestofthispaper.
Itis,however,interestingtounder-standwhymuchmoreormuchlessluminousAGNswerenotfoundinthetworedquasarsearches.
Isthisaselectioneect,oristhereaphysicalpreferenceforredobjectstoclusterinalimitedrangeofluminosityWewillreturntothisquestionlater(°4.
3).
Theexistenceofaredquasarpopulationimmediatelyraisesimportantquestions.
Whatmakesthemredcom-paredwithusualbluequasarsHowcommonarethey,particularlyonceallowanceismadefortheirreduceduxduetoprobableobscurationIftheyareabsorbed,byhowmuchWhereistheabsorbingdustymaterialMightalarger,moreobscured,AGNpopulationexist4.
1.
HowCommonareRedQuasarsWecanaddresstherelativenumbersofredquasarsinaroughway.
Thepopulation,althoughaminority,isquitecommon.
Wefoundsevenredquasarsoutof45candidatesforwhichourspectroscopywasadequatetoproduceaclas-sication.
Assumingthatthe45werearandomsubsampleoftheoriginalsampleof87,thatsamplewouldproduce14redquasars.
Thisis2.
4%of575sourceswithopticalcolorsavailable.
Atouruxlimit,Stockeetal.
(1991)ndthat51%ofallX-raysourcesareAGNs.
Soaminimumof13.
5/288(4.
7%)AGNsinourunidentiedsampleareradio-quietredquasars(withO\20)atthissoftX-rayuxlevel.
TheBoyle&diMatteo(1995)upperlimitof9%ofCam-bridgeROSATSerendipitySurvey(CRSS)X-raysourcesbeingredquasarsisconsistentwiththeminoritypopulationofmoderatelyobscuredquasarswehavefound(AV\2)here.
Additionalredquasarscouldbehiddeninoursample.
Oursampleof45classiedspectraisnotarandomsub-sampleofthecandidatelist.
Figure1bshowsthatweprefer-entiallyselectedobjectswithi.
e.
,thebrighteraox[1.
3,objects(withB\21.
5).
Ifthesixobjectsforwhichweattemptedtogetspectraturnouttoberedquasars,thenthefractionofredquasarsamongthePSPCAGNscouldbealmostdoubleourrstestimate.
Thereareafurther36redcandidatesforwhichnospectroscopywasattempted.
Sothetrueoccurrencerateofredquasarsisuncertainbyafactorof7.
TondthefractionofredquasarsamongalltheAGNsinourX-ray,ux-limitedsample,wemustallowforthe165300blueAGNsintheidentiedsample,so1%7%ofthewholesoftX-rayAGNpopulationisred.
IftheredAGNsareobscured,thentheintrinsicrateofoccurrenceofredquasarshastobecalculatedrelativetotheirunreddenedparentpopulation.
ObscurationbyAV\reducestheirunobscuredX-rayuxesbyafactorofD2.
2SincehigheruxAGNsarerarer(theX-rayselectedAGNNo.
1,1999RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARS15logN/logSrelationhasaslopeof[3/2inthisuxrange;Hasinger1995;DellaCeccaetal.
1992),theredpopulationformsalargerfractionofthispopulation,D3%20%.
Usingthefractionofthesourcesattheintrinsicuxoftheredquasarsallowsustocompareourresultwithsamplesunaectedbyobscurationandwithmodelpredic-tions.
Comparisonswiththeobservedfrequencyofradio-loudredquasarswithbroademissionlinesfoundbySmith&Spinrad(1980;178MHz3CR)andStickeletal.
(1996;5GHz1Jysample)andwiththeComastrietal.
(1995)pre-dictionsarestraightforward.
Redquasarsarefoundin15%ofthe3CRsourcesampleand6%20%ofthe1Jy(Carillietal.
1998)sample.
Thesearecomparablewiththe3%-20%ofthe""intrinsicuxX-raypopulationthatwend,suggestingthattheradio-loudandradio-quietquasarpopulationshavesimilarlysizedpopulationsofmoderatelyobscuredquasars.
Theobscurationinthe3CRredquasarsisalsoaboutAV\2(Elvisetal.
1994;Economouetal.
1995;Rawlingsetal.
1995).
Forfourobjectsinthe1Jysample,Carillietal.
(1998)estimatelowerlimitsonfrom2to5basedonAVextrapolatingtheradio-infraredindextotheoptical.
However,sincesuchsteeplyrisingslopesarenotknownamongunobscuredquasars,theselimitsarelikelytobetoolarge,andvaluescomparablewiththe3CRestimatesareprobablyacceptable.
ForAGNswithcm~2,theComastrietal.
NH\1022(1995)modelpredictsthat26%willhave1021\NH\1022cm~2whichissomewhatlargerbutcomparable(AVD2),withthenumbersfoundhere.
Comastrietal.
predictfarlargernumbersofmoreobscuredobjects.
4.
2.
MoreObscuredObjectsMoreobscuredobjectsmayexist.
Puchnarewicz&Mason(1998)ndseveralobjectswithsteeperopticalcon-tinua,andFigure1bshowsseveralreddercandidatesandmanymoreX-rayloudcandidateswithnoopticalspectratodate.
Websteretal.
(1995)suggestedthatmaybeAV\5typicaloftheirredobjects,givingtheirputativeROSATcounterpartsinoursampleV\2325,whichisbelowthePalomarSkySurveylimit.
correspondstoacolumnAV\5of9]1021atomscm~2,whichwouldreduceROSATPSPCcountratesto15%oftheirunobscuredvalues.
Theseobjectswouldthenbehiddenasa6%minorityamongthemorecommon,lowerluminosity,unabsorbedquasarsiftheyhadthesameunobscuredspacedensityasnormalbluequasars.
Some9%ofourinitialX-rayselectedsampleare""blankeldobjects,i.
e.
,havenocounterpartonthePalomarSkySurveys.
Afractionofthesecouldbemoreheavilyobscuredredquasars.
Boyle&diMatteo(1995)ndthattheCRSSsamplecouldbemissingnomorethan9%(attheobservedux)inredquasars.
Subtractingthe1%ofmoderatelyobscuredquasarswehaveidentiedstillleaves8%thatcouldbehighlyobscured.
HencetheCRSSresultis,perhapssurprisingly,consistentwithasizeable,heavilyobscuredpopulation.
TheComastrietal.
(1995)modelpre-dictsacomparablepopulationofAGNswithNHD1022cm~2,whichis1.
1timeslargerthantheunobscuredpopu-lation.
Inoursampletheoccurrenceofredquasarsappearstobe4timeshigherforO[19mag(4/12)thanforO\19mag(3/32;Table2),althoughthenumberofsourcesissmall.
Suchatrendisexpectedifthequasarsareheavilyabsorbed.
Anincreaseinfrom3]1021to1]1022NHcm~2cutstheROSATuxbyafactorof2.
4butreddenstheVbandby3.
8mag(afactor33).
Sotheopticallyfaintersourcesmightwellberedder.
However,theRIXOSredquasars(Puchnarewicz&Mason1998)shownocorrelationofopticalslopewiththethreesteepestslopesareallinmV:thebrighterhalfofthesampleof14.
Gunn&Shanks(1998)havepointedoutthatwhileredshiftingtheultravioletintotheopticalincreasestheeectsofreddening,thecorre-spondingshiftofhardX-raysintothesoftROSATbanddecreasestheeectivenessofreddening.
Toestimateanaccuratefractionofthispotentialhiddenpopulationneedsalargersample,includingmoreabsorbed,fainterobjects.
Atevenlargercolumndensities(10231024cm~2)theComastrietal.
(1995)modelpredictsnearly4timestheunobscuredpopulation.
MoreheavilyobscuredquasarscouldbefoundinhardX-raysurveysfromASCA(Uedaetal.
1998)andtheBeppo-SAXHELLASsurvey(Fioreetal.
1999).
4.
3.
LimitedLuminosityRangeItisstrikingthatwhileROSATsurveysthataredenedsimplybyanX-rayuxlimitndAGNsspanningover3decadesinX-rayluminosity(e.
g.
,CRSS,Boyleetal.
1997;RIXOS,Puchnarewiczetal.
1996),bothRIXOSandthissurveyndredquasarsinonly1decadeofluminosity,andthisdecadeisthelowestoneinwhichRIXOSandCRSSAGNsarefound.
Atwo-tailKolmogorov-SmirnovtestshowsthatthechancethatredandnonredAGNsfromRIXOScomefromthesameluminositydistributionisonlyD2%.
ThissuggeststhatpredominantlylowerluminosityAGNsareobscured.
(NotethattheobservedamountofobscurationonlydecreasestheobservedX-rayluminositybyafactorofD2,andsodoesnotitselfcausethelowobservedluminosities.
)Similarsuggestionshavebeenmadebefore:Lawrence&Elvis(1982)foundthatonlyAGNsbelowergsLXD1044s~1(210keV)showedobscuration.
Occasionalexamplesofhighlyobscuredtype2(i.
e.
,narrow-line)quasarshavebeenreported(Stockeetal.
1982;Almainietal.
1995;Shanksetal.
1995),andcarefulsearcheshavefoundbroadHainmostcases(Halpern,Eracleous,&Forster1998),makingthemsimilartotheredquasarsfoundhere.
Search-esamongthefainterobjectsinoursampleandsearchesathigherenergies(e.
g.
,theBeppo-SAXHELLASsurvey;Fioreetal.
1999)willbemoreeectiveatndingahigh-luminosityredquasarpopulation.
TheComastrietal.
X-raybackgroundmodelsassumeluminosityfunctionsfortheobscuredobjectsthatareiden-ticaltothoseoftheunobscuredobjectsexceptfornormal-izationandsopredictshigh-luminosityredquasars.
IfinsteadobscuredAGNsoccurpreferentiallyatlowlumi-nosity,thiswillsubstantiallyaectthemodelpredictions.
Wewould,forexample,expecttheobscuredpopulationtobemorenumerousandatlowerredshift.
Ifthereisarealdecitofhigh-luminosityredquasars,thenonepossibilitytoexplainthislackmighthavebeenthatasanAGNbecamemoreluminous,thecontinuumionizedtheobscuringmedium,renderingittransparenttoX-rays.
However,ionizedabsorbersarealsomorecommonatlowerluminosities(Laoretal.
1994).
Somostlikely,high-luminosityAGNshavefewerlinesofsightwithinterveningmaterialregardlessofionizationstate.
(Interestingly,thisisinthesamesenseastheBaldwineect:thathigherlumi-nosityquasarshaveweakerCIII]j1909emissionlines.
)Any16KIM&ELVISVol.
516physicalmodelofaquasarwouldneedtoexplainthisdier-ence.
4.
4.
PhysicalPropertiesWecansayonlyalittleaboutthephysicalpropertiesoftheredquasarsfromthisdata.
TheconsistencyoftheopticalreddeningindicatorswiththeX-raycolorssuggeststhatthesameobscuringmaterialcoversbothemittingregionsandthatitliesoutsidethebroademissionlineregion.
Smith&Spinrad(1980)suggestedthattherednessofthered3CRquasarsisintrinsictothecontinuumemissionprocessbasedonthelackofanabsorptionfeatureatj\2200whichisatypicalcharacteristicofMilkyWayA,dust(e.
g.
,Bless&Savage1972).
Thedetectionof21cmHIabsorptiontowardalargefractionofthe1Jy(Stickeletal.
1996)redquasars(Carillietal.
1998)arguesfordustreddeninginthoseobjects.
Sinceoursampleofradio-quietquasarsisrelativelynearby(withredshiftsupto0.
3),wecannotcheckforthisfeaturedirectly.
However,thisexpla-nationisincontrasttotheobservedBalmerdecrementandtheX-raycolors.
Itispossiblethatthereddened3CRsourcescontaindusty,ionizedabsorbers,asisseenin3C212(Mathur1994;Elvisetal.
1994)andIRAS17020]4544(Komossa&Bade1998),wherethedustcompositionmaydierdependingon,forexample,thequasarcontinuumshape.
Ultravioletobservationsareneededtoinvestigatethej\2200featurebutareprobablyinfeasibleatApresent.
4.
5.
OtherRedAGNsSomepreviousstudieshaveconsideredredAGN-likeobjectsinX-raysurveys.
TheRIXOSsurvey(Puchnarewicz&Mason1998)foundthat9%(14/160)oftheirAGNswerered.
However,onlythreeoftheRIXOSsourceshaveBalmerdecrementsthatrequirereddening,sothetrueoccurrencerateofreddenedobjectsmaybesimilartowhatwehavefound.
ThefainteruxlimitoftheRIXOSsurveymayrendermoreabsorbedobjectsvisible.
Certainly,thesteeperopticalslopesofhalfthe([2.
5[aopt[[4.
0)RIXOSsamplesuggestgreaterreddening.
Kruper&Canizares(1989)studiedredAGNsinEinsteinX-rayselectedsamplesandindirectlyconcludedthattheseareredbecauseofthepresenceofhostgalaxies.
Bennetal.
(1998)arriveatasimilarconclusionforlow-frequency,selectedradio-loudquasars.
However,nogalaxianstarlightfeaturesareseeninourspectra,andthehostgalaxycannotexplaintheobservedBalmerdecrementsinoursample.
TheKruper&Canizaresobjectsarenotasredasoursamples,havingB[I\1.
52.
5mag.
IfwetakeR[Itobe0.
51.
0mag(thisistheR[IrangeofthesamplesintheirTable2),B[Rwouldbelessthan2.
0,ourdeningthreshold.
Infact,noneoftheirobjectswithmeasuredRmagnitudesexceedB[R\2.
0.
Thenarrow-lineX-raygalaxies(NLXGs)foundplenti-fullyindeepROSATsurveys(e.
g.
,Boyleetal.
1995a)arealsonormallyassumedtobeobscuredAGNs(e.
g.
,Hasingeretal.
1998;Schachteretal.
1998).
X-rayabsorbedNLXGscouldcontributesignicantlytothecosmicX-rayback-groundiftheyaremorecommonatfainterX-rayuxlevels,aswassuggestedbyMcHardyetal.
(1998;seealsoHasingeretal.
1998foracautionarynote).
AlthoughtheyhavesimilarX-rayluminositiestotheNLXGs,theX-rayselectedredquasarsarenotsimplythesamepopulation,however.
Theredquasarshavethenormal,broadopticalemissionlinesofquasars,whileNLXGshaveeithernoneoronlyextremelyweakones(Boyleetal.
1995b;Figs.
2aand2b).
Moreover,NLXGsusuallyexhibitblueopticalcontin-ua(forexample,O[E\2forveoutofsixNLXGsinCRSS;Boyleetal.
1997),whileredquasarshaveredopticalcontinua(O[E[2).
FurtherX-rayandopticalstudyoftheseobjectsmayletusunderstandwhethertheyaretwoseparatepopulationsorarerelatedby,e.
g.
,specialviewinggeometryorscatteringofabluecontinuum.
ThePalomarsurveyofthenucleiofbrightgalaxies(Ho,Filippenko,&Sargent1997)isbasedonasampleofgal-axiesselectedfortheirnonnuclearpropertiesandsoislessbiasedagainstndingredAGNsthanmostotheropticalsearchmethods.
ThePalomarAGNsarelow-luminosityAGNs,allowingustoseewhetherthehighincidenceofredAGNsatlowerluminositiescontinuestoincreaseatevenlowervalues.
ThePalomarsurveyndsthat18%(8/44)ofSeyfertnucleihavebasedontheirnarrow-lineAV[2Balmerdecrements(Hoetal.
1997).
However,almostalloftheseareLINERsortype2Seyferts,whichmayhavelargereddeningtowardthebroad-lineregion.
OnlyoneSeyfert(NGC7479)showsanyevidenceforabroad-linecom-ponent.
Broademissionlinesareextremelyhardtodetectattheseuxlevels,butthesuggestionisthatthemiddlingluminositiestowardthequasar/Seyfertborderlinearepar-ticularlypronetomoderateobscuration.
5.
CONCLUSIONSRadio-quietredquasarscanbefoundinsubstantialnumbers.
Theycompriseatleast1%,andpotentially7%,ofthesoftX-raypopulationinauxlimitedsurvey.
Correct-ingtheX-rayuxestotheirintrinsicvaluesputsthemamongbrighterAGNs,wheretheyform3%ofthepopu-lation.
Allowingforblankeldsources,asmuchas20%ofROSATselectedquasarsmayberedatagivenunobscuredux.
Thesizeofthispopulationisconsistentwithpreviousupperlimits,withtheComastrietal.
(1995)modelfortheX-raybackground,andwiththesizeoftheradio-loud3CRand1Jyredquasarpopulations.
Redquasarsseemtobepreferentiallylowerluminosityobjectsonthequasar/Seyfertborderlinebutnotathigherorlowerluminosities.
Suchabiasagainstobscuredhigh-luminosityobjectswouldaectX-raybackgroundestimatesforthispopulationandwouldneedexplaininginaphysicalmodelofquasars.
Westressthatthequasarswendhavebroadopticallines.
TheyarenotNLXGs,whichbycontrasthavepre-dominantlynarrowopticalpermittedlinesandbluecontin-ua.
Theopticalslopes,Ha/Hbratios,andX-raycolorsareallconsistent,withreddeningbyassumingstandardAVD2MilkyWaydustproperties.
Sothesameobscuringmaterialprobablycoverseachoftheemittingregions.
Asignicantpopulationofmorehighlyobscured(AV\5)quasarscouldwellexistandbeconsistentwiththeresultshere,withearlierROSATlimits,andwouldbeaspredictedbytheComastrietal.
(1995)model.
HardX-raysurveyswillsoonsettlethequestionofthesizeofanysuchpopulation.
Usingaminorrenementofthetechniquepresentedhere,redquasarscanbefoundwithhigh(20%)efficiencyintheROSATdata.
WethankL.
AngeliniforhelpingustouseWGACATandM.
IrwinforuseoftheAPMonlinecatalog.
WealsoNo.
1,1999RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARS17thankF.
FioreandF.
NicastroforprovidingtheirprogramtocalculateX-rayspectralindicesandF.
FioreonceagainforsupplyingtheX-rayslopesoftheradio-quietsampleinFigure3.
ThesupportbytheFLWO,MMT,andCTIOstasinsettingupandoperatingvariousinstrumentswereinvaluabletothisstudy.
TheHEASARC/GSFCPIMMSprogramwasusedtocalculatePSPCcountrates.
ThisworkwassupportedbyNASAgrantsNAG5-3066(ADP),NAG5-6078(LTSA),andNASAcontractNAS8-39073(ASC).
REFERENCESAlmaini,O.
,Boyle,B.
J.
,Griffiths,R.
E.
,Shanks,T.
,Stewart,G.
C.
,&Georgantopoulos,I.
1995,MNRAS,277,L31Avni,Y.
,&Tananbaum,H.
1986,ApJ,305,83Bade,N.
,Fink,H.
H.
,Engels,D.
,Voges,W.
,Hagen,H.
-J.
,Wisotzki,L.
,&Reimers,D.
1995,A&AS,110,469Benn,C.
R.
,Vigotti,M.
,Carballo,R.
,Gonzalez-Serrano,J.
I.
,&Sanchez,S.
F.
1998,MNRAS,295,451Bless,R.
C.
,&Savage,B.
D.
1972,ApJ,171,293Bohlin,R.
C.
,Savage,B.
D.
,&Drake,J.
F.
1978,ApJ,224,132Boyle,B.
J.
,&diMatteo,T.
1995,MNRAS,277,L63Boyle,B.
J.
,McMahon,R.
G.
,Wilkes,B.
J.
,&Elvis,M.
1995a,MNRAS,285,511.
1995b,MNRAS,276,315Boyle,B.
J.
,Wilkes,B.
J.
,&Elvis,M.
1997,MNRAS,285,511Bregman,J.
N.
,Glassgold,A.
E.
,Huggins,P.
J.
,&Kinney,A.
L.
1985,ApJ,291,505Carilli,C.
L.
,Menten,K.
M.
,Reid,M.
J.
,Rupen,M.
P.
,&Yun,M.
S.
1998,ApJ,494,175Comastri,A.
,Setti,G.
,Zamorani,G.
,&Hasinger,G.
1995,A&A,296,1Condon,J.
J.
,Cotton,W.
D.
,Greisen,E.
W.
,Yin,Q.
F.
,Perley,R.
A.
,Taylor,G.
B.
,&Broderick,J.
J.
1998,AJ,115,1693DellaCeca,R.
,Maccacaro,T.
,Gioia,I.
M.
,Wolter,A.
,&Stocke,J.
T.
1992,ApJ,389,491Dressler,A.
,&Shectman,S.
A.
1987,AJ,94,899Economou,F.
,Lawrence,A.
,Ward,M.
J.
,&Blanco,P.
R.
1995,MNRAS,272,L5Elvis,M.
,Fiore,F.
,Mathur,S.
,&Wilkes,B.
J.
1994,ApJ,425,103Elvis,M.
,Kim,D.
-W.
,&Nicastro,F.
1999,inpreparationEngels,D.
,Hagen,H.
-J.
,Cordin,L.
,Koehler,S.
,Wisotzki,L.
,&Reimers,D.
1998,A&AS,128,507Fiore,F.
,Elvis,M.
,Giommi,P.
,&Padovani,P.
1998,ApJ,492,79Fiore,F.
,LaFranca,F.
,Giommi,P.
,Elvis,M.
,Comastri,A.
,Matt,G.
,&Molendi,S.
1999,inpreparationGregg,M.
D.
,Becker,R.
H.
,White,R.
L.
,Helfand,D.
J.
,McMahon,R.
G.
,&Hook,I.
M.
1996,AJ,112,407Gunn,K.
F.
,&Shanks,T.
1998,Astron.
Nachr.
,319,66Halpern,J.
P.
,Eracleous,M.
,&Forster,K.
1998,ApJ,501,103Hasinger,G.
1995,inMPERep.
263,fromtheUniverse,Rontgenstrahlunged.
H.
U.
Zimmermann,J.
&H.
Yorke(Garching:MPE),291Trumper,Hasinger,G.
,Burg,R.
,Giacconi,R.
,Schmidt,M.
,J.
,&Zamo-Trumper,rani,G.
1998,A&A,329,482Hewett,P.
C.
,Foltz,C.
B.
,&Chaee,F.
H.
1995,AJ,109,1498Ho,L.
C.
,Filippenko,A.
,&Sargent,W.
L.
W.
1997,ApJS,112,315Kellerman,K.
I.
,Sramek,R.
,Schmidt,M.
,Shaer,D.
B.
,&Green,R.
1989,AJ,98,1195Kollgaard,R.
I.
,Feigelson,E.
D.
,Laurent-Muehlson,S.
A.
,Spinrad,H.
,Dey,A.
,&Brinkmann,W.
1995,ApJ,449,61Komossa,S.
,&Bade,N.
1998,A&A,331,L49Kruper,J.
S.
,&Canizares,C.
R.
1989,ApJ,343,66Laor,A.
,Fiore,F.
,Elvis,M.
,Wilkes,B.
J.
,&McDowell,J.
C.
1994,ApJ,435,611Lawrence,A.
,&Elvis,M.
1982,ApJ,256,410Lipovetzky,V.
A.
,Markarian,B.
E.
,&Stepanian,J.
A.
1987,inObser-vationalEvidenceofActivityinGalaxies,ed.
E.
Ye.
Khachikian,K.
J.
Fricke,&J.
Melnick(Dordrecht:Reidel),17Maccacaro,T.
,Gioia,I.
M.
,Wolter,A.
,Zamorani,G.
,&Stocke,J.
T.
1988,ApJ,326,680Mathur,S.
1994,ApJ,431,L75McHardy,I.
M.
,etal.
1998,MNRAS,295,641McMahon,R.
G.
,&Irwin,M.
J.
1992,inDigitizedOpticalSkySurveys,ed.
H.
T.
MacGillivray&E.
B.
Thomson(Dordrecht:Kluwer),417Neugebauer,G.
,Green,R.
F.
,Matthews,K.
,Schmidt,M.
,Soifer,B.
T.
,&Bennet,J.
1987,ApJS,63,615Pfeermann,E.
,etal.
1987,Proc.
SPIE,733,519Puchnarewicz,E.
M.
,etal.
1996,MNRAS,281,1243.
1997,MNRAS,291,177Puchnarewicz,E.
M.
,&Mason,K.
O.
1988,MNRAS,293,243Rawlings,S.
,Lacy,M.
,Sivia,D.
S.
,&Eales,S.
A.
1995,MNRAS,274,428Sandage,A.
R.
1965,ApJ,141,1560Sanders,D.
B.
,etal.
1988,ApJ,325,74Schachter,J.
S.
,Fiore,F.
,Elvis,M.
,Mathur,S.
,Wilson,A.
S.
,Morse,J.
A.
,Awaki,H.
,&Iwasawa,K.
1998,ApJL,503,L123Schmidt,M.
,etal.
1997,A&A,329,495Schmidt,M.
,&Green,R.
F.
1983,ApJ,269,352Seaton,M.
J.
1979,MNRAS,187,785Shanks,T.
,Almaini,O.
,Boyle,B.
J.
,Done,C.
,Georgantopoulos,I.
,Grif-ths,R.
E.
,Rawling,S.
J.
,&Stewart,G.
C.
1995,Spectrum:NewsletteroftheRoyalObs.
,7,7Smith,H.
E.
,&Spinrad,H.
1980,ApJ,236,419Stickel,M.
,Rieke,G.
H.
,H.
,&Rieke,M.
J.
1996,ApJ,468,556Kuhr,Stocke,J.
T.
,Liebert,J.
,Maccacaro,T.
,Griffiths,R.
E.
,&Steiner,J.
E.
1982,ApJ,252,69Stocke,J.
T.
,Morris,S.
L.
,Gioia,I.
M.
,Maccacaro,T.
,Schild,R.
,Wolter,A.
,Fleming,T.
A.
,&Henry,J.
P.
1991,ApJS,76,813Tananbaum,H.
,etal.
1979,ApJ,234,L9J.
1983,Adv.
SpaceRes.
,2:4,241Trumper,Ueda,Y.
,etal.
1998,Nature,391,866M.
-P.
,&P.
1984,ESOSpecialRep.
1Veron-Cetty,Veron,Voges,W.
,etal.
1996,IAUCirc.
,6420,2Webster,R.
L.
,Francis,P.
J.
,Peterson,B.
A.
,Drinkwater,M.
J.
,&Mascl,F.
J.
1995,Nature,375,469White,N.
,Giommi,P.
,&Angelini,L.
1995,WGACAT,http://heasarc.
gsfc.
nasa.
gov/W3Browse/all/wgacat.
htmlWilkes,B.
J.
,&Elvis,M.
1987,ApJ,323,243Zitelli,V.
,Mignoli,M.
,Zamorani,G.
,Marano,B.
,&Boyle,B.
J.
1992,MNRAS,256,349
TheAmericanAstronomicalSociety.
Allrightsreserved.
PrintedinU.
S.
A.
(RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARSDONG-WOOKIM1ChungnamNationalUniversity,Taejon,305-764,SouthKoreaANDMARTINELVISHarvard-SmithsonianCenterforAstrophysics,60GardenStreet,Cambridge,MA02138Received1998May11;accepted1998December8ABSTRACTWehaveperformedasuccessfultargetedsearchforapopulationofred,radio-quiet,andprobablyabsorbedquasars.
Radio-quiet,opticallyredROSATPSPCX-raysourcesbrighterthan1]10~13ergscm~2s~1weresearchedforred(O[E[2.
0,O20)counterpartsintheAutomatedPlate-measuringMachinecatalogofPalomarSkySurveyobjects.
Of45objectsforwhichweobtainedadequatefollow-upopticalspectroscopy,wehavefoundsevenredquasars,vewithTheirredshiftsrangeaopt\[2.
from0.
06to0.
31,andtheirluminositiesaremoderate,lyingonthequasar/Seyfertboundary.
Theseredquasarsstrengthenthecaseforaradio-quietpopulationthatisthecounterpartoftheradio-loudredquasarsfoundbySmith&SpinradandWebsteretal.
Unidentied,faintersourcescouldincreasethefractionofredquasarsbyuptoafactorof7.
Fortheredquasarsfoundhere,theHa/Hbratios,opticalslope,andX-raycolorsallindicatethattheyareabsorbedbyratherthanhavingintrinsicallyredAVD2spectra.
ThisamountofobscurationseemstohideD1%7%ofquasarsatagivenobserveduxorD3%20%whentheiruxesarecorrectedtotheirintrinsicvalues.
Thissizeofpopulationisconsistentwithearlierlimits,withpredictedvaluesfromComastrietal.
,andiscomparablewiththeratefoundamongradio-loudquasars.
Alargepopulationofmoreheavilyabsorbedfainterquasarsequal(AV\5),insizetothebluepopulationcouldexistwithoutviolatingexistingupperlimits,whichisinaccordwiththeComastrietal.
predictions.
Subjectheadings:dust,extinctionquasars:generalX-rays:galaxies1.
INTRODUCTIONQuasarsarethecanonical""ultravioletexcessobjects(Sandage1965).
Yetredquasarshavebeenfoundinradio-selectedsamplesbySmith&Spinrad(1980)andWebsteretal.
(1995).
Websteretal.
(1995)proposedthatalargefrac-tion,perhaps80%,ofradio-loudquasarsmighthavebeenhiddenasredobjects.
Moreover,thecurrentlyfavoredexplanationsforthecosmicX-raybackgroundinvokeapopulationofheavilyobscuredactivegalacticnuclei(AGNs)5timesmorecommonthantheunobscuredpopu-lation(Comastrietal.
1995).
Ifthesmallnumberofknownredquasarsreallyisthe""tipoftheicebergofalarge,evendominant,quasarpopulation,thentheconsequenceswouldbeinteresting:theoverallAGNpopulationandsothemassiveblackholepopulationmaybe5timeslargerthanhadbeenthought;obscuredquasarswouldbealong-livedevolutionaryphase(seeSandersetal.
1988),orallquasarsmaybehiddenalong80%ofpossiblelinesofsight;andredquasarsmaycontributeimportantlytothecosmicX-raybackground.
TheWebsteretal.
conclusioniswidelydis-puted.
Boyle&diMatteo(1995),Stickeletal.
(1996),andBennetal.
(1998)allarguethatanymissingpopulationmustbesmallerandperhapsinsignicant,whileGunn&Shanks(1998)disagree.
HerewepresentanX-raybasedsurveytargetedexplicitlyatredAGNstondradio-quietredquasars.
Radio-loudredquasarsarerelativelyeasytond,sincetheradioemissionisunaectedbyabsorbinggasordustand,inlow-frequencysurveys,usuallycomesfromthelargeradiolobesthatliewelloutsideanyobscuringmaterialin1AlsoatHarvard-SmithsonianCenterforAstrophysics,60GardenStreet,Cambridge,MA02138.
thehostgalaxy.
Anexplicit,albeitsmall-scale,searchforradio-andX-rayloudbutopticallyquietquasars,whichshouldincludereddenedquasars,was,however,notsuc-cessful(Kollgaardetal.
1995).
Radio-quietredquasarsaremuchhardertond,althoughtheymightbeexpectedtobemuchmorecommon.
Inthenormalunreddenedpopulation,radio-quietquasarsoutnumberradio-loudquasars10to1(e.
g.
,theExtendedMediumSensitivitySurvey,Stockeetal.
1991;thePalomarGreencatalog[PG],Kellermanetal.
1989).
However,mostopticalquasarsurveysareactivelybiasedagainstndingredquasars.
SincethesesurveysprimarilysearchforUV-brightobjects(e.
g.
,Markarian,Lipovetsky,Markarian,&Stepanian1987;PG,Schmidt&Green1983;theLargeBrightQuasarSurvey,Hewett,Foltz,&Chaee1995;theHamburgQuasarSurvey,Engelsetal.
1998),theyareblindtoredobjects.
Asaresult,opticalboundsonhowlargeapopulationofradio-quietredquasarsmightexistareweak.
X-rayselectionprovidesawayofselectingredquasarsefficiently:hardX-rays(210keV)penetrateeventensofmagnitudesofopticalextinctionwithminimalabsorption.
EventhelowerenergybandofROSAT(0.
52.
5keV)isnotstronglyaectedbyopticalextinctionofuptoD2mag.
2Astrophysicsmightbeagainstus,sincealthoughbluequasarsareoverwhelminglyX-rayloud(Avni&Tanan-baum1986),redonesmightbeintrinsicallyX-rayfaint.
Fortunately,however,radio-loudredquasarsareknowntobeX-raysources(Bregmanetal.
1985;Elvisetal.
1994),sothisisunlikelytobeaproblem.
2ForstandardMilkyWaycompositionanddust-to-gasratio(Bohlin,Savage,&Drake1978;Seaton1979)thePSPCcountrateisreducedbyafactorof1/eatatomscm~2)forapower-lawAV\1.
7(NH\3]1021photonindexof2.
0,allat0redshift.
910KIM&ELVISVol.
516Completeux-limitedX-raysurveyshavefoundsomeredquasarsorAGNs(Stockeetal.
1982;Kruper&Canizares1989;Puchnarewiczetal.
1996,1997).
InparticulartheROSATInternationalX-Ray/OpticalSurvey(RIXOS)survey(Puchnarewicz&Mason1998)hasidentiedasmallsampleofredquasars.
AspartofamoregeneralsearchforminoritypopulationsofX-raysources,wehaveusedtheROSAT1983)(TrumperarchiveofpointedPSPC(Pfeermanetal.
1987)datatodesignanefficientsearchstrategyexplicitlytargetingredquasars.
TheROSATpointedarchiveprovidesuswithatenfoldincreaseinthenumberofX-raysourcesfrombeforeROSAT(toabout70,000)andreachesmorethan10timesfainterthantheROSATAll-SkySurvey(Vogesetal.
1996).
Bycarefullyselectingasmallnumberofinterestingobjects,wecanmakeanefficientsearchforaradio-quietpopulationofredquasars.
Inthispaperwendasubstantialpopulationofradio-quietredAGNsonthequasar/Seyfertluminositybound-ary.
2.
SAMPLESELECTIONMostROSATsourcesathighGalacticlatitudeareblue,unobscuredAGNs(e.
g.
,Boyle,Wilkes,&Elvis1997;Schmidtetal.
1997).
WeusethisfacttoefficientlyselectagainstsuchobjectsandsoisolateanyredAGNthatmaybeintheROSATarchive.
AsacompendiumoftheX-raysourcesfoundbytheROSATPSPCwehaveusedthe""WGACATcatalog(whichisnamedafteritsauthors,White,Giommi,&Angel-ini1995).
ThiscatalogwasgeneratedfromROSATPSPCpointedobservationsusingaslidingcell,detectalgorithm.
Thismethodissensitivetondingpointsourcesbutcanalsondspurioussourceswhereextendedemissionispresent.
WGACATincludesaqualityagthatnotessuchdubiousdetectionsbasedonavisualinspectionoftheelds.
WehaveonlyusedX-raysourceswithhighdetectionqualityinordertoexcludethespurioussources.
FromtheWGACATcatalogwehaveselectedsourcesbythefollow-ingcriteria:1.
X-raybrightergscm~2s~1)toallow(fX[10~13follow-upobservationswithotherX-raytelescopes;2.
welldetectedwithasignal-to-noiseratiogreaterthan10andaWGACATqualityag,DQFLAG,greaterthan5;3.
withinr\18@fromthedetectorcentertoprovidegoodpositions;4.
athighgalacticlatitude(obo[20)tominimizethefractionofGalacticstars(whicharealsored);5.
notwithin2@ofthetargetposition(atwhichpointthesourcedensityreachesthebackgroundlevel)toselectonlyrandom,serendipitous,sources;6.
northofdecl.
\[18inordertohavetwobandmea-surementsintheAutomatedPlate-measuringMachine(APM)catalog(McMahon&Irwin1992),hencegivinganarchivalopticalcolor;and7.
unidentied,withWGACATclass\9999andnoSIMBADorNASAExtragalacticDatabaseidentication.
3Therstsixcriteriaselected1624sources.
SincethesesourceswereselectedpurelyontheirX-rayproperties,theyformawell-denedsamplefromwhichtostudytheinci-denceofminorityX-raypopulations,includinganyradio-quietredquasars.
Addingtherequirementthatasourcebeunidentiedleft940X-raysourcesthatcouldbeexaminedforhavingredopticalcounterparts.
WethensearchedtheAPMcatalogofobjectsdetectedonthePalomarSkySurveyforopticalcounterpartstotheunidentiedX-raysources.
Tondcounterparts,weusedasearchradiusof26A,whichcorrespondstoabout95%con-denceforX-raysourceswithin18@ofthePSPCdetectorcenter(Boyleetal.
1995a).
Ofthese,881sourceshadAPMcatalogcounterpartsbrighterthanthelimitingmagnitudesO\21.
5andE\20.
(Theremaining""blankeldsarethe3Althoughonly""unidentiedsourceswereselected,one(1WGAJ1118.
0]4505;Table1)turnedouttobeaknownSeyfert1(Badeetal.
1995).
Fig.
1aFig.
1bFIG.
1.
(a)OpticallyidentiedEMSSsourcesintheplane.
Dierentsourcesaremarkedbydierentsymbols.
Oursource-selectioncriteriaaox-(O[E)(O[E[2,areseenasalowerrightbox.
(b)Sameas(a)butforourROSATsamples.
Thelineshowshowaslightlystrictercriterionyieldsaaox\1.
8)aoxlargerfractionofredquasars.
No.
1,1999RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARS11subjectofanotherstudy;Elvis,Kim,&Nicastro1999.
)Amongthese881,manyhadonlyO-bandmagnitudes(suggestingthattheyareblue),leaving575withO[Ecolorsavailable.
ThecombinationoftheROSATX-rayuxandtheAPMmagnitudesallowsustocreatearoughclassicationoftheX-raysourcesinoursample.
ThetwoPalomarO(blue)andE(red)magnitudesareclosetoJohnsonBandCousinsR,respectively(Greggetal.
1996).
FromtheX-rayuxandthetwoopticalmagnitudeswecanconstructatwo-colordiagramofisdenedbythepower-lawindexaox-(O[E).
aoxbetween2keVand2500(Tananbaumetal.
1979;StockeAetal.
1991).
ThisdiagramallowsustoselectredobjectsandthenreducetheGalacticstellarpopulationamongtheseredobjectsbyselectingtheX-rayloudpopulation.
HerewemakeuseoftheobservationthatinstellarsourcestheX-rayuxforagivenopticaluxismuchweakerthaninAGNsandclusters(e.
g.
,Maccacaroetal.
1988).
Figure1ashowsEinsteinExtendedMediumSensitivitySurvey(EMSS)X-raysources(Stockeetal.
1991)intheplane.
aox-(O[E)ThisplotclearlyillustratesthedistinctionbetweenGalacticstellarsourcesandextragalacticsources.
BasedontheEMSSsourcedistribution,wedividedtheROSAT-APMsourcesonthesameplane(Fig.
1b).
TheO[EAPMcolorsarenotasaccurateastheEMSSvalues,whicharebasedonCCDphotometry.
Asaresult,thespreadofobservedcolorsiswider(Fig.
1b),andtherewillbesomeblueobjectsintheredzoneandviceversa.
Tocreateourlistofredquasarcandidates,werstexcludedthe128sourceswithbecausetheyarelikelytobeGalacticaox[1.
8,stars.
Thenweexcludedanother360sourceswithbluecolors,O[E\2,becausetheyaremostlikelyjustnormal,blue,unobscuredAGNs.
Thisresultsinanalsampleof87X-raysourcesdenedbythelowerrightcornerofFigure1bintheplane.
aox-(O[E)Oursampleof87opticallyredX-rayloudsourcesisamere0.
1%oftheD70,000WGACATsources.
ThefractionofX-raysourcesthatmayberedquasars,however,ismuchlarger:D5%oftheinitialX-rayselectedsample,D15%oftheunidentiedsourceswithAPMcolors,andD20%ofX-raybrightobjectswithAPMcolorsthatwillprimarilybeAGNs.
However,otherclassesofX-raysourcethanredquasarscaninhabitthisregionoftheplane:forexample,aox-(O[E)rst-rankedellipticalgalaxiesindistantclustersofgalaxies.
Opticalspectroscopyisneededtondredquasars.
Wehavetakenspectrafor51ofthe87redquasarcandidates,asisdescribedinthenextsection.
3.
OBSERVATIONS3.
1.
OpticalSpectroscopyAtypicalX-rayerrorcirclecontainsjust12opticalobjectsintheAPMcatalog.
Sincewehaveselectedagainstbluecounterparts,webeganbyobservingthebrightestredcounterpart.
Iftwoobjectswerepresent,wealignedthespectrographslittoobtainspectraofbothatonce.
IfthistherstspectradidnotndanAGN,wethenobservedthenextfaintest,ifpresent.
Sincethedensityof(blue)AGNsatB\21isonlyD0.
005pererrorcircle(e.
g.
,Zitellietal.
1992),weexpectonlya1in4chanceofAGNcoincidenceinthe51spectra,sostoppingonceanAGNisfoundwillnotproduceasignicantnumberoffalseidentications.
WeperformedopticalspectroscopywiththeMultipleMirrorTelescope(MMT)on1997March1315,withtheFredLawrenceWhippleObservatory(FLWO)60Atele-scopeon1996November1617and1997February1213,andwiththeCerroTololoInter-AmericanObservatory(CTIO)60Atelescopeon1997February35.
Weusedlong-slitaperturesof2@@3@@]180@@andgratingswith300gpm.
Thespectralresolutionsare6and9fortheMMTand60AAtelescopes,respectively.
Wavelengthcoverageisabout35008000Wetookbias,domeat,andtwilightskyA.
frameseachnight,andthecorrespondingcorrections(biassubtraction,atelding,andilluminationcorrection)wereappliedseparatelytoeachnightofdata.
Atleasttwostan-dardstarswereobservedeachnightforspectrophotometriccalibration.
Theobservingconditionswerenotphoto-metric,exceptfortheCTIOrun,sotheabsolutecalibrationissubjecttoasignicantuncertainty.
However,relativeintensities(suchasalineintensityratioandanopticalpower-lawindex)areaccuratewithin20%,asisconrmedbymultipleobservationsofthesamesource.
Sixsourcesareofundeterminednaturebecausetheyaretoofaintandsogavespectraoftoopoorasignal-to-noiseratio.
3.
2.
ClassicationofSpectraOfthe45sourcesobservedatagoodsignal-to-noiseratio,wehaveidentiedsevenredquasars(Table1).
Theresultsforthesesevenredquasarsarepresentedinthispaper.
(Thefulldatasetwillappearelsewhere.
)Theredquasarsaremixedinwith18starsandasmallnumberofnormalbluequasars,narrowemissionlinegalaxies,andellipticalgalaxies(Table1).
Theellipticalgalaxiesarelikelytobebrightestclustergalaxies.
Wewillreportontheseseparately.
FortheremainingnineX-raysources,theredopticalcandidatewithintheerrorcircleturnedouttobeastar(mostlylatetype),butitisnotlikelythattheseredstarsarethecounterparts,becausetheirvaluesaretoolargeaoxforastar(seeabove;Maccacaroetal.
1988).
Theremainingopticalcandidatesarenotred,andhencewestoppedmakingfurtherobservations.
TheseninesourcesandthethreebluequasarsmeasurethebluecontaminationofthesampleandshouldnotbeconsideredaspartofthelistofredX-raycounterparts.
TheopticalspectraofthesevenredquasarsareshowninFigures2aand2b.
BroadlinesofHa,Hb,andMgIIareclearlyseeninthespectraaswellasbrightnarrowlines(e.
g.
,[OIII]j5007),makingtheAGNcharacteroftheobjectsunambiguous.
InTable2wetabulatesourceposition,red-shift,opticalmagnitudeandcolor,X-rayuxandX-rayTABLE1SUMMARYOFOPTICALIDENTIFICATIONSOFREDX-RAYSOURCECOUNTERPARTSMeasurementTotalRedQuasarsTooFaintNLXGEllipticalGalaxiesMStarsOtherStarsBlueQuasarsNotRed1.
8[aox[1.
6(O19)22100117102aox\1.
6(O\19)2966241037Total5176251813912KIM&ELVISVol.
516Fig.
2aFig.
2bFIG.
2.
(a)Observedspectraoftheveradio-quietredquasars(O[E[2mag,BroadlinessuchasHa,Hb,andMgIIareclearlyseenintheaopt[2.
0).
spectraaswellasbrightnarrowlines(e.
g.
,[OIII]j5007).
Thosestronglinesaremarkedinthegures.
SteepcontinuumslopesandveryweakHblinestrengthsindicateasignicantamountofdustextinctionmag),incontrastto(b),twoquasarspectrawithandrelativelystrongHblines.
(AV[2aopt\2.
0colors,andaswellasosetsbetweentheopticalandaox,X-raypositions.
InFigure1beachclassofidentiedsourcesisplottedintheplane.
Thedistributionofthesesourcesaox-(O[E)canbecomparedwiththeEMSSsourcesinFigure1a,conrmingthatmostX-raysourceswithlowareindeedaoxquasarsorgalaxyclusters.
Theselectiontechniquends7/51redquasars,i.
e.
,8%efficiency.
Aslightlystrictercri-terion,(insteadof1.
8),wouldhaveselectedredaox\1.
6quasarsmoreefficiently(Table2;Fig.
1b):onlyoneMstar(insteadof19stars)wouldhavebeenpresent,withonlyoneredquasarlost,i.
e.
,6/29,alittleover20%.
Oftheinitial87,71%(62)remainwhenistheboundary.
aox\1.
63.
3.
ObservedOpticalPropertiesoftheRedQuasarsWemeasuredtheopticalcontinuumslopesbyttingapowerlawtothecontinuumspectraafterexcludingthestrongemissionlines(Table3).
AlthoughallthesourcesTABLE2BASICPROPERTIESOFREDQUASARSNameRightAngleaDeclinationaOsetbzfXcasoftdahardeOO[Eaox(aopt\[2.
0)J2255.
5]0536225531.
005360111.
30.
06477.
741.
4590.
75016.
382.
441.
636J1234.
3]2614123421.
82613285.
00.
31202.
420.
8601.
71120.
552.
351.
180J1218.
1]2956121807.
12955214.
30.
15141.
620.
9591.
51219.
162.
081.
466J0909.
7]4302090943.
64302477.
00.
27481.
650.
8591.
41721.
382.
281.
114J1143.
6]5521114335.
55520214.
00.
14671.
520.
5351.
04019.
332.
331.
451[0.
9[aopt[[2.
0)J1051.
4]3358105128.
33358048.
00.
18292.
761.
2901.
29518.
272.
721.
515J1142.
6]4624114241.
24624213.
10.
115115.
750.
9261.
26316.
332.
441.
522aOpticalcoordinateinEquinoxJ2000.
bDierenceofX-rayandopticalpositionsinarcseconds.
cInunitsof10~13ergs~1cm~2.
dX-rayspectralindexin0.
10.
8keV.
eX-rayspectralindexin0.
82.
0keV.
No.
1,1999RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARS13TABLE3LINE,CONTINUUMPROPERTIES,ANDLUMINOSITIESOFREDQUASARSADDD4000HaNameaoptaFWHMfcLdM(O)M(E)L(X)43b(aopt\[2.
0)J2255.
5]05362.
39596229.
80.
54[21.
6[24.
11.
02J1234.
3]26142.
647184e5.
1e2.
70e[21.
1[23.
58.
19J1218.
1]29562.
3650115.
20.
56[20.
8[22.
91.
21J0909.
7]43022.
4321782.
30.
91[20.
0[22.
34.
29J1143.
6]55212.
1132235.
10.
51[20.
5[22.
91.
07([0.
9[aopt[[2.
0)J1051.
4]33580.
931797f7.
1f7.
10f[22.
1[24.
83.
07J1142.
6]46241.
41310481.
34.
90[23.
0[25.
46.
75aOpticalspectralindex,flPlaopt.
bInunitsof1043ergss~1.
cInunitsof10~15ergscm~2s~1.
dInunitsof1043ergss~1.
eMgII.
fHb.
wereselectedbasedonaredO[Ecolor,insomecasestheobservedopticalcontinuumshapeisrelativelyat.
Thisisbecauseofbothlineemissioncontributingtotheblueand/orredbandsanduncertaintiesontheOandEmagni-tudes,particularlywhentheobjectisfaint(M.
Irwin1996,privatecommunication).
Thepower-lawindex(FlDlaopt)rangesfrom[0.
9to[2.
6.
Asteepopticalcontinuum,isfoundinveofthesevenredquasars,whileaopt\[2,eventheremainingtwo,intermediateredquasarsareredderthanisfoundforUV-excessselected([1.
5\aopt\[1)quasars([0.
2^0.
8;Neugebaueretal.
1987).
Toillustratethespectraldierencesbetweenthesetwogroups,wedisplaythespectraseparatelyinFigures2a(steep)and2b(intermediate).
Inadditiontothedierenceincontinuumshape,thesetwogroupsalsodierintheirHblinestrengths(seeFigs.
2aand2b).
ThegroupwiththesteepopticalcontinuumhaveonlyweakHblinesornodetection,whereasthegroupwitharelativelyatcontinuumhavestrongerHblines.
SincetheratioofHatoHbissensitivetoopticalextinction,thissuggestsmorereddeninginthesteepslopegroupthantheintermediateslopegroup(Table3),whichisinaccordwiththeopticalcontinuumslopes.
ToquantifythiseectforthosequasarswithnodetectedHbline,weestimateditsupperlimitusingasimplemethodthatassumesaboxprolewithabaseequalto3000kms~1(themeanFWHMofdetectedHblines)andaheightequalto3timestheuctuationnoiseonthecontinuum.
Thisisaconservativemeasurement,becausethepeakofaGaussianprolewouldbemoreeasilydetectedthantheattopofaboxprole,particularlywhenthelinewidthisconsiderablylargerthanthespectralresolution.
MonteCarlosimula-tionsusingaGaussianlineproleassumingPoissonsta-tisticsshowthattheboxproleoverestimatestheupperlimitbyupto50%fortheadoptedlinewidth,whileitreproducesconsistentresultswhenthelinewidthiscompa-rablewiththespectralresolution.
ForthetwoobjectswhoseopticalspectradonotcovertheHaline,wehaveinsteadusedthe[OIII]/HbratioasameasureofrelativeHbstrength.
ForallvequasarswiththeHa/Hbratiosaopt\[2,aregreaterthan5,whilethe[OIII]/Hb[0.
8.
Thelineratiosofthetworemainingquasarsaresmaller(Table2),whichisconsistentwithlessreddeninginintermediate-slopeobjects.
Noneofthecharacteristicgalaxianstellarabsorptionfeatures4areseeninourspectra.
Moststrikingly,no4000Abreakisseeninanyoftheveredquasarsforwhichourspectracoverthatregion,includingallofthesteep-slopegroup.
TypicalvaluesofD(4000)5are11.
2,asisexpectedfromthemeasuredopticalslopes.
Thesecomparewithvaluesof2^0.
2fornormalEandS0galaxiesDressler&Shectman(1987).
Henceanystarlightcontinuumcontribu-tiontotheredquasarcontinuummustbeminor.
3.
4.
X-RayColorsoftheRedQuasarsTodeterminetheroughX-rayspectralpropertiesofthesevenredquasars,werstdouble-checkedinthePSPCimagesthatthesourceswerecleanlyseparatedfromanyconfusingsources,thenmeasuredtheirX-rayhardness(HR\H/M)andsoftness(SR\S/M)ratiosbasedonthecountratesinthestandardROSATPSPCbands:soft,S(0.
10.
4keV);medium,M(0.
40.
86keV);andhard,H(0.
872keV).
TheseratiosarethenconvertedtoeectiveX-rayspectralindices,and(Table2),tocorrectforthevariableasoftahardGalacticline-of-sightabsorptionandtheenergy-dependentpoint-spreadfunction.
(ThesearenotphysicalslopesbutshouldbeconsideredanalogoustoU[BandB[Vcolors;seeFioreetal.
1998foradetaileddiscussionoftheestima-tionandusageofeectiveX-rayspectralindices.
)Duetothelowsignal-to-noiseratioofX-raydata,individualspec-tralindicesarenotreliable.
However,thelocusoftheircolorsformsausefulindicatorofglobalX-rayproperties.
Wecomparethecolorsoftheredquasarswiththoseofnormalradio-quietquasarsinFigure3.
Thelargelledsymbolsaretheredquasarsreportedhere,whilethecloudofsmalldotsrepresentsradio-quietquasarsfromthesampleofFioreetal.
(1998).
Onaverage,theredquasarshavesmallerthanindicatingacutospectralasoftahard,shape.
[Thelinepairsaroundtheperipheryofthegure4CHG-bandj4304,MgIj5175,Ca]Fej5269,Najj5890,5896.
Dressler&Shectman5D(4000)\Fl(40504250A)/Fl(37503950A),(1987).
14KIM&ELVISVol.
516FIG.
3.
EectivesoftandhardROSATPSPCX-rayspectralindices(seetext)oftheredquasars(largelledsymbols)comparedwithnormalradio-quietquasars(smalldots;Fioreetal.
1998).
Steepopticalspectrum(a\[2)redquasarsareshownascircles,andintermediateopticalspec-trum([1.
5\a\[1)redquasarsareshownastriangles.
Thelinepairsaroundtheperipheryofthegureshowoutlinespectralshapesfortheirlocationsintheplane.
(ahard,ahard)showoutlinespectralshapesfortheirlocationsinthe(asoft,plane.
]Thisisconsistentwiththeirhavingthemoder-ahard)ateX-rayabsorptionexpectedfromtheiropticalproperties(Fioreetal.
1998).
4.
DISCUSSIONTheseobservationsshowthatapopulationofredAGNscanbeextractedefficientlyfromtheROSATpointedarchive.
Moreover,theredAGNswendareradioquiet.
NoneofthemisaradiosourceintheNRAOVLARadioSkySurveymJy;Condonetal.
1998),(f1.
4GHz\2.
5implyingGHz)]\2.
0,comparedwithRL\log[f(opt)/f(5forradio-loudquasars(Wilkes&Elvis1987).
2\RL\5TheagreementofX-raycolors,opticalcontinuumslope,andHa/Hbratioswiththesamevalueofobscuringdustandgasarguesfortheirbeingdustreddened(AVD12)objectsratherthaninstrinsicallyredcontinua.
Puchnarewicz&Mason(1988)discussasimilarpopu-lationof14candidatered,AGNsderivedfromtheaopt[2,RIXOSsample,whichextendstoseveraltimesfainterX-rayuxes.
TheRIXOSsamplewasselectedfromtheROSATpointedarchivebasedonX-rayuxalone.
(Thereisoneobjectincommonbetweenthetwosamples.
)TwooftheredRIXOSAGNsmaybeintrinsicallyred,andthreehaveclearreddening.
SothereiscurrentlyatotalofeightreddenedAGNsavailablefromROSAT.
TheredAGNs,bothfromthissampleandfromRIXOS,areborderlinequasar/Seyfertobjects.
TheobservedopticalluminositiesoftheredAGNsaremodest,lyingatthehighendofthetraditionalSeyfertluminosityrange(MB[[23mag;Veron-Cetty&Veron1984;Schmidt&Green1983):fromto[22mag.
6Thedereddened,intrinsicMO\[206Wehaveusedkms~1Mpc~1andH0\50q0\0.
luminosityofthesourcesislikelytobesignicantlyhigher,dependingontheamountofabsorption(thelowerlimitontheextinctionis23maginO).
Thisplacesthematwhichiswithinthequasarregime.
[25\MO\[22,Similarly,theobservedX-rayluminosityrangesfrom1.
3]1043to1.
2]1044ergss~1,whiletheintrinsiclumi-nositiesarelikelytobehigherbyaboutafactorof2,dependingontheintrinsicspectrumandtheamountofabsorptionpresent.
ThepreciseallocationoftheseAGNsasquasarsorSey-fertsisnotfundamentallyveryinteresting,sincethisisjustaconvenientlychosenvalueonacontinuousluminosityscale.
Forsimplicitywewillrefertothemasredquasarsfortherestofthispaper.
Itis,however,interestingtounder-standwhymuchmoreormuchlessluminousAGNswerenotfoundinthetworedquasarsearches.
Isthisaselectioneect,oristhereaphysicalpreferenceforredobjectstoclusterinalimitedrangeofluminosityWewillreturntothisquestionlater(°4.
3).
Theexistenceofaredquasarpopulationimmediatelyraisesimportantquestions.
Whatmakesthemredcom-paredwithusualbluequasarsHowcommonarethey,particularlyonceallowanceismadefortheirreduceduxduetoprobableobscurationIftheyareabsorbed,byhowmuchWhereistheabsorbingdustymaterialMightalarger,moreobscured,AGNpopulationexist4.
1.
HowCommonareRedQuasarsWecanaddresstherelativenumbersofredquasarsinaroughway.
Thepopulation,althoughaminority,isquitecommon.
Wefoundsevenredquasarsoutof45candidatesforwhichourspectroscopywasadequatetoproduceaclas-sication.
Assumingthatthe45werearandomsubsampleoftheoriginalsampleof87,thatsamplewouldproduce14redquasars.
Thisis2.
4%of575sourceswithopticalcolorsavailable.
Atouruxlimit,Stockeetal.
(1991)ndthat51%ofallX-raysourcesareAGNs.
Soaminimumof13.
5/288(4.
7%)AGNsinourunidentiedsampleareradio-quietredquasars(withO\20)atthissoftX-rayuxlevel.
TheBoyle&diMatteo(1995)upperlimitof9%ofCam-bridgeROSATSerendipitySurvey(CRSS)X-raysourcesbeingredquasarsisconsistentwiththeminoritypopulationofmoderatelyobscuredquasarswehavefound(AV\2)here.
Additionalredquasarscouldbehiddeninoursample.
Oursampleof45classiedspectraisnotarandomsub-sampleofthecandidatelist.
Figure1bshowsthatweprefer-entiallyselectedobjectswithi.
e.
,thebrighteraox[1.
3,objects(withB\21.
5).
Ifthesixobjectsforwhichweattemptedtogetspectraturnouttoberedquasars,thenthefractionofredquasarsamongthePSPCAGNscouldbealmostdoubleourrstestimate.
Thereareafurther36redcandidatesforwhichnospectroscopywasattempted.
Sothetrueoccurrencerateofredquasarsisuncertainbyafactorof7.
TondthefractionofredquasarsamongalltheAGNsinourX-ray,ux-limitedsample,wemustallowforthe165300blueAGNsintheidentiedsample,so1%7%ofthewholesoftX-rayAGNpopulationisred.
IftheredAGNsareobscured,thentheintrinsicrateofoccurrenceofredquasarshastobecalculatedrelativetotheirunreddenedparentpopulation.
ObscurationbyAV\reducestheirunobscuredX-rayuxesbyafactorofD2.
2SincehigheruxAGNsarerarer(theX-rayselectedAGNNo.
1,1999RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARS15logN/logSrelationhasaslopeof[3/2inthisuxrange;Hasinger1995;DellaCeccaetal.
1992),theredpopulationformsalargerfractionofthispopulation,D3%20%.
Usingthefractionofthesourcesattheintrinsicuxoftheredquasarsallowsustocompareourresultwithsamplesunaectedbyobscurationandwithmodelpredic-tions.
Comparisonswiththeobservedfrequencyofradio-loudredquasarswithbroademissionlinesfoundbySmith&Spinrad(1980;178MHz3CR)andStickeletal.
(1996;5GHz1Jysample)andwiththeComastrietal.
(1995)pre-dictionsarestraightforward.
Redquasarsarefoundin15%ofthe3CRsourcesampleand6%20%ofthe1Jy(Carillietal.
1998)sample.
Thesearecomparablewiththe3%-20%ofthe""intrinsicuxX-raypopulationthatwend,suggestingthattheradio-loudandradio-quietquasarpopulationshavesimilarlysizedpopulationsofmoderatelyobscuredquasars.
Theobscurationinthe3CRredquasarsisalsoaboutAV\2(Elvisetal.
1994;Economouetal.
1995;Rawlingsetal.
1995).
Forfourobjectsinthe1Jysample,Carillietal.
(1998)estimatelowerlimitsonfrom2to5basedonAVextrapolatingtheradio-infraredindextotheoptical.
However,sincesuchsteeplyrisingslopesarenotknownamongunobscuredquasars,theselimitsarelikelytobetoolarge,andvaluescomparablewiththe3CRestimatesareprobablyacceptable.
ForAGNswithcm~2,theComastrietal.
NH\1022(1995)modelpredictsthat26%willhave1021\NH\1022cm~2whichissomewhatlargerbutcomparable(AVD2),withthenumbersfoundhere.
Comastrietal.
predictfarlargernumbersofmoreobscuredobjects.
4.
2.
MoreObscuredObjectsMoreobscuredobjectsmayexist.
Puchnarewicz&Mason(1998)ndseveralobjectswithsteeperopticalcon-tinua,andFigure1bshowsseveralreddercandidatesandmanymoreX-rayloudcandidateswithnoopticalspectratodate.
Websteretal.
(1995)suggestedthatmaybeAV\5typicaloftheirredobjects,givingtheirputativeROSATcounterpartsinoursampleV\2325,whichisbelowthePalomarSkySurveylimit.
correspondstoacolumnAV\5of9]1021atomscm~2,whichwouldreduceROSATPSPCcountratesto15%oftheirunobscuredvalues.
Theseobjectswouldthenbehiddenasa6%minorityamongthemorecommon,lowerluminosity,unabsorbedquasarsiftheyhadthesameunobscuredspacedensityasnormalbluequasars.
Some9%ofourinitialX-rayselectedsampleare""blankeldobjects,i.
e.
,havenocounterpartonthePalomarSkySurveys.
Afractionofthesecouldbemoreheavilyobscuredredquasars.
Boyle&diMatteo(1995)ndthattheCRSSsamplecouldbemissingnomorethan9%(attheobservedux)inredquasars.
Subtractingthe1%ofmoderatelyobscuredquasarswehaveidentiedstillleaves8%thatcouldbehighlyobscured.
HencetheCRSSresultis,perhapssurprisingly,consistentwithasizeable,heavilyobscuredpopulation.
TheComastrietal.
(1995)modelpre-dictsacomparablepopulationofAGNswithNHD1022cm~2,whichis1.
1timeslargerthantheunobscuredpopu-lation.
Inoursampletheoccurrenceofredquasarsappearstobe4timeshigherforO[19mag(4/12)thanforO\19mag(3/32;Table2),althoughthenumberofsourcesissmall.
Suchatrendisexpectedifthequasarsareheavilyabsorbed.
Anincreaseinfrom3]1021to1]1022NHcm~2cutstheROSATuxbyafactorof2.
4butreddenstheVbandby3.
8mag(afactor33).
Sotheopticallyfaintersourcesmightwellberedder.
However,theRIXOSredquasars(Puchnarewicz&Mason1998)shownocorrelationofopticalslopewiththethreesteepestslopesareallinmV:thebrighterhalfofthesampleof14.
Gunn&Shanks(1998)havepointedoutthatwhileredshiftingtheultravioletintotheopticalincreasestheeectsofreddening,thecorre-spondingshiftofhardX-raysintothesoftROSATbanddecreasestheeectivenessofreddening.
Toestimateanaccuratefractionofthispotentialhiddenpopulationneedsalargersample,includingmoreabsorbed,fainterobjects.
Atevenlargercolumndensities(10231024cm~2)theComastrietal.
(1995)modelpredictsnearly4timestheunobscuredpopulation.
MoreheavilyobscuredquasarscouldbefoundinhardX-raysurveysfromASCA(Uedaetal.
1998)andtheBeppo-SAXHELLASsurvey(Fioreetal.
1999).
4.
3.
LimitedLuminosityRangeItisstrikingthatwhileROSATsurveysthataredenedsimplybyanX-rayuxlimitndAGNsspanningover3decadesinX-rayluminosity(e.
g.
,CRSS,Boyleetal.
1997;RIXOS,Puchnarewiczetal.
1996),bothRIXOSandthissurveyndredquasarsinonly1decadeofluminosity,andthisdecadeisthelowestoneinwhichRIXOSandCRSSAGNsarefound.
Atwo-tailKolmogorov-SmirnovtestshowsthatthechancethatredandnonredAGNsfromRIXOScomefromthesameluminositydistributionisonlyD2%.
ThissuggeststhatpredominantlylowerluminosityAGNsareobscured.
(NotethattheobservedamountofobscurationonlydecreasestheobservedX-rayluminositybyafactorofD2,andsodoesnotitselfcausethelowobservedluminosities.
)Similarsuggestionshavebeenmadebefore:Lawrence&Elvis(1982)foundthatonlyAGNsbelowergsLXD1044s~1(210keV)showedobscuration.
Occasionalexamplesofhighlyobscuredtype2(i.
e.
,narrow-line)quasarshavebeenreported(Stockeetal.
1982;Almainietal.
1995;Shanksetal.
1995),andcarefulsearcheshavefoundbroadHainmostcases(Halpern,Eracleous,&Forster1998),makingthemsimilartotheredquasarsfoundhere.
Search-esamongthefainterobjectsinoursampleandsearchesathigherenergies(e.
g.
,theBeppo-SAXHELLASsurvey;Fioreetal.
1999)willbemoreeectiveatndingahigh-luminosityredquasarpopulation.
TheComastrietal.
X-raybackgroundmodelsassumeluminosityfunctionsfortheobscuredobjectsthatareiden-ticaltothoseoftheunobscuredobjectsexceptfornormal-izationandsopredictshigh-luminosityredquasars.
IfinsteadobscuredAGNsoccurpreferentiallyatlowlumi-nosity,thiswillsubstantiallyaectthemodelpredictions.
Wewould,forexample,expecttheobscuredpopulationtobemorenumerousandatlowerredshift.
Ifthereisarealdecitofhigh-luminosityredquasars,thenonepossibilitytoexplainthislackmighthavebeenthatasanAGNbecamemoreluminous,thecontinuumionizedtheobscuringmedium,renderingittransparenttoX-rays.
However,ionizedabsorbersarealsomorecommonatlowerluminosities(Laoretal.
1994).
Somostlikely,high-luminosityAGNshavefewerlinesofsightwithinterveningmaterialregardlessofionizationstate.
(Interestingly,thisisinthesamesenseastheBaldwineect:thathigherlumi-nosityquasarshaveweakerCIII]j1909emissionlines.
)Any16KIM&ELVISVol.
516physicalmodelofaquasarwouldneedtoexplainthisdier-ence.
4.
4.
PhysicalPropertiesWecansayonlyalittleaboutthephysicalpropertiesoftheredquasarsfromthisdata.
TheconsistencyoftheopticalreddeningindicatorswiththeX-raycolorssuggeststhatthesameobscuringmaterialcoversbothemittingregionsandthatitliesoutsidethebroademissionlineregion.
Smith&Spinrad(1980)suggestedthattherednessofthered3CRquasarsisintrinsictothecontinuumemissionprocessbasedonthelackofanabsorptionfeatureatj\2200whichisatypicalcharacteristicofMilkyWayA,dust(e.
g.
,Bless&Savage1972).
Thedetectionof21cmHIabsorptiontowardalargefractionofthe1Jy(Stickeletal.
1996)redquasars(Carillietal.
1998)arguesfordustreddeninginthoseobjects.
Sinceoursampleofradio-quietquasarsisrelativelynearby(withredshiftsupto0.
3),wecannotcheckforthisfeaturedirectly.
However,thisexpla-nationisincontrasttotheobservedBalmerdecrementandtheX-raycolors.
Itispossiblethatthereddened3CRsourcescontaindusty,ionizedabsorbers,asisseenin3C212(Mathur1994;Elvisetal.
1994)andIRAS17020]4544(Komossa&Bade1998),wherethedustcompositionmaydierdependingon,forexample,thequasarcontinuumshape.
Ultravioletobservationsareneededtoinvestigatethej\2200featurebutareprobablyinfeasibleatApresent.
4.
5.
OtherRedAGNsSomepreviousstudieshaveconsideredredAGN-likeobjectsinX-raysurveys.
TheRIXOSsurvey(Puchnarewicz&Mason1998)foundthat9%(14/160)oftheirAGNswerered.
However,onlythreeoftheRIXOSsourceshaveBalmerdecrementsthatrequirereddening,sothetrueoccurrencerateofreddenedobjectsmaybesimilartowhatwehavefound.
ThefainteruxlimitoftheRIXOSsurveymayrendermoreabsorbedobjectsvisible.
Certainly,thesteeperopticalslopesofhalfthe([2.
5[aopt[[4.
0)RIXOSsamplesuggestgreaterreddening.
Kruper&Canizares(1989)studiedredAGNsinEinsteinX-rayselectedsamplesandindirectlyconcludedthattheseareredbecauseofthepresenceofhostgalaxies.
Bennetal.
(1998)arriveatasimilarconclusionforlow-frequency,selectedradio-loudquasars.
However,nogalaxianstarlightfeaturesareseeninourspectra,andthehostgalaxycannotexplaintheobservedBalmerdecrementsinoursample.
TheKruper&Canizaresobjectsarenotasredasoursamples,havingB[I\1.
52.
5mag.
IfwetakeR[Itobe0.
51.
0mag(thisistheR[IrangeofthesamplesintheirTable2),B[Rwouldbelessthan2.
0,ourdeningthreshold.
Infact,noneoftheirobjectswithmeasuredRmagnitudesexceedB[R\2.
0.
Thenarrow-lineX-raygalaxies(NLXGs)foundplenti-fullyindeepROSATsurveys(e.
g.
,Boyleetal.
1995a)arealsonormallyassumedtobeobscuredAGNs(e.
g.
,Hasingeretal.
1998;Schachteretal.
1998).
X-rayabsorbedNLXGscouldcontributesignicantlytothecosmicX-rayback-groundiftheyaremorecommonatfainterX-rayuxlevels,aswassuggestedbyMcHardyetal.
(1998;seealsoHasingeretal.
1998foracautionarynote).
AlthoughtheyhavesimilarX-rayluminositiestotheNLXGs,theX-rayselectedredquasarsarenotsimplythesamepopulation,however.
Theredquasarshavethenormal,broadopticalemissionlinesofquasars,whileNLXGshaveeithernoneoronlyextremelyweakones(Boyleetal.
1995b;Figs.
2aand2b).
Moreover,NLXGsusuallyexhibitblueopticalcontin-ua(forexample,O[E\2forveoutofsixNLXGsinCRSS;Boyleetal.
1997),whileredquasarshaveredopticalcontinua(O[E[2).
FurtherX-rayandopticalstudyoftheseobjectsmayletusunderstandwhethertheyaretwoseparatepopulationsorarerelatedby,e.
g.
,specialviewinggeometryorscatteringofabluecontinuum.
ThePalomarsurveyofthenucleiofbrightgalaxies(Ho,Filippenko,&Sargent1997)isbasedonasampleofgal-axiesselectedfortheirnonnuclearpropertiesandsoislessbiasedagainstndingredAGNsthanmostotheropticalsearchmethods.
ThePalomarAGNsarelow-luminosityAGNs,allowingustoseewhetherthehighincidenceofredAGNsatlowerluminositiescontinuestoincreaseatevenlowervalues.
ThePalomarsurveyndsthat18%(8/44)ofSeyfertnucleihavebasedontheirnarrow-lineAV[2Balmerdecrements(Hoetal.
1997).
However,almostalloftheseareLINERsortype2Seyferts,whichmayhavelargereddeningtowardthebroad-lineregion.
OnlyoneSeyfert(NGC7479)showsanyevidenceforabroad-linecom-ponent.
Broademissionlinesareextremelyhardtodetectattheseuxlevels,butthesuggestionisthatthemiddlingluminositiestowardthequasar/Seyfertborderlinearepar-ticularlypronetomoderateobscuration.
5.
CONCLUSIONSRadio-quietredquasarscanbefoundinsubstantialnumbers.
Theycompriseatleast1%,andpotentially7%,ofthesoftX-raypopulationinauxlimitedsurvey.
Correct-ingtheX-rayuxestotheirintrinsicvaluesputsthemamongbrighterAGNs,wheretheyform3%ofthepopu-lation.
Allowingforblankeldsources,asmuchas20%ofROSATselectedquasarsmayberedatagivenunobscuredux.
Thesizeofthispopulationisconsistentwithpreviousupperlimits,withtheComastrietal.
(1995)modelfortheX-raybackground,andwiththesizeoftheradio-loud3CRand1Jyredquasarpopulations.
Redquasarsseemtobepreferentiallylowerluminosityobjectsonthequasar/Seyfertborderlinebutnotathigherorlowerluminosities.
Suchabiasagainstobscuredhigh-luminosityobjectswouldaectX-raybackgroundestimatesforthispopulationandwouldneedexplaininginaphysicalmodelofquasars.
Westressthatthequasarswendhavebroadopticallines.
TheyarenotNLXGs,whichbycontrasthavepre-dominantlynarrowopticalpermittedlinesandbluecontin-ua.
Theopticalslopes,Ha/Hbratios,andX-raycolorsareallconsistent,withreddeningbyassumingstandardAVD2MilkyWaydustproperties.
Sothesameobscuringmaterialprobablycoverseachoftheemittingregions.
Asignicantpopulationofmorehighlyobscured(AV\5)quasarscouldwellexistandbeconsistentwiththeresultshere,withearlierROSATlimits,andwouldbeaspredictedbytheComastrietal.
(1995)model.
HardX-raysurveyswillsoonsettlethequestionofthesizeofanysuchpopulation.
Usingaminorrenementofthetechniquepresentedhere,redquasarscanbefoundwithhigh(20%)efficiencyintheROSATdata.
WethankL.
AngeliniforhelpingustouseWGACATandM.
IrwinforuseoftheAPMonlinecatalog.
WealsoNo.
1,1999RADIO-QUIETREDQUASARS17thankF.
FioreandF.
NicastroforprovidingtheirprogramtocalculateX-rayspectralindicesandF.
FioreonceagainforsupplyingtheX-rayslopesoftheradio-quietsampleinFigure3.
ThesupportbytheFLWO,MMT,andCTIOstasinsettingupandoperatingvariousinstrumentswereinvaluabletothisstudy.
TheHEASARC/GSFCPIMMSprogramwasusedtocalculatePSPCcountrates.
ThisworkwassupportedbyNASAgrantsNAG5-3066(ADP),NAG5-6078(LTSA),andNASAcontractNAS8-39073(ASC).
REFERENCESAlmaini,O.
,Boyle,B.
J.
,Griffiths,R.
E.
,Shanks,T.
,Stewart,G.
C.
,&Georgantopoulos,I.
1995,MNRAS,277,L31Avni,Y.
,&Tananbaum,H.
1986,ApJ,305,83Bade,N.
,Fink,H.
H.
,Engels,D.
,Voges,W.
,Hagen,H.
-J.
,Wisotzki,L.
,&Reimers,D.
1995,A&AS,110,469Benn,C.
R.
,Vigotti,M.
,Carballo,R.
,Gonzalez-Serrano,J.
I.
,&Sanchez,S.
F.
1998,MNRAS,295,451Bless,R.
C.
,&Savage,B.
D.
1972,ApJ,171,293Bohlin,R.
C.
,Savage,B.
D.
,&Drake,J.
F.
1978,ApJ,224,132Boyle,B.
J.
,&diMatteo,T.
1995,MNRAS,277,L63Boyle,B.
J.
,McMahon,R.
G.
,Wilkes,B.
J.
,&Elvis,M.
1995a,MNRAS,285,511.
1995b,MNRAS,276,315Boyle,B.
J.
,Wilkes,B.
J.
,&Elvis,M.
1997,MNRAS,285,511Bregman,J.
N.
,Glassgold,A.
E.
,Huggins,P.
J.
,&Kinney,A.
L.
1985,ApJ,291,505Carilli,C.
L.
,Menten,K.
M.
,Reid,M.
J.
,Rupen,M.
P.
,&Yun,M.
S.
1998,ApJ,494,175Comastri,A.
,Setti,G.
,Zamorani,G.
,&Hasinger,G.
1995,A&A,296,1Condon,J.
J.
,Cotton,W.
D.
,Greisen,E.
W.
,Yin,Q.
F.
,Perley,R.
A.
,Taylor,G.
B.
,&Broderick,J.
J.
1998,AJ,115,1693DellaCeca,R.
,Maccacaro,T.
,Gioia,I.
M.
,Wolter,A.
,&Stocke,J.
T.
1992,ApJ,389,491Dressler,A.
,&Shectman,S.
A.
1987,AJ,94,899Economou,F.
,Lawrence,A.
,Ward,M.
J.
,&Blanco,P.
R.
1995,MNRAS,272,L5Elvis,M.
,Fiore,F.
,Mathur,S.
,&Wilkes,B.
J.
1994,ApJ,425,103Elvis,M.
,Kim,D.
-W.
,&Nicastro,F.
1999,inpreparationEngels,D.
,Hagen,H.
-J.
,Cordin,L.
,Koehler,S.
,Wisotzki,L.
,&Reimers,D.
1998,A&AS,128,507Fiore,F.
,Elvis,M.
,Giommi,P.
,&Padovani,P.
1998,ApJ,492,79Fiore,F.
,LaFranca,F.
,Giommi,P.
,Elvis,M.
,Comastri,A.
,Matt,G.
,&Molendi,S.
1999,inpreparationGregg,M.
D.
,Becker,R.
H.
,White,R.
L.
,Helfand,D.
J.
,McMahon,R.
G.
,&Hook,I.
M.
1996,AJ,112,407Gunn,K.
F.
,&Shanks,T.
1998,Astron.
Nachr.
,319,66Halpern,J.
P.
,Eracleous,M.
,&Forster,K.
1998,ApJ,501,103Hasinger,G.
1995,inMPERep.
263,fromtheUniverse,Rontgenstrahlunged.
H.
U.
Zimmermann,J.
&H.
Yorke(Garching:MPE),291Trumper,Hasinger,G.
,Burg,R.
,Giacconi,R.
,Schmidt,M.
,J.
,&Zamo-Trumper,rani,G.
1998,A&A,329,482Hewett,P.
C.
,Foltz,C.
B.
,&Chaee,F.
H.
1995,AJ,109,1498Ho,L.
C.
,Filippenko,A.
,&Sargent,W.
L.
W.
1997,ApJS,112,315Kellerman,K.
I.
,Sramek,R.
,Schmidt,M.
,Shaer,D.
B.
,&Green,R.
1989,AJ,98,1195Kollgaard,R.
I.
,Feigelson,E.
D.
,Laurent-Muehlson,S.
A.
,Spinrad,H.
,Dey,A.
,&Brinkmann,W.
1995,ApJ,449,61Komossa,S.
,&Bade,N.
1998,A&A,331,L49Kruper,J.
S.
,&Canizares,C.
R.
1989,ApJ,343,66Laor,A.
,Fiore,F.
,Elvis,M.
,Wilkes,B.
J.
,&McDowell,J.
C.
1994,ApJ,435,611Lawrence,A.
,&Elvis,M.
1982,ApJ,256,410Lipovetzky,V.
A.
,Markarian,B.
E.
,&Stepanian,J.
A.
1987,inObser-vationalEvidenceofActivityinGalaxies,ed.
E.
Ye.
Khachikian,K.
J.
Fricke,&J.
Melnick(Dordrecht:Reidel),17Maccacaro,T.
,Gioia,I.
M.
,Wolter,A.
,Zamorani,G.
,&Stocke,J.
T.
1988,ApJ,326,680Mathur,S.
1994,ApJ,431,L75McHardy,I.
M.
,etal.
1998,MNRAS,295,641McMahon,R.
G.
,&Irwin,M.
J.
1992,inDigitizedOpticalSkySurveys,ed.
H.
T.
MacGillivray&E.
B.
Thomson(Dordrecht:Kluwer),417Neugebauer,G.
,Green,R.
F.
,Matthews,K.
,Schmidt,M.
,Soifer,B.
T.
,&Bennet,J.
1987,ApJS,63,615Pfeermann,E.
,etal.
1987,Proc.
SPIE,733,519Puchnarewicz,E.
M.
,etal.
1996,MNRAS,281,1243.
1997,MNRAS,291,177Puchnarewicz,E.
M.
,&Mason,K.
O.
1988,MNRAS,293,243Rawlings,S.
,Lacy,M.
,Sivia,D.
S.
,&Eales,S.
A.
1995,MNRAS,274,428Sandage,A.
R.
1965,ApJ,141,1560Sanders,D.
B.
,etal.
1988,ApJ,325,74Schachter,J.
S.
,Fiore,F.
,Elvis,M.
,Mathur,S.
,Wilson,A.
S.
,Morse,J.
A.
,Awaki,H.
,&Iwasawa,K.
1998,ApJL,503,L123Schmidt,M.
,etal.
1997,A&A,329,495Schmidt,M.
,&Green,R.
F.
1983,ApJ,269,352Seaton,M.
J.
1979,MNRAS,187,785Shanks,T.
,Almaini,O.
,Boyle,B.
J.
,Done,C.
,Georgantopoulos,I.
,Grif-ths,R.
E.
,Rawling,S.
J.
,&Stewart,G.
C.
1995,Spectrum:NewsletteroftheRoyalObs.
,7,7Smith,H.
E.
,&Spinrad,H.
1980,ApJ,236,419Stickel,M.
,Rieke,G.
H.
,H.
,&Rieke,M.
J.
1996,ApJ,468,556Kuhr,Stocke,J.
T.
,Liebert,J.
,Maccacaro,T.
,Griffiths,R.
E.
,&Steiner,J.
E.
1982,ApJ,252,69Stocke,J.
T.
,Morris,S.
L.
,Gioia,I.
M.
,Maccacaro,T.
,Schild,R.
,Wolter,A.
,Fleming,T.
A.
,&Henry,J.
P.
1991,ApJS,76,813Tananbaum,H.
,etal.
1979,ApJ,234,L9J.
1983,Adv.
SpaceRes.
,2:4,241Trumper,Ueda,Y.
,etal.
1998,Nature,391,866M.
-P.
,&P.
1984,ESOSpecialRep.
1Veron-Cetty,Veron,Voges,W.
,etal.
1996,IAUCirc.
,6420,2Webster,R.
L.
,Francis,P.
J.
,Peterson,B.
A.
,Drinkwater,M.
J.
,&Mascl,F.
J.
1995,Nature,375,469White,N.
,Giommi,P.
,&Angelini,L.
1995,WGACAT,http://heasarc.
gsfc.
nasa.
gov/W3Browse/all/wgacat.
htmlWilkes,B.
J.
,&Elvis,M.
1987,ApJ,323,243Zitelli,V.
,Mignoli,M.
,Zamorani,G.
,Marano,B.
,&Boyle,B.
J.
1992,MNRAS,256,349
- diagramps半透明相关文档
- pinps半透明
- 第1包电热恒温培养箱等国产设备
- 通用实验室设备与耗材目录
- 三星ps半透明
- outputps半透明
- 目录目录I概述11项目由来
Sharktech鲨鱼服务器商提供洛杉矶独立服务器促销 不限流量月99美元
Sharktech（鲨鱼服务器商）我们还是比较懂的，有提供独立服务器和高防服务器，而且性价比都还算是不错，而且我们看到有一些主机商的服务器也是走这个商家渠道分销的。这不看到鲨鱼服务器商家洛杉矶独立服务器纷纷促销，不限制流量的独立服务器起步99美元，这个还未曾有过。第一、鲨鱼机房服务器方案洛杉矶机房，默认1Gbps带宽，不限流量，自带5个IPv4，免费60Gbps / 48Mpps DDoS防御。C...
美国服务器20G防御 50G防御 688元CN2回国
全球领先的IDC服务商华纳云“美国服务器”正式发售啦~~~~此次上线的美国服务器包含美国云服务器、美国服务器、美国高防服务器以及美国高防云服务器。针对此次美国服务器新品上线，华纳云也推出了史无前例的超低活动力度。美国云服务器低至3折，1核1G5M低至24元/月，20G DDos防御的美国服务器低至688元/月，年付再送2个月，两年送4个月，三年送6个月，且永久续费同价，更多款高性价比配置供您选择。...
lcloud零云：沪港IPLC,70元/月/200Mbps端口/共享IPv4/KVM;成都/德阳/雅安独立服务器低至400元/月起
lcloud怎么样?lcloud零云，UOVZ新开的子站，现在沪港iplc KVM VPS有端午节优惠，年付双倍流量，200Mbps带宽，性价比高。100Mbps带宽，500GB月流量，10个，512MB内存，优惠后月付70元，年付700元。另有国内独立服务器租用，泉州、佛山、成都、德阳、雅安独立服务器低至400元/月起！点击进入：lcloud官方网站地址lcloud零云优惠码：优惠码：bMVbR...
ps半透明为你推荐
-
万维读者网读者投稿邮箱安装程序配置服务器失败安装用友u8的数据库最后说：“安装程序配置服务器失败。参考服务器错误日志和 C:WINDOWSsqlstp.log 了解更多信息。”拂晓雅阁我对电脑操作不熟悉，想买一本自学的电脑书籍，是电脑入门那一类的，最好还有办公软件应用那一类的arm开发板单片机开发板与ARM开发板有什么不同？中小企业信息化小企业需要信息化吗?需要的话要怎么实现信息化呢?二层交换机请教：二层交换机是干什么用的啊？三星s8什么时候上市三星s8什么时候上市 三星s8上市时间cisco防火墙思科防火墙asa5505路由配置是什么？首页无法修改默认主页无法修改怎么办？液晶显示器电源维修液晶显示器 电源板损坏 如何检修？ 好的加分！