Protectingtheirreplaceable|f-secure.
comStudyoneffectivenessofpopulardefensemeasuresJarnoNiemel.
VirusBulletin2013Twitter:@jarnomnStatisticallyeffectiveprotectionagainstAPTattacksWhyThisResearchWasMadeApplyinghardeningincorporateenvironmentisexpensiveThusIwantedtogivedecisionmakingsupporttoolsforcorporatesecurityInthisresearchweevaluatedpopularhardeningapproachesagainstasetofexploitsAttacksanddefensesevolveconstantlysowefocusedmoreondifferentstylesofapproachratherthanexactsettingsortoolsFortestsweobviouslyusedpubliclyavailabletoolsExploitsUsedInTestsTheusedexploitsetconsistedof~930confirmedexploitdocumentsamplesSamplesinthewild2010-2013CVEidentificationwasdonebyscanresultsMostexploitshaveshortlifespaninactiveuseAPTnatureverifiedbycontextidentificationPressevents,conferenceproceedingsDiplomatic/politicalreports,analysisHumanrights/activismreports,articlesMilitaryreports,events,analysisBusinessrelatedmailF-SecureOctober10,20133050100150200250300051015202530354045500102030405060708090100110120130140150051015202530354045501.
1.
101.
3.
101.
5.
101.
7.
101.
9.
101.
11.
101.
1.
111.
3.
111.
5.
111.
7.
111.
9.
111.
11.
111.
1.
121.
3.
121.
5.
121.
7.
121.
9.
121.
11.
121.
1.
131.
3.
13AnalysisMethodWetestedsampleswithWindowsXPSP3AdobeAcrobat8.
0.
0AdobeFlashplayer6.
0Office2003WeintentionallyusedobsoletesoftwareversionstoenableasmanyexploitsaspossibleWeusedautomaticforensicstocheckforexploitsuccessindicatorsNetworkcommunicationProcesscreationFilecreationEachexploitwasverifiedtoworkconsistentlyinbasesystemF-SecureOctober10,20134ProtectionMethodsApplicationmemoryhandlingmitigationsApplicationSandboxingHardeningapplicationsettingsHardeningoperatingsystemF-SecureOctober10,20135ApplicationSanboxingChrome,Acrobat,etcpopularappshavebuiltinsandboxingTheproblemwiththemisthatattackerhastocircumventtheminordertoexploitThuswewantedtotestexploitsagainstunexpectedsandboxingWeusedSandboxie3.
76ProwithcustomconfigurationOwnsandboxforeachdocumenttypeFileexecutiondeniedforanyfilescreatedbysandboxedapplicationNofileaccessoutsidethesandboxforAcrobatAccessto%documents%%recent%andnetworkdrivesforOfficeapplicationsF-SecureOctober10,20136ChangestoOfficeInstalledOfficefilevalidationInstalledMOICEisolationSetMacrosecurityleveltohighDisabledtrustonadd-onsandtemplatesChangestoAcrobatDisabledopeningnon-PDFattachmentsDisabledtrustinmultimediacomponentsDisabledmultimediaplayerDisabledJavascriptF-SecureOctober10,20137HardenedSecuritySettingsForClientAppsAdvisoriesoftenhavemitigationinstructionswhattodobeforepatchisavailableWewantedtofindouthoweffectivethosemeasuresareingeneralWhoonearthneedsaflashcontentinPDFfileinthefirstplaceAfterVBpapersubmissionNSAcameoutwiththeirAcrobatguidelineshttp://www.
nsa.
gov/ia/_files/app/Recommendations_for_Configuring_Adobe_Acrobat_Reader_XI_in_a_Windows_Environment.
pdfHardenedSystemAccessPoliciesInT22011weannouncedresearchpointingtothathardeningbreaksmalwareHoweverAPTsarequiteadifferentbeastcomparedtoplainoldmalwareWetestedthesamplesagainstfollowinghardenedsystemsettingsBlockedfilewritingtorootsofC:\,D:\,etc,%localsettings%,%appdata%BlockedfilewritingrecursivelytoC:\windows,%programfiles%PreventedfileexecutionfromC:\,%documents%,c:\RECYCLER,%temp%,%APPDATA%,%localsettings%F-Secure10.
lokakuuta20138ApplicationMemoryHandlingMitigationsMemoryhandlingmitigationspreventtypesofmemoryoperationsneededbyexploitsThusnormalappsaremostlyunhinderedwhileexploitsfailtoworkCurrentlyonlytoolprovidingsuchcapabilitiesisMicrosoftEMETAllocationmitigations(SEHOP,Heapspray,ASLR,Nullpage)Codeexecutionorloadingmitigations(DEP,ROP,Bottomuprnd,EAF)Hookingpreventions(Deephooks,Antidetours,Bannedfunctions)ForthisresearchweusedEmet4.
0bwhichwasthelatestavailableF-SecureOctober10,20139ApplicationSandboxingResultsUnfortunatelySandboxieinterferedwithourautomaticforensicsWewereabletogetresultsfor452sampleswith100%protectionOftheremainingsampleswetested60randomsampleswhichhad100%protectionSowecantsaywithfullcertainty,butthirdpartysandboxingseemstobeeffectiveBuiltinpayloadsweredroppedbutnotexecutedSampleswhichtriedtodownloadwereblockedF-SecureOctober10,201310CVEFailed:networkeventFailed:fileeventFailed:processeventSuccessCVE-2004-02101CVE-2006-24921CVE-2006-35903CVE-2007-565921CVE-2008-48411CVE-2009-09271CVE-2009-3129219CVE-2009-43249CVE-2010-01886221231CVE-2010-08068CVE-2010-12975CVE-2010-257217CVE-2010-288382CVE-2010-3333133946CVE-2010-365429CVE-2011-00971CVE-2011-010168CVE-2011-061121CVE-2011-12691CVE-2012-0158144916CVE-2012-07792GrandTotal894556737HardenedClientAppsresultsHardeningapplicationsgave80%totalprotectionagainstexploitsCVE-2010-0188failedasnotallsampleswereusingJavaScriptCVE-2010-0188failedaswedidnotthinkifisolatingRTFfilesCVE-2012-0158alsofailedduenotisolatingRTFfilesInOffice2013OFVandMOICEarebuiltinInAcrobattherecommendationsstillapplyF-SecureOctober10,201311HardenedSystemAccessPoliciesresultsHardenedsystemaccesspoliciesgaveverysmalltotalprotectionof~10%~7%werepartiallymitigatedNetworkwasblockedin40samplesProcesscreationblockedin28samplesSointotalsystemhardeningisineffectiveF-SecureOctober10,201312CVEFailed:networkeventFailed:fileeventFailed:processeventSuccessCVE-2004-02101CVE-2006-24921CVE-2006-35903CVE-2007-5659201CVE-2008-48411CVE-2009-09271CVE-2009-3129159528CVE-2009-4324324CVE-2010-01882942CVE-2010-080671CVE-2010-12975CVE-2010-2572287CVE-2010-2883327250CVE-2010-3333182141CVE-2010-365411126CVE-2011-00971CVE-2011-010145113CVE-2011-0611192CVE-2011-12691CVE-2012-015815217CVE-2012-07792GrandTotal34634115189MemoryHandlingMitigationsResultsEMETwasabletostopeverysingleexploit!
However4.
0bisnewerthansamples,soresultscanbeskewedThereareclaimsthatEMETcanbecircumventedButinourtestswecouldnotfindasamplethatactuallydoessoMemoryhandlingmitigationsarenoteffectiveagainstallexploittypesIfexploitisbasedonotherthancodeexecution,EMETwillnothelpButsuchexploitsareveryrareandwecouldnotfindinthewildsampleF-SecureOctober10,201313CVEfailedsuccesscve-2004-021001cve-2006-249201cve-2006-359003cve-2007-5659021cve-2008-484101cve-2009-092701cve-2009-31290219cve-2009-432409cve-2010-01880296cve-2010-080608cve-2010-129705cve-2010-2572017cve-2010-2883082cve-2010-3333098cve-2010-3654029cve-2011-009701cve-2011-0101068cve-2011-0611021cve-2011-126901cve-2012-0158043cve-2012-077902GrandTotal0927DefenceInDepth,HardenYourNetworkPreventlateralmovementwithinyournetworkIsolateeverythinginnetwork,noinboundtoclientsnooutboundfromserverBlockremoteexecutionandRDPfromotherthanadminnetworksegmentAllowusertologinonlytohisworkstationsIsolateemailtoapprovedbusinessuseonlyAllowemailonlyovercompanymailserverDon'tallowmailsendingwithoutuserauthenticationControlDNSresolution,donotallowunknowndomainstoresolveMostAPTC&CinfrarelyonbeingabletoresolvedomainnamesMakedatadifficulttostealUseDRMtomakestolendocumentsworthlessUserightsmanagementservertoprovidetransparentcryptofordocumentsValiduserscanreaddocuments,stolendocsareworthlessoutsidecompanyWatermarkcompanybrowsersandcheckwatermarkinserverHaveownbrowserthatcanaccessonlyintra.
CheckagainstthatintheserverWatermarkcanbefaked,buthardtoget100%rightonthefirstgo->alarmUsetokenbasedemailcertificatesandcryptoforallinternalmailDirectstealingofmailfilesbecomesuselessAttackerneedstodecryptmessagesbeforestealing,whichslowsdownattackandgivesyoutimetoreactConclusionsWiththeexceptionofOShardeningallothermethodswereveryeffectiveVeryfewattackersaimatanythingbutdefaultconfigurationWhichmethodstousedependsonwhatyourcorporateITfindseasiesttodeployAsruleofthumballapplicationsthatdealwithexternaldatashouldbehardenedPersonallyIwouldrecommendacombinationofhardenedapplicationsettingsandEMETSandboxingisalsoveryeffectivebutcanrequireefforttomakeittransparenttousersMostimportantthingtodoisnottorelyonasinglesecuritylayerOurcorporatesecurityproductisverygoodatcatchingexploitsbutnosinglelayerisgoingtobeenoughF-SecureOctober10,201316
关于半月湾HMBCloud商家之前也有几篇那文章介绍过这个商家的产品,对于他们家的其他产品我都没有多加留意,而是对他们家的DC5机房很多人还是比较喜欢的,这个比我们有些比较熟悉的某商家DC6 DC9机房限时,而且半月湾HMBCloud商家是相对便宜的。关于半月湾DC5机房的方案选择和介绍:1、半月湾三网洛杉矶DC5 CN2 GIA同款DC6 DC9 1G内存 1TB流量 月$4.992、亲测选择半...
古德云(goodkvm)怎么样?古德云是一家成立于2020年的商家,原名(锤子云),古德云主要出售VPS服务器、独立服务器。古德云主打产品是香港cn2弹性云及美西cn2云服务器,采用的是kvm虚拟化构架,硬盘Raid10。目前,古德云香港沙田cn2机房及美国五星级机房云服务器,2核2G,40G系统盘+50G数据盘,仅35元/月起,性价比较高,可以入手!点击进入:古德云goodkvm官方网站地址古德...
提速啦(www.tisula.com)是赣州王成璟网络科技有限公司旗下云服务器品牌,目前拥有在籍员工40人左右,社保在籍员工30人+,是正规的国内拥有IDC ICP ISP CDN 云牌照资质商家,2018-2021年连续4年获得CTG机房顶级金牌代理商荣誉 2021年赣州市于都县创业大赛三等奖,2020年于都电子商务示范企业,2021年于都县电子商务融合推广大使。资源优势介绍:Ceranetwo...
localsettings为你推荐
太康县公安局网警取证塔采购项目thinksns什么是thinkphpdestoondestoon这个变量是啥意思?conn.asp数据库连接出错,请打开conn.asp文件检查连接字串。ldapserverLDAP3是什么三友网网测是什么意思?银花珠树晓来看谜语白色花无人栽一夜北风遍地开。旡根无叶又无枝不知是谁送花来。谜底是什么徐州商标介绍徐州的一种产品tumblr上不去吃鸡更新完打不开,成这样了,怎么办在线等,挺急的400电话查询能查出400电话是什么地区的吗
万网域名注册 中国域名网 lamp google镜像 美国主机评测 英语简历模板word 数字域名 vip购优汇 空间论坛 秒杀预告 200g硬盘 hkg 国外免费asp空间 台湾谷歌 Updog 吉林铁通 如何建立邮箱 google台湾 空间登陆首页 海外空间 更多