Changeoption82
option82 时间:2021-04-04 阅读:()
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTacklingSpoofingAttacksinBroadbandAccessNetworksBharatJoshi(bharat_joshi@infosys.
com)PavanKurapati(pavan_kurapati@infosys.
com)RamakrishnaRaoDTV(ramakrishnadtv@infosys.
com)2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVAgendaSpoofing–What,WhyandHowTypesofuserconnectionsinBroadbandAccessConcentratorsTypesofspoofingHowtocollectdatatodoAnti-spoofinginAccessNetworkAnti-spoofingHowtorecoveranti-spoofingdataafterBACcrash/reboot2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVWhatisSpoofiingSpoofingisaprocesswherebyoneentitymasqueradesasanotherentityWhyisspoofingdoneSpoofingAbyBisdoneforvariouspurposesBseekstheprivilegesofABintendstohideitstracksAsanattackonAHowisspoofingdoneWeshallseeincomingslides2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTheultimategoalofspoofingUnauthorizedServiceGetserviceonsomeoneelse'sexpenseLossofServiceonTargetMakesurethatthetargetdoesnotgetanyserviceDifficulttotracetheattackerMakesurethatpeoplecannotfindwhoattackedthem.
UnnecessarypacketscloggingthenetworkMakesurethatnobodygetsagoodservice.
SecondaryvictimPrimarytargetrespondstospoofpacketandoverwhelmthesourcewhichbecomessecondaryvictim.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTypesofuserconnectionsforanIPbasedDSLAMBridgedIPRoutingRFC2684basedbridgedencapsulationbetweenEndUserandDSLAMDSLAMinroutingmodewithroutedVLANsconfiguredonuplinki/fDynamicIPallocationusingDHCPPPPoE/APPPterminationinDSLAMIPallocationfromlocalpoolDSLAMinroutingmodewithroutedVLANsconfiguredonuplinki/fIPoARFC2684basedroutedencapsulationbetweenEndUserandDSLAMDSLAMinroutingmodewithroutedVLANsconfiguredonuplinki/fDynamicIPallocationusingDHCPL3DSLAMxDSLHomeHubxDSLHomeHubMPLSCloudPEPRouterPRouterBRASL3n/wDataCenterL3DSLAMInternetservices2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV6DSLAML3AxDSLHomeHubL3n/wDHCP2UnicastDISCOVER+Option82populatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID1BroadcastDHCPDISCOVERUnicastDHCPOFFERwithoption82echoed3SendDHCPOFFERtothehostafterremovingoption8246UnicastREQUEST+Option82populatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID5BroadcastDHCPREQUESTUnicastDHCPACKtotheclientwithoption827SendDHCPACKtothehostafterremovingoption828AddressallocationmechanismsforIPDSLAM–DHCP2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTypesofuserconnectionsforaLayer2DSLAM1:1VLANsMapeveryuserconnectiontooneunique802.
1qbasedVLANNoneedofanyMAClearningofindividualhostsDownstreamtrafficmappingdonebasedonVLANsQinQorStackedVLANsAnouterServiceVLANidentifyingaspecificserviceisaddedDownstreammappingdonebasedoncombinationofCVLANandSVLANN:1TransparentBridgedVLANsMultipleusersmappedtoacommonVLANDownstreammappingdonebasedonVLANandDstMACcombinationMAClearningisrequiredforoperationL2DSLAMxDSLHomeHubxDSLHomeHubMPLSCloudPEPRouterPRouterBRASAccessAggregationDataCenterL2DSLAMInternetservices2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV8DSLAML2RAxDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroDHCP2BroadcastDISCOVER+Option82populatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID1BroadcastDHCPDISCOVER3UnicastDISCOVERwith'giaddr'populatedUnicastDHCPOFFERwithoption82echoed45BroadcastDHCPOFFERwithoption82andwithout'giaddr'SendDHCPOFFERtothehostafterremovingoption8268BroadcastREQUEST+Option82populatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID7BroadcastDHCPREQUEST9UnicastREQUESTwith'giaddr'populatedUnicastDHCPACKtotheclientwithoption8210SendDHCPACKtothehostafterremovingoption8211AddressallocationmechanismsforL2DSLAM–DHCP2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV9DSLAML2RAxDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroDHCPRADIUSPortEnabled1EAPOLStart2IdentityRequest3IdentityResponse4IdentityDetails5EAPMD5Challenge6MD5ChallengeResponse7AuthSuccess8AuthSuccess9DHCPAuthentication&AddressallocationmechanismsforL2DSLAM–DHCP+802.
1x2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV10DSLAMxDSLHomeHubBRASMetroRADIUS2PADI+IntermediateAgentpopulatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID1PADIPADO+IntermediateAgentechoed35PADR6PADR+IntermediateAgentpopulatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-IDPADS+IntermediateAgentechoed79PPPNegotiationsAuthentication&AddressallocationmechanismsforL2DSLAM-PPPoEPADOafterremovingagentinformationoption4PADSafterremovingagentinformationoption82009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTypeofSpoofingMACSpoofingIPSpoofingARPSpoofingControlprotocolinternalheaderspoofingPPPoEsession-idspoofingDHCPchaddr,ciaddr,relay-agent-informationoptionspoofing2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV12DSLAMAttackerChangeSrcMACaddressandfloodtrafficSimulates1000sofMACaddressatfasterratexDSLMACTablemaximumlimitreachedLegitimatetrafficdroppedduetoMACtableexhaustionChangingSourceMACaddresstoanillegitimateaddressAttackerxDSLMACI/FB2A2FloodtrafficwithbothMACAandMACBMACBLegitimatetrafficblockedMACAMACspoofing2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVIPspoofingChangingSourceIPaddresstoanillegitimateaddressAttackerxDSLIPBDoSattackonIPAIPASendtrafficwithIPAandMACBRepliesfloodedtoIPA12PingofDeathServiceProvider'sNetwork2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVARPspoofingRespond/sendARPResponsewithillegitimateIPaddressABCDARP:WhoisIPB1ARPReply:IamIPB:MACA2IPMACAABATrafficflowingtohostAARPTableABCDGratuitousARP:IamIPB:MACA1IPMACAABATrafficflowingtohostAARPTableServiceProvider'sNetworkServiceProvider'sNetwork2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDHCPHeaderDHCPHeaderspoofingOp(1)Htype(1)Hlen(1)Hops(1)Xid(4)Secs(2)Flags(2)Ciaddr(4)Yiaddr(4)Siaddr(4)Giaddr(4)Chaddr(16)Sname(64)File(128)Options(Variable)ClientIdenrtifierRelayAgentOptionDSLAMAttackerxDSLL2RAL3RADHCPServerABDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BChaddr:A2Spoof'chaddr'fieldDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BClientId:A3Spoof'ClientIdentifier'fieldDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BOption82RemoteId:A4SpoofOption82fieldChangingInternalfieldswithinDHCPheaderDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BCiaddr:A1Spoof'ciaddr'field2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVSimilarlyPPPoESession-IDfieldidentifiesauniquesession.
SpoofingthiscanalsocauseservicedisruptionPPPoEHeaderPPPoEHeaderspoofingVERTYPECODESESSION_IDLENGTHPAYLOADChangingSESSION_IDfieldinPPPoEHeaderAttackerxDSLIPBIPAPPPoEIABRAS1PADT:SESSION_ID:ASessionDisconnectedServiceProvider'sNetwork2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVAnti-spoofingWhatisanti-spoofingMechanismtoidentifyspoofingandstoppingit.
Howanti-spoofingisdoneBydroppingthespoofedpacketsHowtoidentifythespoofedpacketsByverifyingIPAddressofthereceivedpacket.
ByverifyingMACaddressofthereceivedpacket.
ByverifyingthecombinationofIPandMACaddressforagiveninterfaceByverifyingtheIPaddress,MACaddressandothersessionbasedidentificationintheprotocolheader.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDatarequiredforAnti-spoofingForeachuserconnectionListofValidIPaddressesassignedListofValidMACaddressesandifpossiblethecombinationofMACandIPaddresses,TimeforwhicheachIPaddressisvalid.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVWhyanti-spoofinginBroadbandAccessConcentrator(BAC)BACisattherightplace:Itknowsalltherequiredinformationtodoanti-spoofing.
Anti-spoofingbecomesdifficultandlesseffectiveifitisnotdoneasnearthesourceaspossible.
Itisnotonlyimportanttodropspoofedpackets,itisimportanttodropthemasearlyaspossible.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDatacollectionforAntispoofinginBAC-PPPoE1xDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroRADIUS2PADIPADO34PADRPADSBACObtainSession-IDfromPADSIPMACSession-IDI/FAA1011BB1022PPPLCPPPPIPCPBACObtainIPinformationfromIPCP567PADTBACDeletethespoofingentry2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDatacollectionforAntispoofinginBAC-DHCPxDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroDHCPIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB120212DHCPDISCOVERDHCPOFFER34DHCPREQUESTDHCPACKBACObtainIP/MAC/LeasetimefromDHCPACKMessage6DHCPRELEASEBACRemovetheentryfromtableLeaseEXPIREBACRemovetheentryfromtable2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDatacollectionforAntispoofinginBAC–802.
1x+DHCP1xDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroDHCP2InitialEAPNegotiationsEAPAuthSuccess34DHCPMessageexchangeDHCPACKBACObtaintheMACaddressfromEAPAuthSuccessmessageIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202RADIUSBACObtainIP&LeasetimefromDHCPACKMessage2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVMACAntispoofingDSLAMAttackerAttackerxDSLMACI/FB2A1FloodtrafficwithbothMACAandMACBMACBNoImpactonAMACAMACBIPMACLeaseI/FBB1202Floodtrafficwith1000'sofSrcMACsinadditiontoMACBCompareAntispooftableanddiscardnonmatchingentriesNoMACtableExhaustion!
MACI/FB2MACTableAntiSpoofTableIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202CompareAntispooftableanddiscardnonmatchingentriesNospoofingofNeighbor'sMAC!
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVIPAntispoofingAttackerxDSLIPBNoImpactonAIPASendtrafficwithIPAandMACB1IPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202CompareIPagainstthei/finAntispooftableMetro2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVARPAntispoofingABCDARP:WhoisIPB1ARPReply:IamIPB:MACA2IPMACAABBARPTableABCDGratuitousARP:IamIPB:MACA1IPMACAABBARPTableIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202CompareIP/MACagainstthei/finAntispooftableIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202ServiceProviderN/wServiceProviderN/w2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDHCPHeaderAntispoofingDSLAMAttackerxDSLL2RAL3RADHCPServerABDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BChaddr:A1AntiSpooffilterdiscardDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BOption82RemoteId:A3Option82fromuntrustedentity.
DiscardIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202InspectDHCPHeader&comparechaddr&ClientIDwithantispooftableAcceptDHCPwithoption82onlyifitiscomingfromtrustedentityDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BCiaddr:A2AntiSpooffilterdiscard2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVPPPoEHeaderAntispoofingAttackerxDSLIPBIPAPPPoEIABRAS1PADT:SESSION_ID:101IPMACSession-IDI/FAA1011BB1022SessionIDdoesnotmatchNoImpactonAMetro2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLosingdatacollectedforanti-spoofingDatausedinAntispoofingcanbelostduetovariousreasonsPlannedrebootSoftwarecrashPowerfailureReplacementofsystemSoftwareupgrade2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVHowtorecoverlostdataStaticconfigurationRequiredDataisavailableintheconfiguration.
PPPoEForPPPoE,thekeep-alivetimersareconfiguredandthesessionisre-initiatediftherearenorepliestothekeep-alivemessagesDHCPDHCPdoesnothavekeepalivemechanisminplace.
DHCPhasa'leasetime'whichisusuallyinorderof'days'.
Howtorecoverfromthissituation2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRecoveringLeaseinformationforDHCPStableStorage:NotveryusefulasnotmanyBACssupportstablestorage.
LimitederasecyclesisalsoabottleneckinthisapproachBroadcastARPs:NeedtowaitfordownstreamtraffictoarriveandinitiateARPrequests.
Willincreasethedelay.
Cannotgetthecompleteinformationinonerequest.
PronetospoofingattacksifamalicioususerrepliestotheARPrequest.
RedundantcontrollersBACcanhaveredundantcontrollersandupononecontrollercrash,theothercontrollercantakeoverwithpre-synchedleasedata.
Notsuitableforpowerfailurescenariosorforupgrades.
Havingredundantcontrollersalsoaddtohardwarecosts2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRecoveringLeaseinformationforDHCPQuerythroughSNMP/LDAPCurrentlynostandardMIBsareavailableforDHCPleaseinformation.
BACstypicallydonotsupportSNMPclientinterfacesQueryleaseinformationfromDHCPserverSolvesmostoftheproblemsstatedabove2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeasequeryforDHCP(RFC4388)RFC4388introducedanewDHCPrequestLeasequerywhichaBACcanusetoqueryDHCPservertoobtainleaseinformation.
ThreetypesofqueriesaresupportedQuerybyIPaddressOnlyIPaddressispopulatedinthequerymessage.
QuerybyMACaddressOnlyMACaddressispopulatedinthequerymessage.
Ifmorethanoneleaseisavailable,thencorrespondingIPaddressesarereturnedinassociated-ipoption.
BACthengetsadditionaldatabygeneratingquerybyIPaddress.
QuerybyClientidentifierOnlyclientidentifieroptionispopulatedinthequerymessage.
Ifmorethanoneleaseisavailable,thencorrespondingIPaddressesarereturnedinassociated-ipoption.
BACthengetstheadditionaldatabyqueryingbyIPaddress.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeasequeryforDHCP(RFC4388)Threetypesofreplymessagetypesareintroduced:DHCPLEASEACTIVEWhenDHCPserverknowsaboutthequeryidentifier.
DHCPLEASEUNKNOWN:WhenDHCPserverdoesnotknowaboutthequeryidentifier.
AnAccessConcentratorcachethisinformationsothatthiscanbeusedtoavoidgeneratingLeaseQueryforthequeryidentifier.
ThisisknownasNegativeCaching.
DHCPLEASEUNASSIGNED:WhenDHCPserverdoesmanagethequeryidentifierbutnoleaseisyetassigned.
NegativeCachingisdoneforthisresponseaswell.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–DataDriven34DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I1MACIPLeaseI/fM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1AntiSpoofTable123I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–DataDriven35DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerCRASHMACIPLeaseI/fAntiSpoofTable123I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–DataDriven36DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer1DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
22LeaseQuerybyIPAddress3LeaseActiveM1,T1,I1MACIPLeaseI/fM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1AntiSpoofTable4DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
25123I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–NegativeCaching37xDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerCRASH123I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–NegativeCaching381DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
102LeaseQuerybyIPAddressNegativeCachingxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer123MACIPThresholdI/fM1192.
168.
1.
10T1I13LeaseUNKNOWN182.
168.
1.
10,M14I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–NegativeCaching392DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
103LeaseQuerybyIPAddressNegativeCachingxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer123MACIPThresholdI/fM1192.
168.
1.
10T1I14LeaseUNKNOWN182.
168.
1.
10,M1Thresholdexpired1I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVIssueswithRFC4388basedleasequeryExistingLeasequerymechanismisdatadriven:LeasequeryisinitiatedonlywhenAccessConcentratorsreceivesdataExistingmethodsuggeststheuseofnegativecaching.
NegativeCachingconsumeslotofresourcesunderspoofattacks.
Resultsinincreasedoutagetimefortheclients.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVIssueswithRFC4388basedleasequery(contd.
.
)Gettingconsolidatedleaseinformationperconnectionisnotpossible:Existingmechanismdoesn'thaveanymethodstogetconsolidatedleaseinformationforalltheclientsbelongingtoaconnection/circuitMultipleclientscanresideforagivenconnection/circuit.
IfAccessconcentratorhasleaseinformationofalltheclientsforagivenconnection/circuit,anti-spoofingcanbedoneindataplane(fastpath)2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVQuerybyremote-idRemote-IDsuboptionidentifyiesaconnection/circuituniquely.
ThisisgloballyuniqueidentifierRemote-IDcanbetrustedastheyarecreatedbyRelayAgent.
AccessConcentratorneednotwaitforthetraffictoarriveandcangenerateLeaseQueryassoonasitcomesupafterareboot.
DHCPServercanprovideconsolidatedLeaseInformationforaspecificconnection/circuit.
Oncealltheleaseinformationforagivenconnection/circuitisobtained,anti-spoofingcanbedoneindataplane(fastpath).
NoneedforNegativeCaching.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeaseQuerybyRemoteId43xDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer123M1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I1M3192.
168.
1.
10T3I1MACIPLeaseI/fAntiSpoofTableI12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeaseQuerybyRemoteId44xDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerCRASH123MACIPLeaseI/fAntiSpoofTableI12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeaseQuerybyRemoteId451LeaseQuerybyRemoteIdforI12LeaseActiveofallthreeleases*3DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
8xDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer123M1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I1M3192.
168.
1.
10T3I1MACIPLeaseI/fAntiSpoofTable4DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
8BACdoesnotneedtowaitforthetraffictoinitiateLQLeasequerybyremote-idresultsinobtainingcompleteinformationonagiveninterface.
NoneedofinitiatingsubsequentqueriesI1*Leaseactiveforoneleaseisreturnedfollowedbyassociated-IPoption.
ThisresultsinsubsequentquerybyIPforremainingleases2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:ServeridentifiesaLeasequerybyremote-idwhentheleasequerymessagehas:Chaddr,siaddr,Ciaddr,htype,hlenandchaddriszeroandClientidentifieroptionisnotpresentandOption82withonlyRemote-Idsub-optionispresent.
SendsaLEASEACTIVEpopulatingtheciaddrwiththeIPaddressthatwasmostrecentlyaccessedbytheclient.
AllotherIPaddressesarereturnedinAssociated-IPoption.
RelayagentthensendsaLeasequerywith"QuerybyIPAddress"foralltheadditionalIPaddressesreturnedinAssociated-ipoption.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:ServermayreturnaLEASEUNASSIGNEDifitknowsitmanagestheleasefortheconnectionidentifiedbyRemote-Idsub-optionbutnoleaseisassignedyet.
ServermayreturnLEASEUNKNOWNifitdoesnotknowthecorrespondingRemote-idsub-option.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVWhyBulkLeasequeryTraditionalleasequery(Both4388)andleasequerybyremote-idworksontheprincipleofretrievingoneleaseatatimeWhilequerybyremote-idsolvesalltheproblemsassociatedwithRFC4388basedleasequerymechanism,itstillinvolvesgeneratinghugenumberofleasequeriestogetallthepossibledataBulkleasequeryworksontheprincipleofestablishingTCPconnectionbetweenRAandServerandretrievinginformationinbulk2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVBulkLeaseQuery49DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerMACIPAddressLeaseTimeInterfaceM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I2M3192.
168.
1.
3T2I3I1I2I32009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVBulkLeaseQuery50DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerCRASHI1I2I3MACIPLeaseI/f2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVBulkLeaseQuery51DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerMACIPAddressLeaseTimeInterfaceM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I2M3192.
168.
1.
3T2I33DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
81BulkLeaseQueryinaTCPSession2LeaseActiveofallleases4DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
8LeaseinformationofallinterfacesobtainedininonequeryI1I2I32009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer1TCPSession2BulkLeaseQuerywithXID23LEASEQUERYACTIVEforXID24LEASEQUERYACTIVEforXID25LEASEQUERYACTIVEforXID26LEASEQUERYDONEforXID27TCPsessionclose2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:AQuerier(TypicallyaRelayAgent)establishesaTCPconnectionwiththeserveronport67.
Twonewquerytypesareadded"QuerybyRelay-ID"whererelay-idisauniqueRelayagentIdentifier.
AllleasesallocatedthroughaspecificRelayAgent.
"QueryforallconfiguredIPs"whereallIPaddressheldbyDHCPServerirrespectiveofstateisreturned.
Inthiscase,unassignedIPaddressesarereturnedwithUNASSIGNEDstate.
Newfiltersareadded:StartandEndtimefiltercanbepassedtoretrieveleasesforwhichstatehaschangedwithinthespecifiedtime.
Otherquerytypes(QuerybyIPAddress,MACaddress,Client-IDandremote-id)arealsosupported.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:UponreceivingaBULKLEASEQUERY,DHCPservergeneratesastreamofLEASEACTIVEforeachleasethatfulfilsthequery.
EndofleaseforagivenqueryisindicatedbytheLEASEQUERYDONEmessage.
MultipleBulkLeasequerycanbeinitiatedoverasingleTCPconnection.
Transactionid(XID)isusedtodistinguishbetweentherepliesformultiplequeries.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVStandardizationandImplementationeffortsStandardizationefforts:Querybyremote-idandBulkLeaseQuerydraftisbeingstandardizedinDHCworkinggroupofIETF.
Implementationefforts:WehavecreatedaProof-Of-Conceptimplementationof'QuerybyRemote-Id'and'BulkLeaseQuery'byenhancingISCDHCPserver.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVReferences:S.
Bellovin,"SecurityproblemsintheTCP/IPprotocolsuite,"SIGCOMMComputerCommunicationReview,vol.
19,no.
2,pp.
32–48,1989.
R.
BeverlyandS.
Bauer,"Thespooferproject:inferringtheextentofsourceaddressfilteringontheinternet,"inSRUTI'05:Proc.
oftheStepstoReducingUnwantedTrafficontheInternet,2005.
IETFStandards:RFC2131,DynamicHostConfigurationProtocolLayer2RelayAgenthttp://www.
ietf.
org/id/draft-ietf-dhc-l2ra-04.
txthttp://www.
ietf.
org/id/draft-ietf-dhc-l2ra-extensions-01.
txtQuerybyremote-idhttp://www.
ietf.
org/id/draft-ietf-dhc-leasequery-by-remote-id-02.
txtBulkleasequeryhttp://www.
ietf.
org/id/draft-ietf-dhc-dhcpv4-bulk-leasequery-00.
txtTR-101fromBroadbandForumhttp://www.
broadband-forum.
org/technical/download/TR-101.
pdf2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVThankYou
com)PavanKurapati(pavan_kurapati@infosys.
com)RamakrishnaRaoDTV(ramakrishnadtv@infosys.
com)2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVAgendaSpoofing–What,WhyandHowTypesofuserconnectionsinBroadbandAccessConcentratorsTypesofspoofingHowtocollectdatatodoAnti-spoofinginAccessNetworkAnti-spoofingHowtorecoveranti-spoofingdataafterBACcrash/reboot2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVWhatisSpoofiingSpoofingisaprocesswherebyoneentitymasqueradesasanotherentityWhyisspoofingdoneSpoofingAbyBisdoneforvariouspurposesBseekstheprivilegesofABintendstohideitstracksAsanattackonAHowisspoofingdoneWeshallseeincomingslides2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTheultimategoalofspoofingUnauthorizedServiceGetserviceonsomeoneelse'sexpenseLossofServiceonTargetMakesurethatthetargetdoesnotgetanyserviceDifficulttotracetheattackerMakesurethatpeoplecannotfindwhoattackedthem.
UnnecessarypacketscloggingthenetworkMakesurethatnobodygetsagoodservice.
SecondaryvictimPrimarytargetrespondstospoofpacketandoverwhelmthesourcewhichbecomessecondaryvictim.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTypesofuserconnectionsforanIPbasedDSLAMBridgedIPRoutingRFC2684basedbridgedencapsulationbetweenEndUserandDSLAMDSLAMinroutingmodewithroutedVLANsconfiguredonuplinki/fDynamicIPallocationusingDHCPPPPoE/APPPterminationinDSLAMIPallocationfromlocalpoolDSLAMinroutingmodewithroutedVLANsconfiguredonuplinki/fIPoARFC2684basedroutedencapsulationbetweenEndUserandDSLAMDSLAMinroutingmodewithroutedVLANsconfiguredonuplinki/fDynamicIPallocationusingDHCPL3DSLAMxDSLHomeHubxDSLHomeHubMPLSCloudPEPRouterPRouterBRASL3n/wDataCenterL3DSLAMInternetservices2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV6DSLAML3AxDSLHomeHubL3n/wDHCP2UnicastDISCOVER+Option82populatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID1BroadcastDHCPDISCOVERUnicastDHCPOFFERwithoption82echoed3SendDHCPOFFERtothehostafterremovingoption8246UnicastREQUEST+Option82populatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID5BroadcastDHCPREQUESTUnicastDHCPACKtotheclientwithoption827SendDHCPACKtothehostafterremovingoption828AddressallocationmechanismsforIPDSLAM–DHCP2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTypesofuserconnectionsforaLayer2DSLAM1:1VLANsMapeveryuserconnectiontooneunique802.
1qbasedVLANNoneedofanyMAClearningofindividualhostsDownstreamtrafficmappingdonebasedonVLANsQinQorStackedVLANsAnouterServiceVLANidentifyingaspecificserviceisaddedDownstreammappingdonebasedoncombinationofCVLANandSVLANN:1TransparentBridgedVLANsMultipleusersmappedtoacommonVLANDownstreammappingdonebasedonVLANandDstMACcombinationMAClearningisrequiredforoperationL2DSLAMxDSLHomeHubxDSLHomeHubMPLSCloudPEPRouterPRouterBRASAccessAggregationDataCenterL2DSLAMInternetservices2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV8DSLAML2RAxDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroDHCP2BroadcastDISCOVER+Option82populatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID1BroadcastDHCPDISCOVER3UnicastDISCOVERwith'giaddr'populatedUnicastDHCPOFFERwithoption82echoed45BroadcastDHCPOFFERwithoption82andwithout'giaddr'SendDHCPOFFERtothehostafterremovingoption8268BroadcastREQUEST+Option82populatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID7BroadcastDHCPREQUEST9UnicastREQUESTwith'giaddr'populatedUnicastDHCPACKtotheclientwithoption8210SendDHCPACKtothehostafterremovingoption8211AddressallocationmechanismsforL2DSLAM–DHCP2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV9DSLAML2RAxDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroDHCPRADIUSPortEnabled1EAPOLStart2IdentityRequest3IdentityResponse4IdentityDetails5EAPMD5Challenge6MD5ChallengeResponse7AuthSuccess8AuthSuccess9DHCPAuthentication&AddressallocationmechanismsforL2DSLAM–DHCP+802.
1x2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV10DSLAMxDSLHomeHubBRASMetroRADIUS2PADI+IntermediateAgentpopulatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-ID1PADIPADO+IntermediateAgentechoed35PADR6PADR+IntermediateAgentpopulatedwithRemote-ID/Circuit-IDPADS+IntermediateAgentechoed79PPPNegotiationsAuthentication&AddressallocationmechanismsforL2DSLAM-PPPoEPADOafterremovingagentinformationoption4PADSafterremovingagentinformationoption82009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVTypeofSpoofingMACSpoofingIPSpoofingARPSpoofingControlprotocolinternalheaderspoofingPPPoEsession-idspoofingDHCPchaddr,ciaddr,relay-agent-informationoptionspoofing2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV12DSLAMAttackerChangeSrcMACaddressandfloodtrafficSimulates1000sofMACaddressatfasterratexDSLMACTablemaximumlimitreachedLegitimatetrafficdroppedduetoMACtableexhaustionChangingSourceMACaddresstoanillegitimateaddressAttackerxDSLMACI/FB2A2FloodtrafficwithbothMACAandMACBMACBLegitimatetrafficblockedMACAMACspoofing2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVIPspoofingChangingSourceIPaddresstoanillegitimateaddressAttackerxDSLIPBDoSattackonIPAIPASendtrafficwithIPAandMACBRepliesfloodedtoIPA12PingofDeathServiceProvider'sNetwork2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVARPspoofingRespond/sendARPResponsewithillegitimateIPaddressABCDARP:WhoisIPB1ARPReply:IamIPB:MACA2IPMACAABATrafficflowingtohostAARPTableABCDGratuitousARP:IamIPB:MACA1IPMACAABATrafficflowingtohostAARPTableServiceProvider'sNetworkServiceProvider'sNetwork2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDHCPHeaderDHCPHeaderspoofingOp(1)Htype(1)Hlen(1)Hops(1)Xid(4)Secs(2)Flags(2)Ciaddr(4)Yiaddr(4)Siaddr(4)Giaddr(4)Chaddr(16)Sname(64)File(128)Options(Variable)ClientIdenrtifierRelayAgentOptionDSLAMAttackerxDSLL2RAL3RADHCPServerABDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BChaddr:A2Spoof'chaddr'fieldDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BClientId:A3Spoof'ClientIdentifier'fieldDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BOption82RemoteId:A4SpoofOption82fieldChangingInternalfieldswithinDHCPheaderDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BCiaddr:A1Spoof'ciaddr'field2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVSimilarlyPPPoESession-IDfieldidentifiesauniquesession.
SpoofingthiscanalsocauseservicedisruptionPPPoEHeaderPPPoEHeaderspoofingVERTYPECODESESSION_IDLENGTHPAYLOADChangingSESSION_IDfieldinPPPoEHeaderAttackerxDSLIPBIPAPPPoEIABRAS1PADT:SESSION_ID:ASessionDisconnectedServiceProvider'sNetwork2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVAnti-spoofingWhatisanti-spoofingMechanismtoidentifyspoofingandstoppingit.
Howanti-spoofingisdoneBydroppingthespoofedpacketsHowtoidentifythespoofedpacketsByverifyingIPAddressofthereceivedpacket.
ByverifyingMACaddressofthereceivedpacket.
ByverifyingthecombinationofIPandMACaddressforagiveninterfaceByverifyingtheIPaddress,MACaddressandothersessionbasedidentificationintheprotocolheader.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDatarequiredforAnti-spoofingForeachuserconnectionListofValidIPaddressesassignedListofValidMACaddressesandifpossiblethecombinationofMACandIPaddresses,TimeforwhicheachIPaddressisvalid.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVWhyanti-spoofinginBroadbandAccessConcentrator(BAC)BACisattherightplace:Itknowsalltherequiredinformationtodoanti-spoofing.
Anti-spoofingbecomesdifficultandlesseffectiveifitisnotdoneasnearthesourceaspossible.
Itisnotonlyimportanttodropspoofedpackets,itisimportanttodropthemasearlyaspossible.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDatacollectionforAntispoofinginBAC-PPPoE1xDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroRADIUS2PADIPADO34PADRPADSBACObtainSession-IDfromPADSIPMACSession-IDI/FAA1011BB1022PPPLCPPPPIPCPBACObtainIPinformationfromIPCP567PADTBACDeletethespoofingentry2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDatacollectionforAntispoofinginBAC-DHCPxDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroDHCPIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB120212DHCPDISCOVERDHCPOFFER34DHCPREQUESTDHCPACKBACObtainIP/MAC/LeasetimefromDHCPACKMessage6DHCPRELEASEBACRemovetheentryfromtableLeaseEXPIREBACRemovetheentryfromtable2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDatacollectionforAntispoofinginBAC–802.
1x+DHCP1xDSLHomeHubBRASL3RAMetroDHCP2InitialEAPNegotiationsEAPAuthSuccess34DHCPMessageexchangeDHCPACKBACObtaintheMACaddressfromEAPAuthSuccessmessageIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202RADIUSBACObtainIP&LeasetimefromDHCPACKMessage2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVMACAntispoofingDSLAMAttackerAttackerxDSLMACI/FB2A1FloodtrafficwithbothMACAandMACBMACBNoImpactonAMACAMACBIPMACLeaseI/FBB1202Floodtrafficwith1000'sofSrcMACsinadditiontoMACBCompareAntispooftableanddiscardnonmatchingentriesNoMACtableExhaustion!
MACI/FB2MACTableAntiSpoofTableIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202CompareAntispooftableanddiscardnonmatchingentriesNospoofingofNeighbor'sMAC!
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVIPAntispoofingAttackerxDSLIPBNoImpactonAIPASendtrafficwithIPAandMACB1IPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202CompareIPagainstthei/finAntispooftableMetro2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVARPAntispoofingABCDARP:WhoisIPB1ARPReply:IamIPB:MACA2IPMACAABBARPTableABCDGratuitousARP:IamIPB:MACA1IPMACAABBARPTableIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202CompareIP/MACagainstthei/finAntispooftableIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202ServiceProviderN/wServiceProviderN/w2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVDHCPHeaderAntispoofingDSLAMAttackerxDSLL2RAL3RADHCPServerABDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BChaddr:A1AntiSpooffilterdiscardDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BOption82RemoteId:A3Option82fromuntrustedentity.
DiscardIPMACLeaseI/FAA2001BB1202InspectDHCPHeader&comparechaddr&ClientIDwithantispooftableAcceptDHCPwithoption82onlyifitiscomingfromtrustedentityDHCPRelease:MACB:SrcIP:BCiaddr:A2AntiSpooffilterdiscard2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVPPPoEHeaderAntispoofingAttackerxDSLIPBIPAPPPoEIABRAS1PADT:SESSION_ID:101IPMACSession-IDI/FAA1011BB1022SessionIDdoesnotmatchNoImpactonAMetro2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLosingdatacollectedforanti-spoofingDatausedinAntispoofingcanbelostduetovariousreasonsPlannedrebootSoftwarecrashPowerfailureReplacementofsystemSoftwareupgrade2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVHowtorecoverlostdataStaticconfigurationRequiredDataisavailableintheconfiguration.
PPPoEForPPPoE,thekeep-alivetimersareconfiguredandthesessionisre-initiatediftherearenorepliestothekeep-alivemessagesDHCPDHCPdoesnothavekeepalivemechanisminplace.
DHCPhasa'leasetime'whichisusuallyinorderof'days'.
Howtorecoverfromthissituation2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRecoveringLeaseinformationforDHCPStableStorage:NotveryusefulasnotmanyBACssupportstablestorage.
LimitederasecyclesisalsoabottleneckinthisapproachBroadcastARPs:NeedtowaitfordownstreamtraffictoarriveandinitiateARPrequests.
Willincreasethedelay.
Cannotgetthecompleteinformationinonerequest.
PronetospoofingattacksifamalicioususerrepliestotheARPrequest.
RedundantcontrollersBACcanhaveredundantcontrollersandupononecontrollercrash,theothercontrollercantakeoverwithpre-synchedleasedata.
Notsuitableforpowerfailurescenariosorforupgrades.
Havingredundantcontrollersalsoaddtohardwarecosts2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRecoveringLeaseinformationforDHCPQuerythroughSNMP/LDAPCurrentlynostandardMIBsareavailableforDHCPleaseinformation.
BACstypicallydonotsupportSNMPclientinterfacesQueryleaseinformationfromDHCPserverSolvesmostoftheproblemsstatedabove2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeasequeryforDHCP(RFC4388)RFC4388introducedanewDHCPrequestLeasequerywhichaBACcanusetoqueryDHCPservertoobtainleaseinformation.
ThreetypesofqueriesaresupportedQuerybyIPaddressOnlyIPaddressispopulatedinthequerymessage.
QuerybyMACaddressOnlyMACaddressispopulatedinthequerymessage.
Ifmorethanoneleaseisavailable,thencorrespondingIPaddressesarereturnedinassociated-ipoption.
BACthengetsadditionaldatabygeneratingquerybyIPaddress.
QuerybyClientidentifierOnlyclientidentifieroptionispopulatedinthequerymessage.
Ifmorethanoneleaseisavailable,thencorrespondingIPaddressesarereturnedinassociated-ipoption.
BACthengetstheadditionaldatabyqueryingbyIPaddress.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeasequeryforDHCP(RFC4388)Threetypesofreplymessagetypesareintroduced:DHCPLEASEACTIVEWhenDHCPserverknowsaboutthequeryidentifier.
DHCPLEASEUNKNOWN:WhenDHCPserverdoesnotknowaboutthequeryidentifier.
AnAccessConcentratorcachethisinformationsothatthiscanbeusedtoavoidgeneratingLeaseQueryforthequeryidentifier.
ThisisknownasNegativeCaching.
DHCPLEASEUNASSIGNED:WhenDHCPserverdoesmanagethequeryidentifierbutnoleaseisyetassigned.
NegativeCachingisdoneforthisresponseaswell.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–DataDriven34DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I1MACIPLeaseI/fM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1AntiSpoofTable123I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–DataDriven35DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerCRASHMACIPLeaseI/fAntiSpoofTable123I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–DataDriven36DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer1DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
22LeaseQuerybyIPAddress3LeaseActiveM1,T1,I1MACIPLeaseI/fM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1AntiSpoofTable4DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
25123I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–NegativeCaching37xDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerCRASH123I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–NegativeCaching381DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
102LeaseQuerybyIPAddressNegativeCachingxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer123MACIPThresholdI/fM1192.
168.
1.
10T1I13LeaseUNKNOWN182.
168.
1.
10,M14I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVRFC4388basedleasequery–NegativeCaching392DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
103LeaseQuerybyIPAddressNegativeCachingxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer123MACIPThresholdI/fM1192.
168.
1.
10T1I14LeaseUNKNOWN182.
168.
1.
10,M1Thresholdexpired1I12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVIssueswithRFC4388basedleasequeryExistingLeasequerymechanismisdatadriven:LeasequeryisinitiatedonlywhenAccessConcentratorsreceivesdataExistingmethodsuggeststheuseofnegativecaching.
NegativeCachingconsumeslotofresourcesunderspoofattacks.
Resultsinincreasedoutagetimefortheclients.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVIssueswithRFC4388basedleasequery(contd.
.
)Gettingconsolidatedleaseinformationperconnectionisnotpossible:Existingmechanismdoesn'thaveanymethodstogetconsolidatedleaseinformationforalltheclientsbelongingtoaconnection/circuitMultipleclientscanresideforagivenconnection/circuit.
IfAccessconcentratorhasleaseinformationofalltheclientsforagivenconnection/circuit,anti-spoofingcanbedoneindataplane(fastpath)2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVQuerybyremote-idRemote-IDsuboptionidentifyiesaconnection/circuituniquely.
ThisisgloballyuniqueidentifierRemote-IDcanbetrustedastheyarecreatedbyRelayAgent.
AccessConcentratorneednotwaitforthetraffictoarriveandcangenerateLeaseQueryassoonasitcomesupafterareboot.
DHCPServercanprovideconsolidatedLeaseInformationforaspecificconnection/circuit.
Oncealltheleaseinformationforagivenconnection/circuitisobtained,anti-spoofingcanbedoneindataplane(fastpath).
NoneedforNegativeCaching.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeaseQuerybyRemoteId43xDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer123M1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I1M3192.
168.
1.
10T3I1MACIPLeaseI/fAntiSpoofTableI12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeaseQuerybyRemoteId44xDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerCRASH123MACIPLeaseI/fAntiSpoofTableI12009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVLeaseQuerybyRemoteId451LeaseQuerybyRemoteIdforI12LeaseActiveofallthreeleases*3DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
8xDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer123M1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I1M3192.
168.
1.
10T3I1MACIPLeaseI/fAntiSpoofTable4DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
8BACdoesnotneedtowaitforthetraffictoinitiateLQLeasequerybyremote-idresultsinobtainingcompleteinformationonagiveninterface.
NoneedofinitiatingsubsequentqueriesI1*Leaseactiveforoneleaseisreturnedfollowedbyassociated-IPoption.
ThisresultsinsubsequentquerybyIPforremainingleases2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:ServeridentifiesaLeasequerybyremote-idwhentheleasequerymessagehas:Chaddr,siaddr,Ciaddr,htype,hlenandchaddriszeroandClientidentifieroptionisnotpresentandOption82withonlyRemote-Idsub-optionispresent.
SendsaLEASEACTIVEpopulatingtheciaddrwiththeIPaddressthatwasmostrecentlyaccessedbytheclient.
AllotherIPaddressesarereturnedinAssociated-IPoption.
RelayagentthensendsaLeasequerywith"QuerybyIPAddress"foralltheadditionalIPaddressesreturnedinAssociated-ipoption.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:ServermayreturnaLEASEUNASSIGNEDifitknowsitmanagestheleasefortheconnectionidentifiedbyRemote-Idsub-optionbutnoleaseisassignedyet.
ServermayreturnLEASEUNKNOWNifitdoesnotknowthecorrespondingRemote-idsub-option.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVWhyBulkLeasequeryTraditionalleasequery(Both4388)andleasequerybyremote-idworksontheprincipleofretrievingoneleaseatatimeWhilequerybyremote-idsolvesalltheproblemsassociatedwithRFC4388basedleasequerymechanism,itstillinvolvesgeneratinghugenumberofleasequeriestogetallthepossibledataBulkleasequeryworksontheprincipleofestablishingTCPconnectionbetweenRAandServerandretrievinginformationinbulk2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVBulkLeaseQuery49DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerMACIPAddressLeaseTimeInterfaceM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I2M3192.
168.
1.
3T2I3I1I2I32009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVBulkLeaseQuery50DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerCRASHI1I2I3MACIPLeaseI/f2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVBulkLeaseQuery51DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServerMACIPAddressLeaseTimeInterfaceM1192.
168.
1.
2T1I1M2192.
168.
1.
8T2I2M3192.
168.
1.
3T2I33DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
81BulkLeaseQueryinaTCPSession2LeaseActiveofallleases4DataTrafficfrom192.
168.
1.
8LeaseinformationofallinterfacesobtainedininonequeryI1I2I32009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:DSLAMLayer3RelayAgentxDSLHomeHubServiceProviderNetworkDHCPServer1TCPSession2BulkLeaseQuerywithXID23LEASEQUERYACTIVEforXID24LEASEQUERYACTIVEforXID25LEASEQUERYACTIVEforXID26LEASEQUERYDONEforXID27TCPsessionclose2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:AQuerier(TypicallyaRelayAgent)establishesaTCPconnectionwiththeserveronport67.
Twonewquerytypesareadded"QuerybyRelay-ID"whererelay-idisauniqueRelayagentIdentifier.
AllleasesallocatedthroughaspecificRelayAgent.
"QueryforallconfiguredIPs"whereallIPaddressheldbyDHCPServerirrespectiveofstateisreturned.
Inthiscase,unassignedIPaddressesarereturnedwithUNASSIGNEDstate.
Newfiltersareadded:StartandEndtimefiltercanbepassedtoretrieveleasesforwhichstatehaschangedwithinthespecifiedtime.
Otherquerytypes(QuerybyIPAddress,MACaddress,Client-IDandremote-id)arealsosupported.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVProtocolDetails:UponreceivingaBULKLEASEQUERY,DHCPservergeneratesastreamofLEASEACTIVEforeachleasethatfulfilsthequery.
EndofleaseforagivenqueryisindicatedbytheLEASEQUERYDONEmessage.
MultipleBulkLeasequerycanbeinitiatedoverasingleTCPconnection.
Transactionid(XID)isusedtodistinguishbetweentherepliesformultiplequeries.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVStandardizationandImplementationeffortsStandardizationefforts:Querybyremote-idandBulkLeaseQuerydraftisbeingstandardizedinDHCworkinggroupofIETF.
Implementationefforts:WehavecreatedaProof-Of-Conceptimplementationof'QuerybyRemote-Id'and'BulkLeaseQuery'byenhancingISCDHCPserver.
2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVReferences:S.
Bellovin,"SecurityproblemsintheTCP/IPprotocolsuite,"SIGCOMMComputerCommunicationReview,vol.
19,no.
2,pp.
32–48,1989.
R.
BeverlyandS.
Bauer,"Thespooferproject:inferringtheextentofsourceaddressfilteringontheinternet,"inSRUTI'05:Proc.
oftheStepstoReducingUnwantedTrafficontheInternet,2005.
IETFStandards:RFC2131,DynamicHostConfigurationProtocolLayer2RelayAgenthttp://www.
ietf.
org/id/draft-ietf-dhc-l2ra-04.
txthttp://www.
ietf.
org/id/draft-ietf-dhc-l2ra-extensions-01.
txtQuerybyremote-idhttp://www.
ietf.
org/id/draft-ietf-dhc-leasequery-by-remote-id-02.
txtBulkleasequeryhttp://www.
ietf.
org/id/draft-ietf-dhc-dhcpv4-bulk-leasequery-00.
txtTR-101fromBroadbandForumhttp://www.
broadband-forum.
org/technical/download/TR-101.
pdf2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIV2009InfosysTechnologiesLimitedSANOGXIVThankYou
- Changeoption82相关文档
- 配置option82
- truckoption82
- Multipleoption82
- 支持option82
- 招标文件项目名称:汕头大学行政楼网络设备采购项目(重招)
- 支持option82
老薛主机入门建站月付34/月,年付345元，半价香港VPS主机
老薛主机怎么样?老薛主机这个商家有存在有一些年头。如果没有记错的话，早年老薛主机是做虚拟主机业务的，还算不错在异常激烈的市场中生存到现在，应该算是在众多商家中早期积累到一定的用户群的，主打小众个人网站业务所以能持续到现在。这不，站长看到商家有在进行夏季促销，比如我们很多网友可能有需要的香港vps主机季度及以上可以半价优惠，如果有在选择不同主机商的香港机房的可以看看老薛主机商家的香港vps。点击进入...
火数云 55元/月BGP限时三折，独立服务器及站群限时8折,新乡、安徽、香港、美国
火数云怎么样？火数云主要提供数据中心基础服务、互联网业务解决方案，及专属服务器租用、云服务器、专属服务器托管、带宽租用等产品和服务。火数云提供洛阳、新乡、安徽、香港、美国等地骨干级机房优质资源，包括BGP国际多线网络，CN2点对点直连带宽以及国际顶尖品牌硬件。专注为个人开发者用户,中小型,大型企业用户提供一站式核心网络云端服务部署,促使用户云端部署化简为零,轻松快捷运用云计算！多年云计算领域服务经...
10gbiz：香港/洛杉矶CN2直连线路VPS四折优惠,直连香港/香港/洛杉矶CN2四折
10gbiz怎么样?10gbiz在本站也多次分享过，是一家成立于2020的国人主机商家，主要销售VPS和独立服务器，机房目前有中国香港和美国洛杉矶、硅谷等地，线路都非常不错，香港为三网直连，电信走CN2，洛杉矶线路为三网回程CN2 GIA，10gbiz商家七月连续推出各种优惠活动，除了延续之前的VPS产品4折优惠，目前增加了美国硅谷独立服务器首月半价的活动，有需要的朋友可以看看。10gbiz优惠码...
option82为你推荐
-
美国互联网瘫痪2000年美国的互联网危机事件的原因？www.kkk.com谁有免费的电影网站,越多越好?杰景新特萨克斯吉普特500是台湾原产的吗xyq.163.cbg.comhttp://xyq.cbg.163.com/cgi-bin/equipquery.py?act=buy_show_equip_info&equip_id=475364&server_id=625 有金鱼贵吗？网站检测请问，对网站进行监控检测的工具有哪些？haole10.com空人电影网改网址了？www.10yyy.cn是空人电影网么广告法中华人民共和国广告法中,有哪些广告不得发布?www.15job.com南方人才市场有官方网站是什么？www.k8k8.com谁能给我几个街污网站我去自己学彪言彪语寻找一个电影和里面的一首歌，国产的，根据真实故事改编的校园爱情电影，里面的男主角是个屌丝但很会弹钢