LetThemInsolvencysituationsrarelyleavecouponholdersinapositionwheretheycanhavetheircakeandeatitThesuddencollapseofMaria'sBakeryinAprilraisesnewcon-cernsovertheextenttowhichholdersofcouponsareprotectedfromthein-solvencyofcouponissuingcompanies.
Inthecaseofcakecoupons,thepurchasermakesanadvancepaymentinreturnfor'onedozenassorted,cakes'(inpracticetheirequivalentvalue)promisedinthecoupon.
Heorshehasacontractualrighttodemanddeliveryofthecakesuponproductionofthecoupon.
Failureonthepartoftheis-suerresultsinabreachofcontract,entitlingthepurchasertopursuelegalredressandobtaindamages.
Thosewhoreceivecouponsasgiftsenjoythesamerightofredemption,astheissuingcompanyhasmadeauni-lateraloffertodeliveronedozencakestoanyonewhoproducesthecoupon.
Ascontractualrightsarepersonalratherthanproprietaryrights,iftheissuingcompanybecomesinsolvent,theholderofthecakecouponisonlyentitledtoashareofthecompany'sassets,alongwiththeotherunsecuredcreditors,onapanpassubasis-unlessthecouponholdercanprove,interalia,thattitleoversomeoftheseassetshasalreadypassedorthatsomeoftheseassetsareactuallyheldbytheinsolventcompanyontrustforhimorher.
Accordingly,theholderofacakecouponmaytrytoestablishthefol-lowingclaims,noneofwhich,however,offermuchhope.
Thefirstclaim,relatingtomer-chandisepromisedunderacoupon,isthattitlehasalreadypassedtothepur-chaserofthecouponbeforethecom-pany'sinsolvency.
Iftheholderisnottheoriginalpurchaserbutadonee,hehasobtainedtitlethroughconstruc-tivedelivery(thatis,deliveryofthecoupon)bytheoriginalpurchaser.
Unders18oftheSaleofGoodsOrdi-nance,'WherethereisacontractforthePage22saleofunascertainedgoodsnoprop-ertyinthegoodsistransferredtothebuyerunlessanduntilthegoodsareascertained.
'As'unascertainedgoods'inthissectionincludegoodstobemanufacturedatsomefuturedatebytheseller,purelygenericgoodsandanunidentifiedportionofaspecifiedbulk,the'onedozenassortedcakes'prom-isedinthecouponsfallwithinthisdefinition.
Eventhoughtheymightbesub-sequentlyascertained,fortitletopass,r5(1)ofs20oftheSaleofGoodsOrdinanceprovidesthat,subjecttocon-traryintention,thegoodsmusthavebeenunconditionallyappropriated;theymusthavebeenearmarkedorat-tachedtothecontractinquestion.
Hence,intheordinarycourseofbusiness,titleoverthecakesdoesnotpassuntilthecustomershavechosenthecakesandthesaleassistantshaveremovedthemfromthedisplayshelves.
Inanycase,thisargumentisofnopracticalhelpwhereperishableitemssuchascakesareconcerned.
Norwoulditbeusefulforconsumersofservicessuchasholdersofrentalcoupons.
Thesecondclaimisthatthepur-chasemoneyisheldbythecompanyintrustfortheclaimant.
Thepurchasercanarguethattheissuingcompanyreceivesthepurchasemoneyinafidu-ciarycapacity,aspurchasershaveplacedtrustandconfidenceinit.
Thisargumentwasrejected(almost)outrightinReGoldcorpExchangeLtd[1995]1AC74,wherethePrivyCoun-cilwasunwillingtofindanyseparatefiduciarydutyinrelationtothepur-chasemoneythatisdifferentfromordinarycontractualduties.
Anotherwayofestablishingatrustoverthepurchasemoneyistoassertthatmoneypaidunderacontractforthesaleofgoodscanbeconstruedasatrustinthepurchaser'sfavour.
Thismayapplyifthereis'eitheramutualintentionthatthemoneysshouldnotfallwithin,thegeneralfundofthecom-pany'sassetsbutshould,beappliedforaspecialdesignatedpurpose,orthathavingoriginallybeenpaidoverwith-outrestrictiontherecipienthaslaterconstitutedhimselfatrusteeofthemoney':ReGoldcorpExchangeLtd,above,affirmingQuistcloseInvestmentsLtdvRollsRazorLtd[1970]AC567.
Hence,inReKayfordLtd(InLiquida-tion)[1975]1WLR279,whereamailordercompanythatwasinfinancialdifficultiesputcustomers'depositmoneysinan.
account,meaningtokeepthemseparatefromitsgeneralassets,atrustwascreatedinfavourofthecus-tomers.
However,forthisargumenttosuc-ceed,theclaimantmustshowthattherecipientisnotfreetospendthepur-chasemoneyasitchooses:ReGoldcorpExchangeLtd,above.
Itwouldthusappearthatintheabsenceofanypromiseoractionbytheissuingcompanytokeepthepurchasemoneyseparatefromitsfunds,itisdifficulttoseehowtherequisitetrustcouldbeestablished.
Furthermore,doneesofcouponsareunabletorelyonsuchtrustsinrelationtothepurchasemoney,asitisdifficulttofindanyvalidassignmentofthebeneficialinterest,ifany,tothem.
CoulditbearguedthatthisresultistooharshonconsumersWhilstonecanappreciatetheirpredicament,pro-tectingcouponholdersbygivingthemproprietaryrightswillupsettheallo-cationofrisksthatthepartieshavealreadyundertaken.
Bypurchasingcoupons,consum-ersshouldrecognisethattheyareexchangingconvenience(orpricedis-counts)fortheriskofinsolvency.
Inthiscurrenteconomicclimate,theyshouldbeadvisedtoexercisethenec-essarycautionbeforepurchasingcouponsorredeemthembeforeitistoolate.
;LusinaHofacultyofLawUniversity''ofHongKongHangKongLaivycrJuly1998
racknerd怎么样?racknerd最近发布了一些便宜美国服务器促销,包括大硬盘服务器,提供120G SSD+192TB HDD,有AMD和Intel两个选择,默认32G内存,1Gbps带宽,每个月100TB流量,5个IP地址,月付$599。价格非常便宜,需要存储服务器的朋友可以关注一下。RackNerd主要经营美国圣何塞、洛杉矶、达拉斯、芝加哥、亚特兰大、新泽西机房基于KVM虚拟化的VPS、...
亚洲云Asiayun怎么样?亚洲云成立于2021年,隶属于上海玥悠悠云计算有限公司(Yyyisp),是一家新国人IDC商家,且正规持证IDC/ISP/CDN,商家主要提供数据中心基础服务、互联网业务解决方案,及专属服务器租用、云服务器、云虚拟主机、专属服务器托管、带宽租用等产品和服务。Asiayun提供源自大陆、香港、韩国和美国等地骨干级机房优质资源,包括BGP国际多线网络,CN2点对点直连带宽以...
青果网络QG.NET定位为高效多云管理服务商,已拥有工信部颁发的全网云计算/CDN/IDC/ISP/IP-VPN等多项资质,是CNNIC/APNIC联盟的成员之一,2019年荣获国家高薪技术企业、福建省省级高新技术企业双项荣誉。那么青果网络作为国内主流的IDC厂商之一,那么其旗下美国洛杉矶CN2 GIA线路云服务器到底怎么样?官方网站:https://www.qg.net/CPU内存系统盘流量宽带...
let为你推荐
免费注册域名怎样免费注册域名呢 要详细的步骤哦虚拟主机服务器虚拟主机与独立服务器区别域名空间什么是域名,空间?服务器租赁服务器出租是什么意思,来点简单能看得懂的代理主机如何将我工作的电脑设置为代理主机 让我回家以后可以用家里的电脑连接店里的主机访问网络网站空间域名网站、域名空间三者的关系海外域名我想了解一下“国内域名”,“国外域名”以及“海外服务器”这三个方面的一些知识合肥虚拟主机虚拟主机是干嘛的?买了虚拟主机是否要一台电脑?郑州虚拟主机请问郑州哪家公司可以做网站还有相应服务器服务的?沈阳虚拟主机有没有不限空间、不限流量的网站?
域名商 omnis 国外服务器网站 免备案空间 阿里云代金券 java空间 中国电信测速112 idc资讯 789电视网 网站木马检测工具 国外免费asp空间 中国电信宽带测速网 服务器监测 国外ip加速器 多线空间 in域名 web服务器搭建 重庆电信服务器托管 西安主机 xuni 更多