AcuriouscaseofbrokenDNSresponsesBabakFarrokhiRIPE75AboutmeUnixSA(FreeBSD,Solaris,Linux)since1996IPNetworkingsince1997FreeBSDPortsTeamsince2004Enthusiasticcoder@farrokhiPrologueWhenitcomestonetwork,IalwayshavetrustissuesMostpeopleignorethosestrangenetworkbehaviorsOnlyafewpeopletaketheredpillandgodowntherabbithole.
.
.
ObservationOutgoingSMTPfailsduetoMXlookupfailuresonlycertaindomains(e.
g.
twitter.
com)Localresolverreturns"incorrect"responsePublicResolver(e.
g.
Google)alsoreturnedincorrectresponseIneededtolookdeeperintothisDowntherabbithole.
.
.
StrangeresponsesfrompublicresolversThisisnotwhatIexpectedtogetfromapublicresolver:%dig+short-tAtwitter.
com@8.
8.
8.
810.
10.
34.
34%dig+short-tAripe.
net@8.
8.
8.
8193.
0.
6.
139%dig-tMXtwitter.
com@8.
8.
8.
8;;Gotbadpacket:badlabeltype45bytes40108180000100010000000007747769twi7474657203636f6d00000c0001c00c00tter.
com.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
0c000100000379000341414100.
.
.
.
.
.
y.
.
AAA.
NeedtotakeacloserlookNotobviousatfirstglance,buttimedeltaisstrange.
.
.
%tcpdump-ttt-c2-nqrripe.
pcapreadingfromPCAP-NGfileripe.
pcap00:00:00.
000000IP192.
168.
0.
132.
53425>8.
8.
8.
8.
53:UDP,length2700:00:00.
138933IP8.
8.
8.
8.
53>192.
168.
0.
132.
53425:UDP,length75%tcpdump-ttt-c2-nqrtwitter.
pcapreadingfromPCAP-NGfiletwitter.
pcap00:00:00.
000000IP192.
168.
0.
132.
58418>8.
8.
8.
8.
53:UDP,length2900:00:00.
028077IP8.
8.
8.
8.
53>192.
168.
0.
132.
58418:UDP,length45dnsping-AnewtoolisbornStartedasahumblePythonscripttosolvemyownproblemNotintendedtore-inventthewheelSimilaruserexperienceasthelegacyPING%.
/dnsping.
py-s8.
8.
8.
8-c3ripe.
netdnsping.
pyDNS:8.
8.
8.
8:53,hostname:ripe.
net,rdatatype:A32bytesfrom8.
8.
8.
8:seq=0time=200.
371ms32bytesfrom8.
8.
8.
8:seq=1time=217.
320ms32bytesfrom8.
8.
8.
8:seq=2time=236.
644ms---8.
8.
8.
8dnspingstatistics---3requeststransmitted,3responsesreceived,0%lostmin=200.
371ms,avg=218.
112ms,max=236.
644ms,stddev=18.
149msICMPvsDNSResponseTimes%ping-q-c108.
8.
8.
8PING8.
8.
8.
8(8.
8.
8.
8):56databytes---8.
8.
8.
8pingstatistics---10packetstransmitted,10packetsreceived,0.
0%packetlossround-tripmin/avg/max/stddev=124.
237/155.
044/227.
499/31.
464ms%.
/dnsping.
py-q-s8.
8.
8.
8-c3twitter.
comdnsping.
pyDNS:8.
8.
8.
8:53,hostname:twitter.
com,rdatatype:A---8.
8.
8.
8dnspingstatistics---3requeststransmitted,3responsesreceived,0%lostmin=12.
934ms,avg=21.
355ms,max=29.
425ms,stddev=8.
251msFirstanomalyDifferentdomainnamesbeingtreateddifferentlyAroguenameserverimpersonatingasGoogleResolverTheroguenameserverisclosetome(givenresponsetimes)WhereisitAndhowcanIfindoutdnstraceroute:TraceroutetoolforDNSprotocolSimilartolegacytraceroute,butforDNSprotocolSendoutactualDNSqueriesandexpectaresponseUsingTTLtricktomapthejourneyCouldnotuselegacytraceroutewithUDPprobesThetrafficredirectionisbasedonDNS"payload"RealvsRogueDNSServers%.
/dnstraceroute.
py-s8.
8.
8.
8ripe.
netdnstraceroute.
pyDNS:8.
8.
8.
8:53,hostname:ripe.
net,rdatatype:A1192.
168.
0.
1(192.
168.
0.
1)3.
912ms2*3192.
168.
10.
105(192.
168.
10.
105)15.
792ms4172.
17.
2.
1(172.
17.
2.
1)17.
063ms5172.
17.
2.
9(172.
17.
2.
9)11.
245ms6172.
19.
18.
5(172.
19.
18.
5)24.
862ms7172.
19.
17.
2(172.
19.
17.
2)18.
972ms810.
201.
177.
41(10.
201.
177.
41)13.
261ms910.
10.
53.
190(10.
10.
53.
190)14.
240ms10185.
100.
209.
117(185.
100.
209.
117)176.
592ms11*12de-cix.
fra.
google.
com(80.
81.
192.
108)152.
757ms13108.
170.
251.
193(108.
170.
251.
193)90.
347ms14google-public-dns-a.
google.
com(8.
8.
8.
8)185.
401ms%.
/dnstraceroute.
py-s8.
8.
8.
8twitter.
comdnstraceroute.
pyDNS:8.
8.
8.
8:53,hostname:twitter.
com,rdatatype:A1192.
168.
0.
1(192.
168.
0.
1)3.
160ms2*3192.
168.
10.
105(192.
168.
10.
105)5.
985ms4172.
17.
2.
1(172.
17.
2.
1)8.
535ms5172.
17.
2.
9(172.
17.
2.
9)20.
617ms6172.
19.
18.
5(172.
19.
18.
5)7.
823ms7*8*9google-public-dns-a.
google.
com(8.
8.
8.
8)19.
557msBacktothecaseofbrokenMXRoguenameserveralsoreturns"broken"responsesOnlytocertaintypeofqueries(e.
g.
MX)%dig-tMXtwitter.
com@8.
8.
8.
8;;Gotbadpacket:badlabeltype45bytes40108180000100010000000007747769twi7474657203636f6d00000c0001c00c00tter.
com.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
0c000100000379000341414100.
.
.
.
.
.
y.
.
AAA.
Lookingatpacketsagain.
.
.
ResponsetoMXrequestismalformedServerrespondedwithPTRresponseRDLENGTHis3butRDATAfieldcontains4bytesAdditionalbytewasalwaysNULLSeemslikeabugincodeQueriedtop10,000domainnames[1],received139brokenresponses[2]UncoveringtherougeresolveraddressQueryTXTrecordfrommaxmind.
test-ipv6.
comIttellsyouthepublicaddressofyourresolverTheaddressshouldbelongtoGoogle(AS15169)AnythingelsemeansMITMUsingRIPEAtlastoseeifthisisaregularpractice%dig+short-tTXTmaxmind.
test-ipv6.
com@8.
8.
4.
4"ip='74.
125.
74.
14'as='15169'isp='Google'country='FI'"IsitjustmeLet'saskRIPEAtlas500Probesworldwide-484Replied(DNS/UDP/IPv4)475Good(Req.
fromGoogleaddressspace)~98%9Bad(Req.
fromnon-Googleaddressspace)~2%Same500probes-484Replied(DNS/TCP/IPv4)479Good~99%5Bad~1%ThelogicbehindDNStrafficredirectionWhatisthemotivationTherearemainlytworeasons:1.
Privacyprotection(TheGood)Preventsendingrequesttousehaveyourend-pointIPaddressasitssourceaddressFilteroutmalwareslookingfortheirC&C2.
DNSbasedserviceredirection(TheEvil)RestrictyouraccessRedirectyourtrafficCountermeasuresForcelocalresolvertouseTCPDNSCrypt(dnscrypt.
org)OpenDNSsupportsit,desktopclientsavailableDNSoverTLS/DTLS(RFC7858and8094)DNSPrivacyProject(dnsprivacy.
org)offerstutorials,tools,recommendationsandtestserversDNSSECFromtop100domainnamesonly2ofthemaresigned[3]WhatiftheroguenameserverdoesnotvalidateDNSSECFinalwordsDon'ttrustapublicDNSresolver,useyourownThereain'tnosuchthingasafreelunch(TANSTAAFL)Stubresolversareeasytosetupanduse(e.
g.
Stubby)Don'ttrustyourupstream,encryptasmuchaspossibleDNScontainsimportantinformationAsperRFC7258:"PervasiveMonitoringIsanAttack"Toolsofthetradednsping,dnstracerouteanddnsevalarepartof"dnsdiagtoolkit"onGitHub[4]LookingforfeedbackandideasfromcommunityCombiningwithothertools(e.
g.
RIPEAtlas)toperformmorecomplexbehavioranalysisSuggestion:dnstracerouteinRIPEAtlasprobesQuestionsResources[1]https://github.
com/opendns/public-domain-lists[2]https://gist.
github.
com/farrokhi/0b56ae06813391be9164[3]https://gist.
github.
com/farrokhi/1d9de9df5877aaf9c42fc14412a4b0f8[4]https://github.
com/farrokhi/dnsdiagAlsomyarticlesonRIPELabsdiscussionthesameissue:https://labs.
ripe.
net/Members/babak_farrokhi
zji怎么样?zji是一家老牌国人主机商家,公司开办在香港,这个平台主要销售独立服务器业务,和hostkvm是同一样,两个平台销售的产品类别不一平,商家的技术非常不错,机器非常稳定。昨天收到商家的优惠推送,目前针对香港邦联四型推出了65折优惠BGP线路服务器,性价比非常不错,有需要香港独立服务器的朋友可以入手,非常适合做站。zji优惠码:月付/年付优惠码:zji 物理服务器/VDS/虚拟主机空间订...
弘速云怎么样?弘速云是创建于2021年的品牌,运营该品牌的公司HOSU LIMITED(中文名称弘速科技有限公司)公司成立于2021年国内公司注册于2019年。HOSU LIMITED主要从事出售香港vps、美国VPS、香港独立服务器、香港站群服务器等,目前在售VPS线路有CN2+BGP、CN2 GIA,该公司旗下产品均采用KVM虚拟化架构。可联系商家代安装iso系统。点击进入:弘速云官方网站地址...
百星数据(baixidc),2012年开始运作至今,主要提供境外自营云服务器和独立服务器出租业务,根据网络线路的不同划分为:美国cera 9929、美国cn2 gia、香港cn2 gia、韩国cn2 gia、日本cn2 gia等云服务器及物理服务器业务。目前,百星数据 推出的日本、韩国、香港cn2 gia云服务器,2核2G/40G/5M带宽低至60元/月,600元/年。百星数据优惠码:优惠码:30...
traceroute为你推荐
用户重庆2011年停止接单产品支持ipad支持ipadCTiosiphone连不上wifi苹果手机无法连接wifi是什么原因iexplore.exe应用程序错误iexplore.exe---应用程序错误.是什么意思?tcpip上的netbios怎么启用TCP/IP上的NetBIOSx-router设置路由器是我的上网设置是x怎么弄x-routerx-0.4x等于多少?
美国虚拟主机 国外vps租用 域名备案批量查询 国外免费域名网站 新网域名解析 企业主机 fastdomain 百度云100as 韩国空间 mediafire 流媒体服务器 php主机 42u标准机柜尺寸 iis安装教程 debian源 免费smtp服务器 创梦 anylink 刀片服务器的优势 静态空间 更多